
Given Mrs. Foster’s adamant willingness to portray herself as a new ‘Iron Lady’ in refusing to step aside, it seems as though an early election is on the horizon sooner rather than later. This whole fiasco has crippled many people’s faith in politics altogether, including the power-sharing institutions themselves. But we must always distribute blame where it is due and not make generalisations – the fact is, there exists a rotten core of dark forces at the heart of the DUP; who have shamed themselves with expediency in light of the Red Sky, Iris Robinson, MP’s Expenses and RHI episodes, among many other scandals.
I don’t doubt for one moment that there are decent people in the DUP – Jenny Palmer has my respect and both Jonathan Bell & David McIlveen deserve credit for the abuse they have highlighted. But we may need to undergo a process of creative destruction to weed out the corrupt and sinister elements within the political system we live under. I’ll explain what I mean throughout the article. The reason Mrs. Foster won’t step aside is because she probably suspects that any objective investigation or pragmatism could result in her political demise. That would establish a strong precedent which would enforce standards and ethics on the Unionist political class which they would subsequently have to live up to. They don’t want that because, from the inception of this state, an Orange aristocracy has governed according to the most rotten gut instincts and self-interest. The Peace Process has forced them to change somewhat, but the only guarantee that they will be held to account for their shady practices, and prosecuted if guilty, is a sovereign and independent Ireland – this brings me to my next point.
I won’t insult your intelligence by suggesting that Sinn Fein or any political party is perfect, they are after all human institutions and subject to human error. But it is the best and only vehicle which working class people have throughout the length and breadth of this island to comprehensively stand up for their interests. Labour talk of their links to the Trade Unions; Sinn Fein and republicanism is the Trade Union for the struggles and sweat of the whole of the Irish people. But change takes time and democracy isn’t perfect, as JFK once said.
Now it’s a sensible practice that those who fight the war or liberate a country, should negotiate directly with the occupying or enemy power. General De Gaulle did so in France and made something truly special out of that country with his critical mass of patriots. If you want to know what any politician or party will be like in Government then you’ve only to look and see who supports them and why. And also, who is against them and why.
I wouldn’t doubt for a moment that there are many decent people in People Before Profit who want to see fundamental root and branch changes of the economic system that has failed people across the globe. It is a global problem after all and not just confined to Ireland. But the question is who and how you deliver it. Now I’ve written extensively about People Before Profit; I’ve researched them through to my finger-tips and listened to what they have to say. I’m impressed by the number of young people getting engaged in politics therein, but I will debate with anyone who is gullible enough to think that their policies and promises are even deliverable in an independent Ireland, let alone a power-sharing administration at Stormont; which has no sovereignty, no currency of its own and no central bank – to nationalise sections of the economy and redistribute wealth. That’s not a party political assertion, it is an economic FACT. They would be unable to do anything beyond that which is currently being done because as long as partition remains then the British Parliament will decide our spending priorities – FACT. Already, more money is spent in the North per head than anywhere in Scotland, England or Wales – so do you really think that a right wing Conservative Government is going to give Gerry Carroll and Eamonn McCann the massive sums of money they require to fulfil their manifesto promises and policies? It would be a redundant exercise even sending them there to negotiate on our behalf when the truth is they have no clout whatsoever over any Westminster Government.
This brings me on to my next point – the people who have most attacked me for writing about People Before Profit haven’t been party members themselves, no no, it has been hardline Unionists and Loyalists. You can view their comments accordingly. So we really must ask ourselves, what do the Loyalists and Unionists know about PBP that we don’t as of yet? I’ll tell you what it is – they know PBP have no proverbial b***s when it comes to securing demands off the British or the Unionists. They know that PBP leaders haven’t fought any struggle at the coal-face, including by force of arms, to exercise any leverage over power-brokers. The only reason we have a peace process is because the republican campaign against British tyranny was costing the Westminster Exchequer far too much money (the destruction of Canary Wharf secured the negotiations). These are facts of history and human nature. When Irish men and women were fighting to rid this country of foreign domination, they were being attacked and ridiculed by the Eamonn McCanns of those days, in the ultra-left idealist groups and among the bourgeois liberals in South Dublin. If the Westminster Government had not imposed cuts on the North, McCann wouldn’t even have a seat – he was electorally rejected consistently throughout his life because people knew then that his message couldn’t and can’t be delivered upon.
