
By now the world has witnessed the horrific footage of the verbal bile and abuse which Fr. Gary Donegan experienced on Saturday, led by none other than dissident republicanism’s very own Colonel Custer – Damian ‘Dee’ Fennell. Everyone I have spoken to has said how they feel shocked and outraged at this episode, culminating in a public reaction far worse than anything ever produced before by GARC members in all their prior controversies.
Fennell, who recently failed in having his ongoing prosecution nullified, for minutes (not seconds) looked as though he was ready to punch the well-respected local Clergyman after a dispute regarding the recent deal on parades. Surrounded by a mob of dissident protestors, he confronted Fr. Gary in a way which may raise eyebrows when his current gagging order, accepted from a British court, is evaluated in due course. It certainly seemed to me and anyone who watched that footage as though he instigated the episode and was the clear ring-leader of a less-than-amicable gathering of hostile locals and some disgruntled people who aren’t even from North Belfast, never mind Ardoyne.
I admire that brave priest: he stood his ground against that ‘rant’ (to be polite) and deserves the title of Reverend for the patience he displayed, because if it had been me I would have involved the police and held him to account legally for his behaviour. However, it makes you wonder what world Dee and his followers are living in that they think it acceptable and right to speak to other human beings like that, never mind a respected local cleric who is well regarded by the vast majority of Ardoyne and Greater Belfast. I know GARC complain about receiving no real funding from the state they so detest but would manners have cost you a thing?
When any priest comes to my house, he usually gets a cup of tea and a friendly chat about how things are in the community and parish. But something tells me there is a lot more behind this, an underlying desire for a publicity stunt, which has backfired tremendously on Fennell and his followers.
Recently, he was involved in establishing a “blood nationalist” dissident fringe party, ‘Saoradh’, which claims it has no interest in contesting elections – yet Fennell himself stood as a candidate in local government elections (albeit on a host of Westminster & Assembly issues) not so long ago. Of course, he was opposed in that election by the other dissident candidate and GARC affiliate, RNU’s Sammy Cusick. Tellingly, Saoradh and their party conference, if you would call it that, seemed more like a character assassination of Gerry Adams, than a discussion about policy and real issues. Attended by some of the proverbial ‘big whigs’ of the dissident splinter cells, it must have been an emotive time for the nay-sayer camp given it was so under subscribed.
Yes, the timing of all of this has been a political stalling tactic on the part GARC, who, fearing that they will lose their raison d’etre now that an agreement has been reached on the parading and Twaddell camp issue, let out an outburst of slow but sure irrelevance. Indeed, (and I write based on anecdotal evidence) anyone who challenges GARC at all tends to come up against a torrent of highly personal abuse and vilification of the most ugly kind – never proper discussion and debate on policy, ideas or realistic alternatives. They attack people with rhetoric and insults which even the most bitter loyalist would not have peddled. Notice, pointedly, how there is a clear lack of young people involved in their activities – why so? Because the youth can’t stand the sort of tense atmosphere which GARC want to regress us all back to. In a nutshell, they make the Drumcree stand-off seem as friendly as Strictly Come Dancing, and young people are simply not going to mortgage their futures voting for those who romanticise war as the first option and not the last. We are never going back to that!
But let’s be clear, this whole episode had nothing to do whatsoever with the content of the parading deal – GARC were always going to wholeheartedly oppose any sort of agreement at all, regardless of terms and conditions. From the day and hour GARC was formed they have been involved in a perceived coup d’etat for who apparently represents the good people of Ardoyne – the will of the mob or the leaders you elect to govern? They got their proverbial answer at the Council ballot box and now think they can throw their toys out of the metaphorical pram because they can’t stand the response. What exactly do they stand for, other than opposing all measures and attempts to bring the two communities together on areas of mutual benefit and reconciliation as a society?
