A Better Future: towards a culture of life, care and hope for all
- “Voting for those who will govern our society is a moral act. Each vote cast, or not cast, potentially influences the values that will shape future law and policy” – see catholicbishops.ie for both the bishops’ media statement and pastoral reflection on the Assembly Elections.
- “We appeal for a new and more constructive political culture, one based on a shared commitment to the common good and the priorities of citizens rather than on traditional constitutional issues” – see catholicbishops.ie for both the bishops’ media statement and pastoral reflection on the Assembly Elections.
- “The social and moral teaching of the Church is clear, that it is never morally acceptable to support any policy that undermines the sacred inviolability of the right to life of an innocent person in any circumstances” – see catholicbishops.ie for both the bishops’ media statement and pastoral reflection on the Assembly Elections.
The above are statements from the Irish bishops, with the suggestion that priests might like to include them in their bulletin next Sunday. The bishops, like everyone else, have a right – even a duty – to contribute to political debate. I’m going to offer a translation of the three paragraphs above.
Paragraph One: Translated – “Everybody should vote, because that’ll determine the Assembly and Executive”. I’m totally in agreement with that. It is, you might say, stating the bleeding obvious – or what should be the bleeding obvious. Everybody with a vote should use that vote.
Paragraph Two: Translated: “Ignore the constitutional question and focus exclusively on other matters.” I’m totally in disagreement with that. The notion that people should not be concerned about continued British jurisdiction from Westminster because that would mean they couldn’t focus on ‘bread-and-butter’ issues is part-laughable, part-insulting.
Paragraph Three: Translated- “Vote for the SDLP.” Since the three paragraphs are directed at church-going Catholics, we can assume (perhaps not?) that their Lordships are not thinking of encouraging voting for the DUP and have in mind the SDLP, which is opposed to abortion in all circumstances. I’m in total disagreement with this. I don’t think Sinn Féin have got it right by supporting abortion in cases such as ‘lethal foetal abnormality’, but because the clear between-the-lines signal of the bishops’ statement is to vote for the SDLP, and I would never urge any thinking person to do that. While I believe that abortion should not occur in cases of potentially-lethal abnormality – life itself is lethal – I also believe it shouldn’t occur in cases of rape or incest. If you believe in the protection of innocent human life, it seems to me logic drives you to that position. There are those in Sinn Féin who have similar beliefs – some of them have left the party, others have remained in the hope of changing party policy (Anne and Francie Brolly being cases in point). However, I accept that a great number of people sincerely believe something different, and I don’t think reducing a political party to a single issue is a good idea. Besides, despite what the bishops say, Church teaching for Catholics is always trumped by the individual conscience.
In the bad old days, the Catholic bishops, in particular Cardinal Daly, used to tell congregations they must not vote for Sinn Féin. But as one bemused parish priest at the time said to me “But they do!”.
It’ll be interesting to see the contortions of those who ache to bludgeon Sinn Féin on this one, while actually agreeing with their position.


Bishops have a duty to speak on political issues and offer advice to their faithful in all aspects of life.
Like you said, Jude, the catechism tells all Catholics to follow their conscience even to the point where it brings them into opposition to the teachings of The Church. So people are perfectly free to do as they please.
I will be following my conscience and will be abstaining come March so I’m in the bad books of the good Bishops on this one.
Cal, if you’re abstaining on voting, why even bother commenting on a political blog like this one, don’t you see the irony?
I have to admit, Gearóid, irony almost always goes over my head.
I am interested in politics but not in the slightest interested in seeing Stormont up and running again.
I don’t believe Stormont can advance nationalism. I will continue to vote in my local council elections but Stormont can jump.
Cal, if you cannot support the ONLY Irish republican party on this island trying to unite it, then you are not an Irish republican.
Do what you want with your vote but don’t at the same time claim to be an Irish republican, It doesn’t wash.
Hi Jude,
Don’t you think though, the question on abortion should be pretty high on peoples agenda? I mean future generations are depending on us to voter for a religiously pluralistic society that is capable of cooperating to defend human dignity from conception to natural death.
Wouldn’t you agree that to vote for a party in favour of making the womb a killing field is very wrong? And, in the next mandate, if a law is introduced to allow abortions then you have aided and abetted the lawmaker and thus an accomplice?
Given what’s at stake, i think the constitutional question is kind of superfluous! If we can’t look after the most vulnerable in society then whats the point of a UI, if we legalize the killing of its future citizens?
The only way to get a party to change policy is to tell them about your opposition and more importantly – not to vote for them.
” a party in favour of making the womb a killing field is very wrong?” – I think that’s overstating it a bit, Kieran. And I don’t think the constitutional question is superfluous – how could it be, when it goes to the heart of the state’s existence?