The number of Sinn Fein MLAs you send to Stormont determines how many republicans will sit at the Executive table. It determines the representation YOU have in holding both the Unionists and the British Government to account, while securing the best possible deal for the people of the North until we have full control over the affairs of our country. That is the power-struggle which exists therein. Now I want to make a pitch and address directly the people of West Belfast – I’m staking my word and credibility on the fact-based analysis I’m telling you here and now. You, like many other communities, are suffering under the neo-liberal economic system that Britain imposes on Ireland. And here’s the solution for you;
When partition comes to a close and it will, and when a republican government is finally elected, the guarantee you have that they will deliver is the right to sack them at will if they don’t. I’ve no doubt that a future Sinn Fein Taoiseach will run deficits and increase public spending; They will intervene in the economy with public money to bring your living standards up to that of Scandinavia. They will act with ‘cojones’ to regulate the banks which destroyed this country. They will build houses across the length and breadth of this land to end the housing crisis. And they will be the party of ensuring FULL EMPLOYMENT, so you have the peace and quiet to live your own life. This isn’t going to happen tomorrow or with the outcome of one election to the Assembly, it is a continuous struggle between the forces of Left and Right, between truth and deception. But the number of republicans you send to Stormont adds to every chip we make in ending the Union between Britain and Ireland.
If the Unionists don’t stand aside for this investigation to take place, then the Shinners should collapse the arena which is keeping them in power. People on the ground need to know that their views and interests are being listened to and this cannot simply be business as usual if accountability doesn’t garner some Unionist resignations over this disaster. But if that election comes, sooner rather than later, then you won’t need to comment on this to query anything I’ve said, I’ll be on the election trail and particularly in West Belfast to get as many republicans elected as possible. I’ll be out knocking doors with other activists and addressing concerns from beyond just a keyboard. We need to hold rallies and events to large crowds and explain what the peace process needs to be taken forward, step by step, and take that argument directly to the British Government. And we need to show the world exactly who it is that represents the best interests of the people of Derry and West Belfast. So the question falls to you: Who do you want to be governed by?

Donal clearly ratted by PbP eating into the Provo vote.
“Now it’s a sensible practice that those who fight the war or liberate a country, should negotiate directly with the occupying or enemy power. General De Gaulle did so in France and made something truly special out of that country with his critical mass of patriots.”
De Gaulle negotiated with the Nazis?? When was this?
Not from Stormont that’s for sure.
I am a long term Sinn Fein voter who was unable to vote for Stormont last time out as it sickened me to my stomach.
If there is an election before an investigation into this latest scandal undertaken by a body with ample powers to compel witnesses and documents has delivered a preliminary report, then don’t expect people to vote.
The most important thing is that this investigation gets under way.
Arlene cannot be acting in the role first minister while this investigation takes place, if she refuses to step aside, then suspend Stormont until the preliminary report is released. That way she doesn’t have to step aside but she wont be acting in that role during the investigation.
If an investigation is not agreed or frustrated, put it in your manifesto that you will not allow Stormont to come up again until an investigation has reported.
Failure to do any of these and don’t bother going around the doors.
Brilliant as ever Jessica. Hammer, nail, head!
People before profit are pie in the sky in government. They are only useful for reminding in opposition,the government, of ideals.
But young people thrive on ideals and “post troubles” youth will be attracted to them. Sinn Fein need to be more articulate about their left wing ideals and how it means chipping away at the present right wing bias from all the other parties, while showing that PBF “immediately”policies would be political suicide. Ireland is a long way off being ready for that.
Communism will never amount to anything in Ireland Nuala.
Many people who voted PBP will have been abhorred to see the red flag waving and singing songs reminiscent of the willie mccrea era.
It was sickening
Donal as someone who is SF to the core and who lived through the entire conflict ,I have to correct you about McCann.Those involved in the Republican struggle were neither “attacked” or “ridiculed by McCann.He was one of the H block prisoners strongest supporters and helped launch Bobby Sands election campaignHe was reviled as “a sneaking regarder” by theneo unionist WP and their ilk and marched alongside and addressed republican parades.He always argued the provos had to be part of any solution and said that socialism could never be achieved in Ireland if id did not involve large numbers of the provisional movement.I know he has become increasingly annoying in recent years but in fairness his role during the troubles was100% sound.
who do you want to e governed by………you want to swap being governed by the brits,to be governed by germany..very republican of you.
We are all governed by money, speculators and world capitalism. We are so small a cog that it doesn’t really matter who orders us about.
I was a Sinn Fein Councillor for 10 years and they still have some ideals, but none that are any more than a chip on the table. Every thing is for sale in Stormont in the quest for votes(money). There are still many people in the party who I would admire and respect, but many of those members only stay because it’s the only show in town, least worst option or it’s been their whole life and when you leave, you leave.
