Sorry – respect is now a one-way street

Screen Shot 2016-04-26 at 12.47.05 Gerry - Version 2

(Note: apologies for the garbled version of this blog which appeared earlier.And thanksto Eddie Whyte for alerting me to its garbledness…)

OK – let’s keep one thing firmly in mind: it’s the election, stupid. All and any words issuing from the mouth of any politician, north or south, for the next couple of weeks, will be with the election north and/or south in mind.

That said, First Minister Arlene Foster’s denunciation of Gerry Adams’s Ard-Fheis speech as “a backward step” is itself a backward as well an illogical statement.  What got Arlene, apparently, was the bit linking the Easter Rising and the more recent Troubles: “We are proud of the men and women of 1916” Gerry Adams said. “We are equally proud if the men and women of the H Blocks and Armagh, and of the 1981 hunger strikers and the patriot dead from our time. We remember them all here tonight”.

Arlene didn’t like that. “This is a clear reference to the PIRA…[and is] insulting to those of us who were victims of the IRA”.

You don’t have to be a psychiatrist to work out why Arlene said what she did. First there’s the election, stupid, and second there’s the fact that her father was shot and wounded by the IRA. So although it will do her and her party no harm in the coming election,  it’s reasonable that a unionist First Minister would have a low opinion of the IRA.

What’s unreasonable is that she should expect everyone else, particularly the leader of Sinn Fein, to take a similar view. You might say “How could anyone pay tribute to an organisation that did so many terrible things?”  But let’s take it the other way round.

Every year, throughout the north, there are wreath-laying ceremonies for those British forces who died in the many wars and conflicts in which Britain has been engaged since the early twentieth century. That clearly includes such matters as the Ballymurphy Massacre, Bloody Sunday, the killing of individuals such as Pat Finucane and Rosemary Nelson, and the many acts of collusion in which the British armed forces engaged throughout the conflict period, including the Dublin/Monaghan bombs and the Glenanne gang’s activities.

One might well point out that these annual ceremonies celebrating these people are insulting to those who were their victims. And the insult will be delivered annually, and nationalists and republicans who do not attend these ceremonies are denounced as refusing to move on.

It would appear that the DUP in the person of Mrs Foster not only reserves the right to honour those who fought on the side of unionism during the conflict but the right to denounce any attempt by their political opponents  to honour those who fought on the side of republicanism. Even further, to expect those who suffered at the hands of British forces to attend annual ceremonies honouring those same forces.

Confession: I quite like Arlene Foster. I’ve met her a couple of times – once when she was a very young member of the UUP, and once more recently, shortly before she became DUP leader. On both occasions she was cheerful, friendly and courteous. But either she doesn’t see the one-sidedness of this denunciation of the Adams speech, which is surprising; or she does see the one-sidedness of it and calculates that this will resonate with the DUP electorate, which is depressing.

 

25 Responses to Sorry – respect is now a one-way street

  1. Joe McVeigh April 26, 2016 at 9:43 am #

    Something happened here after you stated that you quite like Arlene..

    • Jude Collins April 26, 2016 at 12:08 pm #

      It must have been that I said something which angered the gods…

  2. fiosrach April 26, 2016 at 10:09 am #

    Strange layout, a chara

    • Jude Collins April 26, 2016 at 12:08 pm #

      Yes I know, fiosrach. Was working from an ipad. My laptop has now been freed from the expensive grasp of Mr Apple and I have amended the cock-up.

  3. Sherdy April 26, 2016 at 10:31 am #

    Since Arlene shafted Nigel Dodds for the leadership of the DUP I don’t think there has been one week where she hasn’t started off a speech with: ‘Speaking as a victim . . .’
    How long does she intend continuing with that theme, I wonder, as someone continually making the same complaint will soon run out of sympathy?
    ‘Confession: I quite like Arlene’, and you also confessed previously to a fancy for Ruthless Dudley Edwards.
    Jude, I worry about your taste in women!

    • Jude Collins April 26, 2016 at 12:06 pm #

      My admiration of Arlene was strictly platonic, I promise you, Sherdy. As to Ruthie – I didn’t register on her radar at all. She moved at a much higher plane, being the beloved of one Patrick Cosgrove, who went on to write a hagiography of M Thatcher and was said to be destined for a place in her Cabinet, but then (allegedly) blotted his copybook, if that’s the metaphor I want, by (allegedly) taking to the drink and in a moment of absent-mindedness up-throwing the contents of his innards onto Mag’s lap as she sat in the back of a car…Allegedly.

      • Sherdy April 26, 2016 at 1:57 pm #

        My undying admiration for Patrick Cosgrove’s bravery in wedding the former and expressing his lack of devotion to the latter.
        But I can’t decide which of the two acts landed him in the deeper faeces!

  4. giordanobruno April 26, 2016 at 10:41 am #

    Jude
    As you probably know the ads that appear on your PC are tailored to reflect your viewing history, so you have given us an interesting insight into your character.
    I deduce that you are a Disney fan,with hair loss issues, and you are thinking of booking a cheap holiday this year,
    Now can I interest you in a slightly used vacuum cleaner?

