Mary McAleese and the Limits of Consent – by Peter Irvine

 
In recent days, Mary McAleese has renewed her argument that infant baptism violates children’s human rights, amid publicity surrounding her new book, The Baptism Bluff. Her objection is not to the spiritual effects of baptism itself, but to the Catholic Church’s practice of enrolling infants as lifelong members, subject to obligations they never personally consented to.
 
Of course, infants cannot consent to baptism. Neither can they consent to the language they are raised speaking, where they grow up, which school they attend or the moral convictions their parents seek to instil in them. Parents necessarily make decisions on behalf of children who are incapable of making them themselves.
 
Religious upbringing is no exception. Catholic and Protestant parents alike have traditionally regarded passing on their faith as a responsibility, not a violation of their children’s rights.
 
There is also an important distinction between the Catholic Church continuing to recognise someone as baptised and that person being compelled to practise Catholicism. An adult is perfectly capable of rejecting the faith in which they were raised, whatever the Church’s canonical understanding of their membership.
 
This controversy comes amid an increasingly expansive discussion of consent in Irish society. In October, the Dublin Rape Crisis Centre withdrew an advertisement encouraging grandparents to respect their grandchildren’s wishes regarding hugs, following considerable public criticism.
 
Nobody seriously disputes that children should be protected from inappropriate physical contact. Yet the suggestion that grandparents ought to seek permission before embracing their own grandchildren illustrates how the language of consent is increasingly being applied to even the most ordinary expressions of familial affection.
 
There is, however, a more fundamental question concerning McAleese’s understanding of children’s rights.
 
In 2018, she enthusiastically supported repealing the Eighth Amendment, which she herself had voted in favour of in 1983, later declaring that she had voted Yes to repeal with a “heart and a half”.
 
From a pro-life perspective, the contrast is striking. McAleese regards the enrolment of an infant in a religious institution without consent as a serious human-rights concern, yet supported removing constitutional protection for the unborn child’s right to life.
 
Supporters of repeal will naturally invoke the bodily autonomy of pregnant women. That is a separate moral argument, but it does not make the contrast any less worthy of examination.
 
A child’s freedom of conscience deserves protection, particularly as they mature and develop their own convictions. But that freedom need not require parents to abandon the religious traditions they hope to pass on.
 
It is a peculiar understanding of children’s rights which treats baptism as an unacceptable imposition while taking such a different position on the protection of life before birth. After all, neither the newly baptised infant nor the unborn child possesses the capacity to consent.
 

6 Responses to Mary McAleese and the Limits of Consent – by Peter Irvine

  1. Another Jude November 4, 2026 at 6:04 pm #

    Anyone who pays any heed to anything Mary says needs to get out more.

  2. Joe McVeigh November 4, 2026 at 8:00 pm #

    I agree with you Peter. Mary has a weird outlook on life and the Christian life which is inspired by the |Holy Spirit.. Christian parents have responsibilities to make choices for the spiritual well-being of their children. So too Hindu parents and Muslim parents.

  3. Peter November 5, 2026 at 12:22 pm #

    Mary McAleese has an interesting viewpoint on infant baptism, putting her in agreement with some smaller Protestant denominations which believe in adult baptism. The issue of consent can be introduced as the child grows older. Children are now given the choice to opt in/opt out of First Communion and Confirmation.

    On the subject of baptism – the Catholic Church recently released figures showing a sharp drop in the number of baptisms in all dioceses across the country in the 10 years to 2025. Catholic baptisms in the Dublin diocese dropped 40%. Down & Connor diocese which includes Belfast saw a drop of 37.9% and Derry diocese saw 26% fewer baptisms. The Iona Institute attributes about 60% of the drop to the falling birth rate, with the rest being explained by secularisation. Could there be other factors north of the border?

  4. Paul G Shevlin November 5, 2026 at 1:49 pm #

    As per today’s Irish Independent. Fr Dougal McAleese “Well, you know Ted the way God made us all, right? And he’s looking down at us from heaven and everything? And then his son came down and saved everyone and all that. And when we die we’re all going to go to heaven? Well, that’s the bit I have trouble with.”

  5. Another Jude November 6, 2026 at 3:04 am #

    Mary seems to be advocating a policy of MIHA. Make Ireland Heathen Again.

  6. John November 9, 2026 at 8:13 am #

    Letter from today’s Irish Times, quoted in full below. Turns out Dr Mary McAleese is absolutely right, you cannot leave an organisation that you never consented to joining in the first place.

    Sir, – I don’t blame my parents for baptising me into the Catholic Church back in 1972. It was the done thing. Not helped by being told if a child was not baptised and “something happened them”, then the child could end up in limbo. How frightening.

    But as much as my parents conformed to Baptism, my First Communion and Confirmation, we were not a particularly religious family.

    I moved from Catholic school to an inter denominational school in the 1980s and was so interested hearing about other people’s religions and those who had no religious beliefs at all.

    In my late 30s I wrote to my local diocese to register my defection from the Catholic Church but was too late. I was told it was impossible. I had missed the boat (presumably there were quite a few of us trying to jump off the boat at that time so the defection gangplank was removed). Once a member always a member even though there was no choice on my part to sign up in the first place.

    I did not baptise my children. I could not in good conscience sign them up to the club I was in and wanted out of.

    I remember my Dad asking me would I not just do it, sure what was the harm either way? And I explained that I thought there was harm in it. Organised religion has caused a lot of harm and I’d leave it up to my kids to decide their philosophical/religious beliefs after they’d lived a little, met different people, read and thought a lot about it. They would have that choice.

    Maybe we all need to think about the consequences of Baptism rather than thinking of it as a tradition, think of it as signing your child up to a club they did not choose to be in and one they cannot ever leave.

    Thank you Mary McAleese once again for speaking out. – Yours…..

Leave a Reply