A press release and a letter

Screen Shot 2015-11-10 at 15.03.41 Screen Shot 2015-11-10 at 15.04.19

PRESS RELEASE:

Sister of murder victim Robert McCartney, who was murdered by the IRA in 2005, denounces what she perceives as the appalling abuse of the Oireachtas and has made the following Press Statement:

“I have stayed silent up to now about my disgust regarding the nomination of Mairia Cahill to the Seanad because of outstanding civil proceedings I am taking against her”.

“Reservations I have surround her alleged senior position in RNU (the political wing of the terrorist organisation,Og na hEireann) which, it appears, was as recent as 2011. I have today written to Oireachtas members outlining my concerns.

It is vital for victims’ families, fighting for truth and justice to be entitled to work with elected representatives who should operate from a position of integrity and independence”.

“I am asking the Labour Party and Ms Cahill to provide a credible explanation regarding emerging revelations of her involvement with RNU and to do so before the Seanad election.

Without an explanation, the appointment appears to be made solely for political purposes. This undermines the campaigning work of victims’ families, from all backgrounds who campaign for Justice for their loved ones.

I am calling on Joan Burton and the Labour Party to reflect on their decision to nominate Ms Cahill to the Seanad position”.

ENDS

 

 

Date: 09/11/2015

 

Dear Senators and Deputies,

I am writing to express my concern of, and my objection to Ms Cahill’s nomination to the Seanad. This is on the grounds of her involvement in the dissident group RNU, as highlighted by Mr Beades and others over the weekend.  Furthermore, the outright refusal of the Labour Party to provide a comprehensive explanation in relation to this matter only adds injury to families such as my own.

As you will be aware my brother, Robert, was murdered by the IRA and Sinn Fein members in 2005, and in the aftermath the IRA embarked on a cover up, which rendered any prospect of justice impossible.  A key and essential factor in our campaign was pressuring republicans to cooperate with the PSNI and due to this stance my family suffered greatly.

  • A picket held outside my brother’s house (causing my 4year old nephew to vomit

with anxiety)

  • Robert’s friend was badly beaten
  • We were issued with death threats
  • My sister and brother’s fiancé (and two children had to leave the area)
  • We were vilified and condemned
  • Our lives were completely transformed due to his murder and our campaign.

This did not deter us in our quest for justice however; a quest we continue to this day.  When SF did sign up to policing some of those involved in Robert’s murder moved to the dissident groups in protest.

If the revelations regarding Ms Cahill are accurate, then she also moved to the dissidents in opposition to SF’s shift on policing.  It has been cited in the press that Ms Cahill was the National Secretary of RNU from 2010-2011, a very senior position. This cannot be regarded as a minor issue or an irrelevance to the appointment to a political office.

I would also like it noted that Ms Cahill did not inform me of her involvement in RNU when I brought her into my home in 2011. On the contrary, she claimed not to be involved and to be in fear of them. It now appears that at this time she was National Secretary.

Ms Cahill’s nomination to the Seanad, in the absence of any full explanation for her involvement in a group which was actively discouraging people to engage with the police, is unacceptable and a gross undermining of victims of the IRA and dissident republicans.  I fail to understand how a family like our own can ask political parties to hold SF to account regarding matters of truth and justice, (issues which remain at the forefront of  peace process) whilst at the same time those parties ask no questions of Ms Cahill, and provide no answers to the public.

I have been silent on the issues surrounding Ms Cahill’s case. This is due to civil proceedings in process regarding a harassment case I have taken against Ms Cahill.

In 2011 I invited Ms Cahill into my home, because I believed her to be a woman facing a similar experience to our own (i.e. coming up against the Provos).  I supported her as a woman, a feminist and a justice campaigner.  I did not allow her previous involvement in SF to cloud my judgement of her experience or need.

I am now aware that I was not given the full facts and circumstances of Ms Cahill’s position and activities.  I have decided to write this letter because I believe the same now applies to the public, who deserve better from democratic politicians. Also, I believe that as a family seeking justice this appointment will leave us isolated from those political parties who support this nomination (without providing a full explanation acceptable to victims of the IRA and dissidents). The duplicity inherent in the lack of transparency and honesty relating to Ms Cahill’s role would make it difficult for me to engage on basis of integrity and independence.

