
Derryman John Patton has lived in Scotland since 1971 where he was head teacher in two non-denominational schools. He was elected President of the Educational Institute of Scotland, one of a very small number of non-Scots and the only Irish person to do so. A committed credit union enthusiast from his Derry origins, he was the National Development Officer of the Scottish movement for seven years and frequently worked with ministers in the new Edinburgh Parliament.
“A Scottish Parliament- not an end; a means to greater ends”, Donald Dewar, Scotland’s First Minister, said when the present Scottish Parliament was established in 1999. He also quoted the dictum of his Welsh colleague, Ron Davis – “Devolution is a process and not an event”. Dewar had to fight hard within the new Blair administration to ensure that it kept its promise to the Scottish people since his enthusiasm for the project was not universally shared within the Party and was opposed by the Tories. The structure which emerged, with its mixture of first-past-the-post constituencies and 8 parliamentary regions where the electorate vote not for an individual but a political party, was an electoral contrivance, given the great dominance of Labour in Scotland, to ensure that the Nationalists would never have power. Or so it was thought.
In May 2007, the SNP, as the largest party, formed a minority Government and even in those constricting circumstances, its competence impressed observers and the electorate who re-elected Alex Salmond and his Party in 2011 with an overall majority and, crucially, with a mandate to seek a referendum on Scottish independence. The Campaign was launched by both sides, YES Scotland and Better Together in 2012; the difference in style and character was stark right from the start. The pro-Independence people formed a broad, rainbow coalition of support which embraced the wider community while Better Together produced an unlikely coalition of Labour, Tories and LibDems. YES looked to the future prospects of an independent Scotland where the people who live here would take the decisions which affect their everyday lives. Better Together countered with a series of negative scare stories in a campaign that was characterised through its disparate nature as cautious, confusing and hesitant. However, the polls gave them a comfortable lead up until a few weeks ago.
The YES Campaign has been vibrant and inclusive; groups such as Women for Independence, Teachers for Yes, Business Scotland, the National Collective – a forum of writers, musicians artists and people involved in the arts have held packed meetings in pubs, local halls and street corners. The Referendum has brought a good spirited engagement and animation to Scottish civic life that is unprecedented in a political campaign. International media are saluting it as an outstanding, mature model of the democratic process. There is little doubt that the poll on Thursday next will exceed 80%.
The Scottish people have become radical and restless; they have been given a vision of a positive future and they welcome it; the majority are unimpressed by the promises of a dated, political alliance; freshly politicised working people recognise that they have the intellectual capacity to make serious choices; they believe that the Tories have manipulated the financial crisis, caused by banks, to make austerity an ideology which will cut vital services, hammer the poor and is totally alien to Scottish values.
Scots are weary of being passengers on a voyage commanded by Westminster and now they want to be the captains in charge of their own destiny; they have glimpsed the possibility of radical change and are enthusiastic to see more; they know that Scotland is a wealthy country and now they want to create a wealthy and inclusive society. There is now full realisation that this may only be realised, achieved and implemented with Independence.
For the triumph of hope over fear, it has to be YES.

John , it is good to see a piece like yours ,argued with a degree of background knowledge and positivity. Most of us living in Ireland can have no real idea about the nuts and bolts of the Scottish experience .What we do know however is that Cameron’s Tories are as alien a species to most Scots as you could ever imagine .
The mystery is why anyone in Scotland would imagine that the Bullingdon Club background could ever translate into empathy with the Scottish workingman’s life. It’s a mystery to me , personally , why anyone who has an ordinary working life would ever want to vote for the conservatives in any form or stripe. I have to say though that most Unionists here in Northern Ireland probably would , just to spite themselves.The Scottish unionist and the Northern Irish unionist are two different beasts though.
I have to say, that Labour ,having stolen some of the Conservatives ‘ clothing some twenty years ago , have also become nothing more than Tory-Lites in the eyes of most working people. There’s a definite displacement there.What are we to make of career politicians ?
To see them descend en masse , for a last minute assault , to retain that old control speaks volumes. Panic in the air .I think the only thing that might stymie the “yes ” vote is the fear of the unknown. Scotland is in the lucky position that it is a rich country and can afford to take a shot in the dark. Cameron’s only argument at the moment is an emotional one . He ‘s arguing that he’ll be sad to lose his good friend. It looks a little like a love-lorn stalker though .It’s not a good look and a lot of people will scoff at his lack of stiff upper lip.It’s a wee bit too weepy for some . A bit like those old romantic “two- hankie movies” that the ladies used to talk about .The “weepies”.