In the wake of what happened in Ardoyne, including journalists being issued with death-threats and other betrayals of the community best interest, you should make your voice heard to your elected representatives and tell them unequivocally that you want regulation introduced to fine those who act against local neighbourhoods in such a disgraceful way. Your houses, spaces and neighbourhoods are being devalued financially on the property market over this sort of behaviour, so it impacts all of us and we all need to make the solution our business. Let your policy-makers know, via email or letter, that if the GARCs in our midst cannot respect other people with their conduct, then they can do so with their bank accounts. If these are the political geniuses who intend to liberate and emancipate the Irish nation, then most of north Belfast will be putting in for asylum!

let’s hope they or their families are not in need of a priest for a very long time.
Excellent balanced piece – Well said Donal Lavery.
These schoolyard Bullies must always be stood up to!
I hold no brief for Dee Fennel or Farc, sorry GARC. If the idiots in Twadell Avenue have finally decided to pack up and leave, then one parade by them is probably a price worth paying, in spite of the alleged involvement of a Shankill butcher. And the contrast between the quiet dignity of the elderly priest and the oafishness of DM, – sorry DF, -could hardly be more telling. But the whole episode demonstrates that there is a constituency that, in terms of equality and subsistence, have been left behind by the GFA – which agreement indeed has not been delivered on. Catholics with knighthoods in the judiciary mean little to them. How long must we wait for an Irish language act, how many times must the nationalist community be insulted by Philistines like Campbell, Weir and McIlveen? And while Fennel’s oafish behaviour is certainly unbecoming, I prefer to reserve the term “horrific footage” to the bombing of Gaza or Aleppo, beheading of victims by ISIS or the shooting of black people by white cops. Let’s keep a sense of proportion.
Once a cleric makes a public political statement he leaves himself open to criticism of his position. Whether or not he is a cleric or not is irrelevant. When he enters a political dogfight he may get bitten. If he feels the need to provide political leadership let him stand for election. He may be the kindest, most considerate, most conscientious cleric in the world but I think he has taken it a bit too far when he sides with the Orange bully boys against his own community. They have no right to walk where they are not wanted. I would have let them rot at Twaddell (all 3 of them) costing £24000 per week. Could you see them being led up the road with a Catholic priest at their head to ensure their safety? Drumcree is still costing £1000s and this was the biggest embarrassment at Twaddell. Who would have been happiest to see it settled – apart from the outreachers? How many times will these people have to be spat upon before they see how futile it is to try to reconcile with racist reactionaries? Of course if you know and accept your place in the colonial hierarchy you have no problem. Get up of your knees!
The people of Ardoyne are ‘up off their knees’, way above the likes of Fennell and his thugs who are quite simply down in the gutter.
Ardoyne rejected Fennell and his backward brand of politics at the ballot box, he should accept it and sling his hook.
Fennell is the republican version of Willie Frazer a total embarrassment to his community.
60 people if that at his protest and he claims to represent the majority of people of Ardoyne! Methinks Dee reality issues.
The only difference between Fiosrach and those who spit upon the so called ‘outreachers’ is – none. Fiosrach is not only a spitter he’s (she’s) a spewer. How can anyone refer to Orange bully boys and defend the position of a pack, chanting their bile so as to intimidate another, whether he is a priest or not, the intention was to intimidate and that’s the bread and butter of bullyboys. Was FIOSRACH up the road – was he chanting – or did he simply stand back and let others do the dirty work. I suspect the second to be the case it usually is with most paper revolutionaries and Wannabees, stand back and let the others do the dirty work. Watch the videos of the incident closely and see who the quietist are and then look at the smugness on their faces. Someone used this quote from Heany’s, ‘The Cure at Troy’, the other day, not quite sure who it was or if it referred to this incident or not – if it didn’t it should.
People so staunch and true shinning with self-regard like polished stones
And their whole life spent admiring themselves
Pity it all backfired
I have been spat upon and I don’t like it especially by foreigners who are basically unwanted guests in my country. I don’t care if only one person protests at this coat-trailing arrogant swaggering gang of anti Catholic,anti Irish bullies. Some people in this country don’t know when they are being made fools of. You outreach if you want. Let your grandchildren outreach. These people do not want your outreaching. They had supremacy and fear they have lost it. They are an embarrassment to the unionist community but at least they have the courage to stand up for what they believe in. Get up off your knees.