I will leave it to your judgement regarding her suitability in the light of the revelations, but would ask that you demand a full and comprehensive explanation to be provided and published. This would be with a view to protecting the integrity of victims of republican violence, past and present.

I feel I must mention one more thing. In a message to me, Mairia Cahill claims to have recorded me without my knowledge and expressly infers that she will use this material to damage me in some way.  It is my view, and I’m sure the public would agree, that this behaviour is not befitting of a member of the Seanad and should also be addressed.

I would hope that you receive this on the basis upon which it is sent- a genuine and proven concern for matters relating to the rule of law, justice and truth.

Yours respectfully,

Catherine McCartney (sister of Robert McCartney)

23 Responses to A press release and a letter

  1. jessica November 10, 2015 at 3:12 pm #

    miaow

  2. Jim.hunter November 10, 2015 at 4:47 pm #

    Very.good.story.Jude.

    • Jude Collins November 10, 2015 at 5:04 pm #

      You.May.Say.That.I.Etc…

    • M E Moore November 10, 2015 at 5:51 pm #

      Why.are.you.always.trolling.here.Jim.?

      • Jim.hunter November 11, 2015 at 9:03 am #

        I.am.not.trolling.

  3. paul November 10, 2015 at 5:25 pm #

    can’t wait to hear the Kenny, Martin, Burton spin on this. Also I Times and Sindo may be required reading. GRMA Jude

  4. paddykool November 10, 2015 at 5:57 pm #

    I wonder how much publicity this will get…now that the claws are out…..

  5. Patrick November 10, 2015 at 6:06 pm #

    The mainstream media are staying very quiet on this. I wonder why?

    I have to say that I have serious doubts about the honesty of Cahill. There is enough information out there (include her own handwritten letters) to strongly suggest that she wasn’t subjected to a kangaroo court in the way she alleges. I mean it’d be very strange indeed to write warm letters of thanks and offer invites to her home for cups of tea to someone she alleged was part of a group who subjected her to a terrible ordeal.

    Her claim that she was only with RNU for a few hours also doesn’t exactly ring all that true. Would it not require much work within RNU first before one could rise to holding a position as high as ‘National Secretary’? And she claims she held that position only for a few hours. Let’s just call me unconvinced on that one.

    She has refused to deal with these issues and has refused to participate in either of the two Seanad by election debates claiming RTE didn’t invite her to theirs (contradicted by RTE).

    To my mind Cahill seems happy to play the part of a stick to beat Republicans with and is also enjoying some fringe benefits eg regular writing gigs for various newspapers and maybe a lucrative spell in the Seanad. So we know what might motivate Cahill. What might be motivating Catherine McCartney?

    Just my 2 cents. I’m not sure what others think?

  6. Cal November 10, 2015 at 6:09 pm #

    The use of Ms Cahill tells us all we need to know about the sincerity of the main southern political parties in terms of actually helping victims. Politics first and foremost.

    A sad day for all genuine victims seeking justice and truth.

  7. Sherdy November 10, 2015 at 6:14 pm #

    Jude, how dare you be complicit in the questioning of Saint Mairia’s bona fides!
    Don’t you know she’s a victim and as such whatever she says or does must be beyond reproach?
    Just because her versions of different events can change by the day, or appear totally different from other people’s versions, how could you be such a Doubting Thomas?
    Any woman who has the unquestioning backing of politicians, north and south, and of the media, especially of the DOB variety, must be like Caesar’s wife, the most honest and pure.
    The other similarity must be her future as a member of the Senate.
    Or did Caesar’s wife actually make it into the Roman Senate?

  8. Argenta November 10, 2015 at 6:27 pm #

    As far as I’m aware,it hasn’t been your practice to feature press releases in their entirety before.Is this a change in policy?Maybe you could explain why ,in particular ,this press release is being highlighted ?

    • Jude Collins November 10, 2015 at 6:37 pm #

      You may indeed, Argenta. For the good reason that I have not in the past had a press release to put up.

      • Feenyinn O'Taig November 10, 2015 at 8:23 pm #

        I have some burn cream here if anyone needs it.

