The BBC Book of The Week on Ra dio concerning the origins of The East India Company is a “Warts and All” account of its origins. Would that all BBC historical and current affairs programmes aspired to its standard. Robert Clive was born into the class that provided the Church of England with its Clergy, […]
Cops on the frontline: a letter to the Belfast Telegraph by Tom Cooper
November 13th 2019 Sir, I understand why Ruth Dudley Edwards liked Gerry Gregg’s sympathetic film on the RUC (10th November). It was propaganda. I have no problem with RUC personnel telling their stories. They are entitled to their memories, to feeling of triumph, tragedy and despair. I have a problem with this BBC programme as either a comprehensive view of the RUC, or as a comprehensive view from within the RUC. The technique of letting participants, retired RUC officers, tell their own story has merit, if the audience is given a sufficient variety of perspective. Instead, we were presented with political uniformity. The repeated claim that the RUC “didn’t start the fire”, the Troubles, was unquestioned. It is clearly mistaken. Was no retired member of the force capable of stepping outside the bounds of group allegiance to admit that the RUC, a sectarian force in a sectarian state, alienated the nationalist population? Was no former member of the RUC capable of reflection beyond barrack room loyalty? One participant said, “We were hated.” That was left unexplored. RUC personnel in collusion with loyalists received gestural treatment. The conviction of RUC officers Billy McCaughey and John Weir for killing Ahoghill chemist William Strathern served to allow programme participants to distance themselves from those who ‘sullied’ the RUC’s name. Had the programme interviewed John Weir, the audience would have been presented with evidence of collusion further up the ranks. Stathern’s actual killer, Robin Jackson, wasnot charged with that or with other loyalist paramilitary activity. Jackson had associations with security forces, including RUC Special Branch. McCaughey boasted that his RUC Special Patrol Group intimidated out a lone RomanCatholic who joined. He might have spoiled their pastime of harassing Catholics and of enabling loyalists to kill them. The uncritical reference to RUC Special Branch was equally unsurprising, given that the programme researcher served in that ‘force-within-a force’. It was asserted that Special Branch ran agents in both the IRA and in loyalist groups. In fact, Special Branch and British military intelligence ran loyalist groups against the IRA and against nationalist political leaders. Former CID detectives Johnston Browne and Alan Simpson have written critically about how Special Branch operated. They would have made for informative interviewees. Instead, we were given the corporate version of the RUC story. On that basis, can we expect a similar programme containing sympathetic interviews with former IRA volunteers? I won’t hold my breath. Yours sincerely Tom Cooper
Nelson: a suitable case for concern
Those of you who are of mature years like myself may remember a much-loved BBC radio soap called Mrs Dale’s Diary. Its central character, unsurprisingly, was Mrs Dale, and she more than once opened an episode of the soap with the words “I’m worried about [my husband] Jim”. Today, I find myself echoing Mrs D’s […]
How to use words so they damage an electoral candidate
I was listening to a brief part of the Nolan Show on BBC Raidio Uladh/Radio Ulster yesterday morning. Stephen Nolan, ably assisted by that regular voice, Thomas of North Belfast (or was it George from the Shankill – they interchange so smoothly) was once again presenting Sean Kelly and, by association, John Finucane, as the […]
Arlene and Nigel have it out
Arlene enters stage left, Nigel stage right. He immediately approaches her, looking very angry. Nigel: Have you seen the polls? Arlene: No, we use a good Fermanagh man for any plumbing problems. Nigel: God give me patience.. I’m talking about the polls in England. Opinion polls. Arlene: As far as I know, Boris is going to eat that Marxist-Mao-loving-Pol-Pot-follower Shinner-sympathiser Corbyn for breakfast. Which […]
Hillary Clinton and two under-wraps reports
As you probably know, Hillary Clinton in recent days has been landing body blows on Boris Johnson for suppressing a parliamentary report on Russia until after Britain has gone to the polls. Some leaks indicate that Russian multi-billionaires were shoveling money to Tory politicians. “Who do they think they are that they would keep information […]
Johnson’s promise: we’ll be really kind to soldiers. Like, really kind…
Is Boris Johnson an aberration, or does he present a picture of the normal British politician? Some of his fans would say the former, adding that there’s no one like Boris. Some of his critics would say the former, also saying there’s no one like Boris. Apart from Trump, of course. It seems to me […]
HOMILY AT FUNERAL OF FR DES WILSON (November 9, 2019) by Fr Joe McVeigh
A phobal Dé agus a chairde go léir, Tá muid bronach inniú. Tá ár gcara Des imithe ar shlí na Fírinne. It’s a fitting way to describe the death of our friend – a man whose whole life was committed to the Truth-speaking the truth and writing the truth. The Indian poet, Rabin-dranath Tagore once wrote: […]
Stephen Collins: the man who knows how stupid people are
Brendan O’Connor had his palm read on air last week. He was told he narrowly missed being a fascist leader. I wonder did Stephen Collins hear it. In an article written in The Irish Times last May about Ireland and the EU, he compares favourably the English Brexiteers to his fellow – countrymen and women. “A substantial […]
REMEMBER, REMEMBER THE NINTH OF NOVEMBER?
This is the season when the City of London annually celebrates in style the inauguration of its new Lord Mayor. It has done so for many centuries and pantomimes have instilled the legend of the thrice elected Dick Whittington in the minds of millions. I’m sure many hundreds of thousands of babies (including my grandson) […]