Many people still vote for them for the same reasons but a lot of people are choosing not to vote at all because they’ve been the biggest nationalist/Republican Party for years now and failed to deliver. To be fair, people’s expectations of what was/is deliverable are at times unrealistic, but Sinn Fein policies are written in such an open way that they commit to nothing.
The story around the RHISCHEME has been all about the DUP and while they are ultimately responsible, Sinn Fein and the other parties are either negligent or complicit. There would not have been demands to step aside, enquiries, threats or a word about the whole fiasco if Spotlight had not exposed the issue. Sinn Fein members voted against keeping the scheme open a year ago, why, what did they know that others didn’t . They knew what was happening and said nothing. Does that not demonstrate the lengths they’d stoop to keep the show on the road.
As for PBP policies, I’m not familiar with all of them but I know they have a left wing agenda, which is a positive start. I know they’re trying to change Thatchers restrictions on the unions, which are devolved and being enforced by Stormont. You say PBP policies are not realistic prior to Irish Unity and like I said I’m not familiar with them all but I know that Health is devolved and Sinn Fein are making no attempts to stop or even stem the privatisation of almost every part of the service. The same applies in housing,education and every department in Stormont.
The old Magherafelt Council privatised leisure services and not a word about it. Waste management is going the same way and what was once a party to be proud off are voting in favour of an ever increasing, ever unmanageable private sector.
A PBP or independent left wing alternative could absolutely change the destruction of public services. To suggest it’s pie in the sky is the real joke. When the national health service was still a public service, it was affordable and more efficient. When the Housing Executive were still allowed to build and maintain their properties, it was affordable.
On the global point, we are witnessing a rise in far right nationalism. Is it not reasonable to assume the left will awaken in response.
“On the global point, we are witnessing a rise in far right nationalism. Is it not reasonable to assume the left will awaken in response.”
No we are not Michael, we are witnessing the rise of anti globalisation.
Left and right ideals should compliment one another, there are times to invest in public services and public housing construction programs, there are times when it is better to be prudent with the economy.
The wealth gap has grown, driven by EU policies and its financial backers who thrive off globalisation.
The only protest the people have left is their vote and the more extreme the voice the better to get their point across which is why there has been a gradual rise in the far right over 40 years which is about to peak. It is not a new phenomenon by any stretch of the imagination.
The people have been left with no other choice.
What I would agree with is that once change away from the globalisation drive has been effected, left wing policies will be needed to restore the equilibrium that caused the upheaval in the first place which is why there remains hope for Jeremy Corbyn if the Labour party would get behind him.
But the bottom line, is a 6 county state divided from the rest of Ireland is not economically viable and Sinn Fein are absolutely right to prioritise electoral success in Dublin regardless what votes it costs them in the north.
In reply to Michael Coogan,
Of course none of these points you raise seemed to prick your conscience until you failed to get nominated for the Assembly elections in South Down..funny that.
Jessica, I agree on the anti globalisation comment and with a lot of your comments but the point I’m making in relation to the privatisation of housing, health etc is that it would be more economically prudent to stop outsourcing public sector services.
I’m either not reading your comment right or expressing mine properly because other than the globalisation point, (which I shouldn’t have limited to the far right growth) I don’t see where we are that far apart.
Not sure if your comment on Sinn Fein prioritising Dublin are directed at me as I made no reference to this but while I agree with the strategy it is very risky as it leaves a void in the north. A void that could be filled by people a lot more extreme than PBP, and that would set the whole strategy back for decades.
In response to Alex. Your local enough to know I failed to be selected as an Assembly candidate, but I was nominated at the convention by the current Infrastructure Minister and both Ballynahinch and Downpatrick delegates.
I have never written anything in relation to that convention or a multitude of other issues and I could write plenty if need be. I still have the correspondence but as I said previously, there are many in Sinn Fein I still have a lot of respect for and I prefer to leave it alone. Any criticisms I have are constructive not vengeful.
As for none of these points pricking my conscience prior to resigning, your mistaken. I raised these very issues many times while still a serving Councillor and I wasn’t alone. The Friday morning constituency meetings became very difficult to say the least and the minutes I have of them would verify that. No idea who you are Alex but it may be wiser to leave it alone. It serves no constructive purpose to get in to a slanging match and I notice your comment didn’t challenge my points, it was merely an inaccurate attempt to discredit me.
Nope, not local, just making an observation and no wish to mudsling however, you are the one on social media slinging the mud at SF, it just smacks of sour grapes. Always disheartening to see former comrades walk away I wish you well.