As we sit at this point of impasse in Northern Ireland, once more the two leading parties at the Assembly refuse to budge.They get their bullish hard masks on to play the wee game for a further round of talks.
The public look on and the majority of reasonable everyday folk shake their heads
like cows in the field, unable to do or say anything that will move things along.
But if the public really new the fact of the matter how would they feel ? Would they believe it
and would it make many of them wind there necks in?
How can I put this simply, in a way that is easy to digest? Well, here goes.
As a community in Northern Ireland we share space with each other. Due to an inherited and agreed sense of difference we have been in conflict for hundreds of years with one layer of confusion upon another.
Much of what we believe in, at its core, is not true. Did you hear that? Much of what we have accepted about ourselves is a lie, an untruth, a mental toxin that keeps us apart.
At its most simple we see ourselves as either Irish or British. A broad brush but simplistic version of our shared history. It sets most of the detail and historic narrative aside and brings the story down to a level of picking two football teams. Even primary school children would grasp that concept.
In other words it reveals the nub of the problem in 2017. It’s all about land, domination, winning and who can stick the most goals in the net (YES!).
Let’s go back to the beginning and talk about the island we live on. We call it Ireland now but it had no name then, around 8,000 BC at the end of the Ice Age. Around that time people came to live on an island (part of a group of related islands) off the shores of Europe.
No one owned this island and the first people to arrive lived and moved about as hunter gatherers. What language did they speak? No one knows but some of the names for our rivers and mountains come from that time.
Over time, around 4,000 BC, other people came bringing farming skills, introducing ways of living in a more settled way, cultivating fields, introducing field walls, land divisions, seasonal rituals and a greater sense of ownership. A sense of hierarchy that has not really changed.
Now if we jump quite far ahead to 700 AD (the time of the rath) this land dependant society had evolved into a much more distinct entity with a language (sounding different throughout the island) with the ordinary people looking for leadership from their local kings (an rí).
If we look at the Annals of the Four Masters we can see that, even in the early Christian era, Ireland was a deeply troubled place with war as a constant fixture in the seasonal calendar. If you think we only recently have had “The Troubles” I suggest you should check out early Irish history, when jealousy, war, death, betrayal, destruction and enslavement was, very much, part of the fabric of society.
If we regard early Ireland then as divided into 5 divisions, centred on the Hill of Uisneach (ISHNAK) (not to be confused with Tara /Teamhair) with MIDE or Meath at its centre, some esoteric experts regard the North, even then as the area with a character given over to war.
Different waves of people continued to come to dominate the Island of Ireland. It was always about land, money and the potential to make money. Rarely about religion. Religion was an easy way to divide folk.
So with the coming of the Vikings around 795 AD the early Irish Church (often physically fighting amongst itself) was looted for gold, for money, for power, by people who were also great traders and the city builders of Dublin, Carlingford, Wexford, Limerick and others, giving the modern name of Ulaid-Ster to old Ulaid to give us Ulster.
Following the Vikings about 300 years later came the Normans (Northmen/Viking mercenaries who had settled in this area of Northern France) via Wales, bringing with them the language of the court, French. Their echo can still be found around the old Dublin Pale with names like De Lacy, Fitzgerald, Fitzgibbon, Fitzhenry and Fitzherbert. (There are still some “Herberts” to be found to this day, in politics).
Now the Vikings, (with Irish mercenaries) supposedly defeated by Brian Boru (and an army full of Viking mercenaries), didn’t leave Ireland. Just like the Normans, they became quite a well heeled part of Irish society.
“They didn’t go away you know.”
If we rush on ahead in time to the conflicts between Ireland and the court of King Henry the 8th we encounter what seems to be a religious conflict. But it’s really more about access to monastic land and wealth and a war chest, to go fight the Spanish.
Can you see a theme developing here?
The Nine Years War in Ireland left the North of Ireland deeply scared and divided by the genocide the “Essex Strategy” and the actions of Queen Elizabeth the 1st. The events of 1603 have never been fully addressed and the many locals who died from the sword and a man made famine have yet to be accounted for.
These events have never really reached the consciousness of the side of our community that sees itself as British due to lack of education. Like the Armenian massacres in Turkey, at the beginning of its creation as a state, these events would be a hard thing to accept.
Yet the unaddressed genocide at the end of the Nine Years War has effectively contaminated the foundations of the modern 6 County Ulster by never being discussed by young people then or now.
I won’t go much further, but I just want to say this. That with the coming of the Ulster Plantation the North of Ireland was already, very much, a collection of “mixed stock”, not even accounting for the thousands upon thousands of European, Scandinavian, Arctic and some African slaves, brought to Ireland from early times.