  9. alex November 10, 2015 at 7:14 pm #

    Can safely say there’ll be no fawning of Ms Mc Cartney from all and sundry on this matter from politicians and media wanting to use and abuse, will be more a case of move along nothing to see here.

  10. Perkin Warbeck November 10, 2015 at 8:07 pm #

    Truly does Seanad Eireann contribute greatly to the gaiety of the Nation, Esteemed Blogmeister.

    Cahilligula 2

    Like a surreal two-reel from Mack Sennet
    A Lipstick-slapstick now packs the Senate
    Less of toga
    More of Ogla’
    Not so much a horse this go – as a jennet.

    . And to think we almost lost it.

  11. Joe McIvor November 10, 2015 at 9:17 pm #

    What happened to Robert McCartney was appalling and no true republican could support such a cowardly murder and call themselves republicans, but at the time there was the call for people to come forward to the police, why? his friend was beaten but survived, surely he is able to identify Roberts killers, if he fears reprisals from dissendents or whoever were responsible, surely noone would be better protected by the psni, to bring a case forward, if only to embarrass Sinn Féin if as indeed Robert’s sisters claim, members were involved in his death? As for Mairia Cahill, it’s becoming clearer by the day that she is more than likely a paid agent of the Brits run by the spooks. Sinn Féin have always claimed dissendent groups are having their strings pulled by MI5, the dirty war continues apace, they will do and as we well know are capable of anything in there war on Sinn Féin.

  12. ANOTHER JUDE November 10, 2015 at 9:33 pm #

    I agree with Joe McIvor, this place is still a cess pit of double dealing and intrigue with the victims` relatives being exploited. God bless the McCartney family if they ever expected genuine help. As for Ms Caihill, she does seem like a rather complicated woman.

  13. Patrick November 10, 2015 at 9:58 pm #

    Hell hath no fury like a woman scorned

    • kopabergcentral November 11, 2015 at 12:55 am #

      Especially the Belfast Battleaxe variety. Scary Marys

  14. John auld November 11, 2015 at 3:19 am #

    Let us not forget the McCartney family are real and genuine victims in all of this..Their brother was savagely murdered in an entry by drunken thugs who his behind the organisational mask of Sinn Fein and the provisional IRA.Yes murdered by individuals who have no right to get off scott free to save a very fragile peace process..There is no doubting that fact..Yes they are real victims..Miss Cahill though..?????..Hmmmmmmmmm….

  15. Séamus Ó Néill November 11, 2015 at 7:00 am #

    Surely there are lessons here…..two virulent anti Sinn Féiners ,feted and fawned over by the establishment and a very complicit media, having a public tiff,,,,,will sides have to be chosen ? Like Patrick ,I think Ms Cahill is being very economical with the truth…..I don’t buy this “Road to Damascus ” conversion …..I also suspect the hand of MI5 .I am not attempting to diminish Robert Mc Cartney’s murder but flying around the world besmirching Sinn Féin was never going to bring justice……that lay a lot closer to home….. Ms Cahill’s elevation to the Seanad could certainly open up her ‘pinocchio like’ version of events to public scrutiny and that would undoubtedly be welcome but in my opinion she is ineligible ,( unsound mind…in my opinion )

    • giordanobruno November 11, 2015 at 10:58 am #

      Séamus
      Unsound mind?
      You mean like trampolining naked with a dog?
      Or forgetting huge swathes of your past?

    • Argenta November 11, 2015 at 4:26 pm #

      Seamus
      “I also suspect the hand of M I 5—I am not attempting to diminish Robert Mc Cartneys murder”
      It appears that the default position of many Sinn Fein supporters and poster on this blogspot is to blame M I 5 for everything ! Was M I 5 in Mc Guinness’s bar when Robert Mc Cartney was murdered?We are given to understand that the bar was full of S F supporters but what followed was one of the most remarkable acts of collective amnesia in recent times!!Of course the biggest sin ,it appears is to cast aspersions on Sinn Fein.The Mc Cartney sisters should not have travelled to America to publicise the cover up of their brothers murder!!As Mr Storey might say ” How dare they?!!