Fennell is no Custer.At least the last stand Custer took placed him in extreme danger.Fennell slabbers knowing that he will never be in any physical danger,unlike the many SF reps who lost their lives for making a stand.
Donal – looks like nobody else is going to suggest your objections to a priest being shouted at are over – hyped.
So the task falls to me, though I hold no torch for GARC.
As you wrote (with reference to GARC)
“They attack people with rhetoric and insults . . .
there is a clear lack of young people involved in their activities – why so?
In a nutshell, they make the Drumcree stand-off seem as friendly as Strictly Come Dancing”,
Shouting at, ranting and raving at, screaming at, a priest in broad daylight on camera (we’ve all seen the video) falls far short of burning the Quinn children to death in their beds at 4.30 am under cover of darkness. As the Orange Order did at Drumcree.
How can you compare a priest’s momentary discomfort when faced with people’s anger (whether justified or not) to a mother’s life-long sorrow after her sons were burned alive in their beds?
Have you seen this video?
Hardly the stuff to have Dee Fennell shaking in his shoes, but then you know that already.
Just as you know your introductory passage is hardly the whole truth or even a grain, thankfully we don’t have a priest in the room.
I was standing feet away from Dee Fennell when Fr Donegan crossed the road to play his little’ woe is me’ scene for the media.
The priest was challenged and he deserved to be challenged any right thinking person with a grain of integrity and intelligence would demanded to know why Donegan was promoting a backward deal….and before the audience starts yelling….you’re not from Ardoyne, your deal makers, the ones who signed off on your behalf weren’t from Ardoyne.
Sixty people on the Ardoyne Road for those with half a clue was the number allocated by the Commission in response to the Sinn Fein /UVF deal.
Dee Fennell cannot be accountable for the fact Fr Donegan could not sell the back door deal,to a front door audience or even formulate a case.
I wonder how someone like Mr Collins or rather Mr Lavery would feel if this wee piece of treachery was done behind their backs and the Orange Order played it’s little Famine Song on a road near you.
I come from era, when people like Dee Fennell were commended for their stance on oppression…and before we hear yells….of bad old days, resistance to injustice doesn’t come with a sale by date for some,;which is why Dee Fennell the GARC representative stood his ground and articulated his case and the local MLA Gerry Kelly took to his heels and ran.
Dear oh dear Jude Collins, the once tormentor of the Provos now their forever friend removed my piece from here…..oops!!! Or was it Donal.
Dee Fennell has more courage, resistance and backbone than your likes if you lived your life twice over and that’s why Judas you removed my piece.
Imagine you, who never threw a stone let alone a dirty look writing pieces on a man who is part of a resistance community, but then resistance isn’t your bag Collins your collaboration and let’s go along with anything all the way.
Was it the bit about Kellly running or was it the bit about little Fr Donegan staging his own little ‘pity me’ that put you off your corn flakes? A political writer Collins, you wouldn’t know real politics if they followed you about shouting vote, vote, vote for big Gerry.
Ardoyne was treachery to the those people, and it was signed up to by the Provos and the UVF and then rolled out by their wee community puppets like Donegan and co.
There were 400 armed police standing behind Donegan when he stood trance like in response to an articulated challenge, and yet with them odds you manage to contrive this piece of intimidation tat.
Your or ‘Donal’ didn’t seem to make too much about the fact the commission only allowed 60 people on that road to face a ring steeled hostile atmosphere, but then why would you venture on the side of truth, because it has never got in the way of your pro ‘any’ establishment pieces before.
Remove this if you want, because just like another plaster idol of yours Gerry Kelly, when faced with anything you can’t manipulate or fabricate you run. Maidin Mhaith :))))
Um – Fionnuala – I’m sorry to hear you’re upset, but honestly, I had no hand, act or part in the ‘Fennell’s Last Stand’ piece – it is all Donal Lavery’s work, as is indicated. I’m just a host. If you or anyone else would like to put up a piece defending Dee Fennell, I’ll be happy to post it too. Providing its not libel or unadorned abuse. More than welcome.
Well then, I apologise and stand corrected Jude. I have never heard of Donal Lavery, but what I have heard time out of number is quite unrealistic takes on anyone or anything deemed anti status quo.