Well as they say …he can dry his eyes .Nobody’s falling for that old last ditch emotional horseshit . He’s no Scarlett O’Hara and frankly nobody gives a damn about all that old fluff.There doesn’t have to be some big emotional breakdown. He can let his lover get on on with the rest of her life and raise his stoical chin and wish her well. England and Wales will live on and within a generation nobody’ll notice or remember anyway. There’s no need for a big sulking match either …y’know taking our ball back and all that childishness.. That really doesn’t have to be the case . There doesn’t have to be a Scottish border patrol with passports either. rows of toll booths across the border …running through wee farms and through the middle of houses …spike Milligan got it right in “Puckoon” all those years ago… .That’s another red herring .All of us can travel the length and breadth of these islands ..through the Republic of Ireland …into Wales …on to England or Scotland without recourse to flashing a passport.
We can still be friends in many ways without being attached at the hip.
My feeling is that it will be 60-4- No but I’ll be ecstatic to be proved wrong. Irresspective of this outcome the issue won’t go away you know.
The iron fist in the velvet glove has appeared in Scotland. Mr Cameron tells the electorate it would be “heartbreaking” to “break up this family of nations”. Mr Miliband states that independence for Scotland would harm wages and working conditions.
The Royal Bank of Scotland and Lloyds have “contingency plans” to move to England if the “YES” vote is victorious. BP states that the North Sea oil industry would be harmed by a “YES” for independence.
Current Tory social and economic policies have resulted in unemployment and poverty. The policies also contribute to health inequalities. Social deprivation is a fact of life for many in Scotland, England, Wales and in the north of Ireland. Today, some people will depend on food banks, not the Royal Bank of Scotland.
The statements from Mr Cameron, Mr Miliband and other captains of industry betray a complete disregard for an electorate that may choose to tread the path of independence. The real threat to vested financial interests lies in the ability of an independent Scotland to peacefully negotiate with a wide range of commercial interests in order to sustain and develop an economy geared to meet the needs of all its citizens.
John
Why do you think the polls have not been reflecting your prediction?
It is often said here that polls are unreliable partly because people are reluctant to admit to voting for Sinn Fein on account of their past associations.
I would have thought such an effect might operate to show a bias towards the ‘yes’ camp as Scots might be embarrassed to admit they would vote for remaining attached to the old enemy.
Well,giordanobruno, most polling experts agree that the two sides are very close. Methodologies also impact on polling outcomes. Last night’s ‘Daily Record’ poll used landlines – technology which has been largely forsaken by the young and many of the most deprived households have switched to Pay-as-you-Go which they find more manageable on stretched incomes. Both these groups are recognised as fervent YES supporters and the poll would not have reflected that. You are right about declaring an interest; the cliche of cannay Scots is true and many will keep their intentions quietly to themselves. It is remarkable that so many YES people from disparate groups, many totally apolitical, have come out to campaign
I have looked on the referendum with great deal of interest. I looked on the Scottish people with a great deal of admiration at the dignity and determination which they have shown to stand up against the full might of the British Media and the whole British administration and say but we want to do it differently
Hi John,
The Scottish have a great sense of humour. Today I read the Funniest thing I have seen in a very long time.
A ‘Yes’ supporter met the English Labour delegation arriving into Glasgow’s Central Station yesterday. As they started making their way walking into the town Centre, he rode alongside them through the streets in a rickshaw with a sound system playing “The Imperial March”, which accompanied the Evil Emperor and Darth Vader during their dramatic appearances in the Star Wars movies.
He kept up with the group as they walked through the city centre booming into a megaphone “Welcome to our imperial masters! Our imperial masters have arrived!”
http://www.heraldscotland.com/politics/referendum-news/stand-off-at-buchanan-street-steps-yes-campaigners-confront-100-westminster.1410437305
That is just hilariously witty and made me laugh until my sides were sore!
This guy needs a medal!
I felt it was only fair adding the YouTube link. It is even funnier than the written article. It is amazing how 2 guys on a modified bicycle and a sound system can countermine the tens of thousands of pounds of taxpayers money used to ship the Labour hierarchy to Glasgow to inform the Scottish people that they are not competent to run their own affairs