From the beginnings of the Plantation on, it is easy to see that the Irish found love and companionship with the Scottish, the English, the Reiver (what’s a Reiver now?), the Huguenot, the Chinese and more recently, the African, the Polish and more. The process is ongoing.
You cannot stop Love. it moves like clean water through the cracks of immoveable rock.
The truth is that there is undeniable evidence that the story our politicians give us and the historical realty, created by love and attraction are at odds with each other.
But can you, as an individual, accept the fact of the matter. For the fact of the matter is that we are a ragbag mixture of genetic and cultural influences, living on an island, cajoled by a political elite who want to shoe horn us into an imagined view of either being merely Irish or merely British, like factory owners. They have to turn us into a product in a box to put on shelves to maintain their reason for being.
The fact of the matter is that there is another truth out there about ourselves. Waiting to be discovered. It sits amongst us like an old friend. We have so much to offer each other if we can only see who we really are. As diverse and mongrel as the wild flowers in the fields and pastureland, once more being given space to grow along our roadsides and on the edge of things.
One day I hope we will accept this and evolve our ancient truth into something wonderful.
Great piece Randall. Well said indeed.
William Crawley done an excellent show called Imagining Ulster about the mix of people that have been moving across these islands as you say since prehistoric times.
Another to add to your list could be the Gallowglasses who were Scottish mercanaires who took much of their land by force as payment for their services. Many who would consider themselves pure Irish would be shocked to find that this is where they descend from. McCallion and McSorley are two common Gallowglasse names.
We are all mongrels at the end of the day. I myself am a mix of French Hugonaughts, Scottish border reivers and Spainish.
Funny old world.
Thanks Scott. Yes, the Gallowglasses. I omitted those as I was trying to keep the piece short.
Many thanks for your reply. That was very kind of you. In case you are interested I put up daily posts of songs and poems at http://www.randallstephenhall.com
It is good of Jude to post these pieces on his website and I really appreciate the comments. It’s not quite human conversation but i suppose it all helps.
Glad to encounter another mongrel from the fields.
Go raibh maith agat. Thanks.
Stiofán
If you’re going to San Francisco ……………….
and?
Ah Fiosrach and Paddy Maguire (once the king of Fermanagh). One cynical old Ostrich and one Ostrich with no egg to share if “and” is the best you can come up with.
I’d rather be a hippy than a couch potato Nationalist.
Hope you enjoy your tea youse boys.
But the fact you have responded from your slumbers speaks volumes about your unaddressed angst.
“PEACE MAN” to the pair of you.
The public look on and the majority of reasonable folk shake their heads. It may have passed you by, a Stiofain, but the two major parties have been elected by ‘reasonable folk’.
Now hang on a moment .If you go back in time to anywhere there was war, warring tribes and division…not just the island of Ireland ,or what is known now as Great Britain ,but right across Europe and the world ….everywhere.People fought and killed each other .They’re still killing each other . have you seen the news recently.?
Things change but they do not change too much.There once was a mighty Roman Empire and there once was a British Empire. They came and they went and they changed the landscape a little .Come to that there once was an America, only a matter of a few hundred years ago , consisting of a variety of native tribes with their own cultures, which delighted in their own religions and slavery, until the Europeans arrived and brought in their own brand and ideas of slavery and a variety of diseases that decimated the place .
Things change all the time , slowly , usually through expansion, greed adventurism and theft.What we have at this present moment in timein little Norneverland , is an impasse provided entirely by the DUP with a long list of scandals and scandalous behaviour over this past ten or more years.. There are no ifs and there are no buts about any of that. The DUP has refused to embrace any sense equality and they have been pulled on it after having had a nice long run at what can only be described as foolish ,boorish behaviour ending in a scandal to beat all financial scandals.Has everyone forgotten already? .We’re talking foolishness and criminality for starters. They did it all by themselves and have no one else to blame .They were even given a final chance and they threw it all away.
Let’s get down to brass tacks.Politics are about making deals and they only work when you actually stick to a deal you’ve made.If the DUP cannot be true to a deal that they have already made….and look around for scapegoats all they like , they alone have been pulled up on it….. Then how can anyone expect to be able to work with them? Politics are the art of the possible …not the impossible.Do they understand what cutting a deal actually means? That election was about this issue alone ,so unless they can learn very quickly how to do politics , they’ve just had their last chance at the Last Chance Saloon.
I’ve bookmarked this for posterity, puts it all into perspective’ impressive writing,
well said Paddykool
Hi Paddy Kool. Thanks for the effort. Like a fine wine I’ll look forward to reading it.
Sure debate isn’t a bad thing.
Thanks for going the extra mile.
Go raibh maith gat.
Hi Fiosrach. you are entitled to your pinion and I appreciate your feedback. Go raibh maith gat.
Sorry if I seemed a bit reactive.
Good luck.