    • Jude Collins April 26, 2016 at 12:03 pm #

      Ha haaa -very good,gio…The innocent have nothing to fear. Glasnost all round, please. That said, I can understand the Disney, the cheap hol – but this hair loss thing baffles me…

      • giordanobruno April 26, 2016 at 1:04 pm #

        Jude
        It could have been worse!

        • Jude Collins April 26, 2016 at 1:27 pm #

          Indeed. Thank God it didn’t include the Hot Dutch site…

  5. BYC April 26, 2016 at 10:50 am #

    Except Jude, that while Declan Kearney was on stage telling us that the time for recrimination (his word) was over there was a stand in the foyer at the Ard Fheis telling people all about McGurk’s, Ballymurphy, Bloody Sunday and “800 years of crime”. Sinn Fein clearly have no intention of ever easing up on recrimination – pointing accusing fingers and yelling “up the rebels” is standard MO. Compare the limp hand slapping Declan got to the standing ovation for baby demagogue, Matt Carthy.

    And I’ve never seen a stand at another party conference radicalising the next generation with lists of IRA atrocities. People may well be gauche enough to talk about Enniskillen or the Shankill or ask why it took the heros of the IRA 45 bullets to kill a 21 female shopworker by accident them up from but they don’t go down to the printers and fill their conference foyers with posters of them.

    If Arlene’s in a position to point out that Gerry likes to have his cake and eat his cake and then tell the rest of us that cake is a very bad thing altogether maybe Gerry should just push the plate away.

    When the DUP are making you look like militant dinosaurs you should do more than just just your fingers in your ears and go “nah, nah, nah, finucane”.

    If Gerry really means it when he says “But from a unionist perspective all has changed, changed utterly from the days of a one-party state where nationalists were excluded from power; denied equality in housing, employment and voting rights; and where expressions of Irish national identity were criminalised.” why is he still boring on about the Orange State every time he gets the chance? Can Gerry not get used to a world where unionists are actually happier and reassured when nationalists play a full part in society?

    • antonio April 26, 2016 at 1:24 pm #

      Can Gerry not get used to a world where unionists are actually happier and reassured when nationalists play a full part in society?

      I see no evidence that the DUP are happier & reassured when nationalists play a full part in society. Maybe there’s something I haven’t seen.

      • BYC April 26, 2016 at 1:57 pm #

        “I see no evidence that the DUP are happier & reassured when nationalists play a full part in society. Maybe there’s something I haven’t seen.”

        You’ll not see it if you don’t want too.

        Jude finds Arlene “cheerful, friendly and courteous”. Arlene calls Martin by his Christian name and talks about their investment hunting trips to Cookstown together. Ian was Martin’s friend and half of the chuckle brothers. There was some frustration around welfare reform and trying to set a budget but other than that they all seem happy enough.

        Compared to twenty years ago they’re joyous.

        • Ryan April 26, 2016 at 5:23 pm #

          “You’ll not see it if you don’t want too”

          Unionists would know all about that……

        • antonio April 26, 2016 at 5:43 pm #

          ”You’ll not see it if you don’t want too”

          Do not assume you know what I see and want to see.

          Then you go on to tell me Jude’s compliments for Arlene Foster. How does that show Unionists are happy and reassured? Nelson McCausland called Jude ‘that horrible little man’ or something to that effect.

          Arlene calls Martin by his Christian name and hunting trips to Cookstown?? is that is your best example of the D.U.P being happier & reassured when nationalists play a full part in society???
          If it is I think I can just rest my case that the D.U.P loath having to share power with Nationalists.

          Are you not aware that Paisley’s ‘chuckle brothers’ routine with McGuinness was one of the main reason why he was shafted from the leadership as the rank & file were so disgusted by it.

          ‘There was some frustration around welfare reform and trying to set a budget but other than that they all seem happy enough. ‘

          Well what I heard the D.U.P say time and time again on the airwaves about welfare reform was spiteful comments about Sinn Fein & the S.D.L.P being ‘economic illiterates’.

          And have you forgotten Gregory Campbell getting a great round of applause at the DUP’s convention last year when he said ‘we are going to treat Sinn fein’s wish list like toilet paper’. Yes the D.U.P wipe their shitty arses with whatever Sinn Fein want.

          Clearly they are delighted that nationalists play a full part in our society.

          • BYC April 26, 2016 at 6:26 pm #

            There we are. Arlene’s polite to Jude. You bring up Nelson. Ian’s polite to Martin. You bring up some other thing. Arlene’s on first name terms and has a respectful and professional working relationship with Martin. You’ve got Gregory. I don’t need to assume anything. It’s perfectly clear.

    • Ryan April 26, 2016 at 5:20 pm #

      “When the DUP are making you look like militant dinosaurs you should do more than just just your fingers in your ears and go “nah, nah, nah, finucane”

      Even looking like “militant dinosaurs” is a better image than what the DUP have BYC. Speaking of militant dinosaurs…..whatever happened to Ulster Resistance and those lovely red berets?….do you think Robbo and other DUP members still have theirs? On a serious note, where did all those arms imported by Ulster Resistance go? those same arms are responsible for the murder of over 100 people…..

