YOU – THE JURY – AN “APPALLING VISTA” IF CONFLICTING EVIDENCE IS GIVEN YOU by Donal Kennedy

screen-shot-2016-11-01-at-12-08-37

Some  thirty years back I did jury service in London, dealing with three or four cases. Not ones grabbing great headlines, or any headlines, come to that, nor involving politically inspired incidents or prosecutions.

I was impressed particularly by the seriousness of most of my fellow jurors, of various origins and abilities,to try each case on the basis of the evidence set before them. I was also impressed by the razor-sharp awareness of the judges and their ability to recall in an instant the exact words used by a witness, their courtesy,  commitment to fair play and their absence of  punitive instincts. I was really taken by a female judge in her red robes with her cut-glass accent saying “Fuck”, but in mitigation I must record she was quoting evidence put before her, not commenting on it.
I’m not saying that trial by jury is perfect. But the idea that the bald-headed man and the hirsute lady on a Clapham omnibus together with a handful of citizens (or neighbours) picked at random, can be trusted to weigh the evidence for and against an accused person seems very good. I know Jonathan Swift urged that we Irish burn everything English but coal, but I suspect that he would have exempted Trial By Jury from incineration.
Swift’s “Drapier’s Letters” were not published under his own name, because the “Powers That Be” , terrified of  such ” an appalling vista” as an informed Public Opinion would have had him clapped in gaol. As they say in France – “Plus la change”……..Then, as now, people could not be trusted to choose between opposing evidence given a fair hearing.
Much of the media here in Britain is aghast that some people here have read, seen or listened to Russian narratives that undermine or contradict Western ones about world events. I confess that I read last year an English translation of President Putin’s address to the United Nations on its 70th anniversary.
I confess also that I found it admirable. I’ve read other Russian commentary which seems reasonable. The West has sufficient information/propaganda  capacity to refute falsehoods and correct errors in the Russian narratives, but seems to prefer to drown them with hysterical headlines or damn anyone who has the temerity to consider them as Russia’s stooges and her “useful idiots.”
Nothing new here.” I dunno but I b’n tol’  that when George Orwell wrote “Animal Farm,” his satire on Stalinism, he couldn’t get it published. For Uncle Joe and FDR and Winston Churchill were all pals together at the time and criticism of Stalin or Russia was not permitted in Britain.
Michael Portillo recently revealed that “the visionary” Churchill intended to attack the Soviet Union in 1945 with the help of various forces, including Germans who had just surrendered to the Western allies. Fortunately, the British electorate had a less romanticised view of  ChurchillI than those born after his time,and gave his party  (the Tories)  the bum’s rush in the General Election of July 1945.
To refute the falsehoods and correct the errors in the British Press from 1919 through 1921, Ireland’s elected Government, Dail Eireann , circulated to Governments, politicians and journalists abroad THE IRISH BULLETIN. It was printed on a Gestetner type machine, secretly and at the peril of the producers’ lives. Brave and honest MPs in London used it to question and expose British Government Ministers – it would have been pointless to attempt to shame the blighters!  It was not available from newsagents.
In County Clare Edward MacLysaght kept copies of each issue, and, one morning in February 1921 his mother borrowed a couple of copies to  read on the train from Killaloe to Limerick. The train was stopped by Crown Forces and she was court-martialled and sentenced to one month’s imprisonment or a fine of £20 for possession of the paper. She chose imprisonment, but her husband returned from Australia on the same day, and to her chagrin, paid her fine.
On 14 February 2015 one Michael Foley, reviewing “Periodicals and Journalism in Twentieth Century Ireland” in that “paper of record/reference” THE IRISH TIMES gave short shrift to THE IRISH BULLETIN which he said “was not available from corner newsagents.”  The next day I wrote to the paper quoting MacLysaght’s account and speculating on the likely fate of a newsagent stocking the Bulletin.
But THE IRISH TIMES, perhaps contemplating the “appalling vista” of the public consulting THE IRISH BULLETIN, which had exposed its servile publication of Dublin Castle propaganda in the deceitful guise of its own news-gathering during the War of Independence, didn’t publish my letter, or any other letter taking their reviewer to task.
But some months later, when the Belfast Historical and Educational Society published  Volume 3 of its reprints of the IRISH BULLETIN it published my letter to THE IRISH TIMES in its Foreword.
An Appalling Vista haunts the Begrudgers. Men and women will have access to conflicting evidence and conflicting opinions and will have the wit to choose between them.
Lord Denning must be spinning in his grave.

2 Responses to YOU – THE JURY – AN “APPALLING VISTA” IF CONFLICTING EVIDENCE IS GIVEN YOU by Donal Kennedy

  1. joe bloggs November 1, 2016 at 4:48 pm #

    I think I remember one your posts from weeks back recounting your early attempts at journalism. If I remember correctly, the editor of a newspaper described your work as rambling, with no central narrative (sic) and urged you to try and correct those failings.

    Did you ever take his advice? Reading your pieces is like sitting next to someone in the sun room of an old people’s home and listening to their meandering stories after a heavy lunch.

  2. fiosrach November 1, 2016 at 4:52 pm #

    Pass no remarks, Donal. If there’s no pictures some people quickly lose interest.