A weighted border poll?



I nearly crashed my car this afternoon but I have only my own naivety to blame for it.  When I started the car the radio was on Raidio Uladh/Radio Ulster’s Talkback and Crawley was giving people an opportunity to say what they understood by the word ‘majority’ in the Good Friday Agreement. Ian Paisley, keen I suppose to have people talk about him for other reasons than breaking parliamentary rules and going off on family holidays funded by shady governments,  has come up with the wheeze that ‘majority’ simply must mean ‘weighted majority’ or ‘super majority’.  In other words, 50%+1?  ‘No thanks” says Ian.


Mind you, I shouldn’t have been so shocked. The leader of the DUP, Jeffrey Donaldson,  has shown that he’s not wild about 50% + either:  Sinn Féin may have the largest party, but the DUP will do all it can to stop Michelle O’Neill assuming the title First Minister. And the thing it does best is sit on its hands. Or rather, sit on one hand and use the other to receive a hefty salary for not doing what it was elected to do.  If forming an Executive involves making Michelle O’Neill Numero Uno, Jeffrey and his DUP mates are not even a teensy bit keen on such an occurrence.


Professor Colin Harvey was on Talkback, and said it was “crystal clear” what ‘majority’ meant in the Good Friday Agreement. Or in any other agreement, Colin. Or in the English language. People agree to things and then go back on their word, like Boris Johnson saying he’d never consent to a border in the Irish Sea. Ian Paisley Senior guldered ‘Never, Never, Never, Never!’  but then did the Free Presbyterian  Flip and jogged. through his lap of honour (OK, lap of vanity, then) for the next year or so, with Martin McGuinness as smiling Deputy First Minister.


Colin Harvey, I think it was, made the clear distinction on Talkback between what the document the Good Friday Agreement said legally, and what one might like to happen politically.  Legally, a border poll that gave its assent of 50% + 1; politically, the republican majority should do all possible to let  those opposed to a united Ireland feel as much at home in a new Ireland as any of those who have been uber-keen on seeing their country reunited at last.


A new Ireland that came into being with the goodwill of unionism would be a prize worth  striving for; but talk of a weighted majority is delusional horse-feathers,  even coming from the mouth of Ian Paisley. If the DUP plan is to muster behind what it sees as a chink in the Good Friday Agreement, the sensible advice coming from nationalism should be “Don’t even think about it, Ian old sausage’.


7 Responses to A weighted border poll?

  1. James Hunter May 23, 2023 at 2:01 pm #

    Very good Jude

  2. Martin ONeill May 23, 2023 at 3:31 pm #

    When’s a majority not a majority? When Ian Og says so….

  3. Margaret May 23, 2023 at 6:38 pm #

    Spot on Jude as usual.

  4. Peter May 23, 2023 at 6:49 pm #

    Great Jude, heard the conversation myself today!

  5. Boondock May 23, 2023 at 9:29 pm #

    Peter Shirliow was saying something similar last night on UTV. A border poll won’t happen unless nationalist parties can hit 50.1%. it’s just the latest game to deny democracy. SF and SDLP could be on 49% and the combined unionist vote could be 20% and it wouldn’t be enough for a referendum as these guys just assume all the others must be closet unionists. This is why the Alliance party and Greens are going to be coming under more and more pressure