      “Can Gerry not get used to a world where unionists are actually happier and reassured when nationalists play a full part in society?”

      You must’ve been ill and missed the history lesson on discrimination, gerrymandering and sectarianism by Unionist politicians against Catholics/Nationalists BYC. Hence many Catholics weren’t able to play their full part in society due to Unionists. Indeed Paisley for decades opposed power sharing. The DUP was founded as the “PUP – Protestant Unionist Party”, where one of their policies was preference for Protestants in Jobs and Housing. Yup, very happy to have Catholics play a full part in society, so they are……

      • BYC April 26, 2016 at 6:14 pm #

        Dredging up more ancient history Ryan? That’s recrimination that is. Declan says that’s naughty. Stop holding back the peace process Ryan!

        • Ryan April 26, 2016 at 8:50 pm #

          Ancient History? I’m not the one parading with banners commemorating a battle in 1690 or an incident in 1641! That’s Unionists, BYC.

          Declan doesn’t speak for me and I don’t speak for Declan.

          The 1960’s isn’t Ancient History BYC. Considering the allegations against Nelson McCausland and other DUP members of meeting a Housing Association in an Orange Hall and stopping Housing being built for Catholics then it seems discrimination isn’t even History, never mind Ancient History….

        • Antonio April 27, 2016 at 5:01 pm #

          I’m still waiting for you to tell me somethinh substantial to demonstrate Unionism’s happiness with power sharing with nationalist s.
          You seem unaware that you never came up with anything as an example.

  6. Iolar April 26, 2016 at 10:55 am #

    Peer pressure

    “Every year, throughout the north, there are wreath-laying ceremonies for those British forces who died in the many wars and conflicts in which Britain has been engaged since the early nineteenth century…”

    Let’s broach the issue of backward steps in the context of collusion in Ireland.

    Writing about bombs in Dublin and Monaghan, J.Bowyer Bell, ‘In Dubious Battle’ (1996) made the following points about British collusion in Ireland:

    “A great deal of care, trouble, intimidation and influence has been expended to keep British secrets, secret…money, force, loyalty, greed, disinformation, the law, patriotism, fear, all have been deployed for the crown. And if in the end nothing works, then firm denial, regardless of the evidence.”

    Let’s broach the issue of collusion between a civil servant, (a fine oxymoron, Joxer) and a British Lieutenant General. Writing in 1975, Frank Cooper wrote the following to Frank King:

    “…the UDA and the UVF see themselves as defenders of the status quo threatened by a culturally and socially inferior minority which is identified by the Catholic religion. This justifies random attacks on Catholics as a group to ‘keep them down’.

    Perhaps it might be useful to make an issue of the many backward steps made by some seeking a badge of honour and fame courtesy of the honours list.

  7. ben madigan April 26, 2016 at 3:18 pm #

    if anyone’s interested in finding out more about the Dublin-Monaghan bombings here’s a little-viewed film called The Hidden Hand

    https://eurofree3.wordpress.com/2016/01/06/hidden-hand-the-dublin-monaghan-bombings/

  8. Perkin Warbeck April 26, 2016 at 4:41 pm #

    Brits out, Britney in !

    Never-green Arlene takes the Brit from Britney
    As the Most Oppressed Prod Ever, no kitten she
    The listless SF Ard-Fheis
    Gerry Mo: go ‘n refresh !
    Less a list, the word-spears of Arlene, more a litany.

  9. Ryan April 26, 2016 at 5:04 pm #

    “What’s unreasonable is that she should expect everyone else, particularly the leader of Sinn Fein, to take a similar view”

    Well that’s the thing Jude, most Unionist politicians aren’t reasonable people and its regrettable to say that a lot of the Unionist electorate are the same, Unionist bigotry is a vote winner and has been for decades. Any Unionist leader that ever went slightly moderate was removed, O’Neill, Trimble, etc. Even when Paisley mellowed he was removed.

    Something you didn’t mention was Arlene calling on the new Irish Government NOT to push for Irish Unity, she said such a thing would be “unwise”, what she meant by this she didn’t explain. This is the same Arlene that just last week told Micheal Martin to keep his nose out of the North’s affairs when he criticized the two party rule currently in force in Stormont. Arlene wants the South to keep their nose out of the North’s affairs (despite hundreds of thousands of Catholics wanting their involvement) but feels she’s entitled to poke her own nose into the South’s affairs. Well, she’s certainly living up to the hypocrisy of previous Unionist leaders, that’s for sure…..

    We often hear in the media about why our society isn’t “moving on”, why are there more peace walls today than 20 years ago? Its not surprising to see why. I could go on a lecture about the reasons why but everyone already knows. The Northern state is a failure and will always be, its simply unworkable. Then we hear nutters talking about “democratising” Stormont. If majority rule returned here with Unionism in charge we will be back in 1969 within a few weeks. Can you honestly see the DUP or UUP governing in the interests of everyone here? That’s like trusting the Ku Klux Klan to govern impartially over black communities.

    Respect is indeed a one way street when it comes to Unionism but the state of Northern Ireland is on a one way street too, a one way street to failure.