How could any open minded reporter weigh Ardoyne up and come up with Donal’s analysis.
The sixty protestors who stood shouting ‘walk of shame’ were ring fenced, be it media excluded by 400 hundred armed to the teeth members of the RUC. In reality terms intimidation is not the way to go especially given the fact, that the armed consensus overseers are outnumbering you on an 85:15 ratio and that’s not taking into account the police saturation in Ardoyne.
Apologies to you once more if I jumped the gun ( no intended pun) and yes I might considered a truthful, factual piece from my own personal perspective ….go raibh maith agat
I will await Fionnuala Perry’s ‘truthful, factual’ piece with interest should it ever appear because her utterances so far have been far from factual.
One question, which she may be able to answer, is how come there was no GARC protest at the previous two Orange Marches in the mornings in the area?
Not one turned up to protest so is it only certain Orange parades through the area that GARC are against? They appear to be only against those ones that give them a chance to jump up and down and create a media storm.
They called a protest the night before with roughly 200 people attended and half of them were from outside the area – great support they have from the people of Ardoyne!
Fionnuala and indeed GARC are more anti-SF than they are the Orange marches or the British presence in Ireland. That is a fact.
As far Gerry Kelly running away – don’t be silly woman. Gerry Kelly has faced down the might of the British state and all its surrogates and to think he would run from the likes of the rabble of visionless, leaderless, bully boys/girls that assembled on Saturday morning is frankly laughable.
Aine
I don’t speak for GARC, my piece if you go back and read it is about Saturday morning and yeah I’ll give you a factual piece on that.
I wouldn’t be too concerned where the people come from on the Friday night, because in our little stage managed protest on the Springfield Road, Sinn Fein ( who police it ) bussed their own supporters in from everywhere including Ardoyne.
Of course I’m anti Sinn Fein, I’m a life long Republican and given the fact that I was reared in a highly sectarian area I’m also anti Orange marches.
Why are you commenting on Kelly running away….where you there wee woman ?? We all faced down the might of the British State, whether you did or not is questionable, given the fact you shy away from using your full name therefore I’ve no clue who you are.
Unless your living under a stone, Gerry Kelly is a Stormont minister and part of the British establishment, who stood on Saturday surrounded by members of the RUC.
I’d say what you know about me or a lot of people there on Saturday or even the politics of this state would fit neatly onto the back of stamp…you’re the laugh here.
OK Fionnuala so you don’t speak for GARC but you attended and supported their protest so maybe you can answer the point about them not being against ALL Orange parades in the area as they only protest against selected ones.
What’s the big issue with my identity? So I don’t use my full name, its the points you are meant to address in a political debate, not the person.
I do know several of the people that attended the protest on Saturday as I live in North Belfast, I don’t know you – so what! Libelous comments? You’ll need to explain that one in greater detail to me. Anyways you have a nice weekend Fionnuala and try and get out a wee bit, it’s good for the head.
I’ll also be putting a letter in the Irish news Aine…feel very free to come in and answer that, but then you can’t the Irish News won’t run with half a name…pity that :((((
Jude are you removing my comments, well if your are don’t just remove the ones that don’t suit remove them all!!
Commented on another blog in answer to Aine whoever and her libelous claims and for some reason just like this morning my comments are removed but no one else’s….I know maybe it’s Donal :))))
Fionnuala – if your comments didn’t show, it most certainly is due to cock-up and not conspiracy. If you have them in Word form or whatever, put them up again and I’ll make sure they show. Tá bron orm – apologies.
Fionnuala
The comments here are put up at a glacially slow pace. It is like trying to have a conversation by pigeon post.
I am not having a dig at Jude.
He has his own life to lead away from the keyboard of course, but it it can sometimes seem that ones carefully considered words of wisdom will never actually appear.
Yes you are having a dig at Jude, gio – who else? ‘Glacially slow pace’. Global warming must really be rapid down your way.
Jude
It’s not really a dig. I’m sure you are doing your best!
Didn’t suspect a conspiracy. Just thought if they were disappearing then the rest would be better removed.
The clue is “……… Own life to lead ……”