You may be right on “The only way to get a party to change policy is to tell them about your opposition and more importantly – not to vote for them.” I’m honestly not sure. Like many – eg., Peadar Tobin TD – I’m opposed to abortion – even, I suspect, more fully than the SDLP – but you need to make a distinction between permitting those who honestly believe it’s the right thing to do – have an abortion – and actually performing or encouraging others to do so. It’s a difficult one. The danger is that it eclipses every other plank of a political platform. Permitting governments to use your taxes to fund the armed forces – including the for-killing-innocent-civilians nuclear weapons – is surely at least as serious, yet i hear nothing from the bishops on this.
What men dressed in skirts say I find hard to take serious
yep,and what their at and have been at.you would imagine they would they would have brown begs over their heads along with their skirts.
On the issue of abortion I do believe that reducing a party to a single issue is right. Sinn Féin are pushing for abortion for sick and disabled children with life limiting conditions (fatal fetal abnormality is a media slogan not a medical term) Such abortions are late term and particularly gruesome, the child often been dismembered and in some cases he/she is given a lethal injection in the heart and then delivered dead. Any party who justifies and promotes this barbarism should be reduced to a single issue.. Last August you showed an image of a mangled little baby, a victim of a successful abortion and I admired your courage in doing so, how now can you defend a party that defends this? Is this not a fundamental issue for you?
Pól- thanks for your thoughts. I have mixed feelings on this. I know a lot of people who disagree with me that human life begins with conception. I know a lot more people who disagree with me that abortion of the ‘lethal/fatal foetal abnormality’ (I agree with you, there’s no such medical condition) and abortion for rape or incest is wrong – but I can’t bring myself to believe such people are insincere in what they believe, even though it runs counter to my own. I don’t accept that you can reduce a party to one issue from many – well you can but I don’t think it’s a good idea. No one has answered my comment re our taxes allowing the manufacture of weapons and the payment of men to use these in all sorts of circumstances. I suspect that many people who say life begins at conception haven’t considered what that means, just as those who deny life begins with conception haven’t thought what that means. I am suspicious of the Catholic (northern) bishops: they have a habit of being anti-republican and even nationalism, if you look at history. They may well be sincere in their views now, but I suspect there’s a little bit of anti-Shinner in there too.
Are the SDLP opposed to abortion in all circumstances? They were the only party who failed to provide a spokesperson when the subject was debated 2 nights ago on UTV.Eastwood was somewhat evasive in his talkback phone in when fatal foetal abnormality was mentioned,saying only that the reccomendations on the subject should be published.Likewise Hanna is kicking to touch,hiding behind the “lets see what ‘s being proposed on the matter.Maybe a more forthright journalist could actually nail them down on the issue?
I would be very reluctant to allow free for all abortion but if the occasion arose where my wife/daughter/granddaughter was told that she was carrying a foetus with no head or pregnant through rape or incest, I just don’t know what I would advise. I would do nothing but cry a few silent tears. Just as I would if pregnancy was impossible. But to legislate for English abortion law to come in here, to be used as you would a throwaway Kleenex, then I would vote for TUV first. But sure nationalism is oul’ hat and we have to ‘progress’.
But always remember that the church will follow the money. Always has from trouble started in Ireland. They are the establishment. They have excommunicated republicans, read them out from the altar and ostracised any priest with enough spirit to kick over the traces. They are the middle aged,middle class,middle of the road politicians at prayer.
The Catholic Hierarchy are very poor political guides.
In 1918 when de Valera descended on them like the Holy Ghost they condemned Conscription
on the grounds that the British Government had no mandate from the people of Ireland. When
the Irish people gave Sinn Fein a mandate to establish an Irish Republic the Bishops did not
recognise that Republic nor its parliament Dail Eireann. But when Dail Eireann and the Republican Courts were shouldered aside by an Irregular Junta, the Provisional Government
led by Michael Collins, the Bishops excommunicated the Republican Forces and raised no objections to the shooting and torture of prisoners by the junta. When that junta’s survivors
aped the strutting Blackshirts of Mussolini and the Brownshirts of Hitler and sponsored an
expeditionary force of Franco’s auxiliaries they had the blessings of the Hierarchy. They were less alarmed by the rise of Fascism that the lifting of hemlines.
I say this in sorrow, as a Catholic.
Fatal foetal abnormality means that their is no prospect of a baby being born alive.It does not mean”life limiting conditions”.Bernie Smith and her ilk have previously signed nomination papers for the DUP and urged support for the TUV.They sneak round chapels every election putting grossly untrue leaflets on car windscreens as they haven’t the guts to debate with people who would expose their lies.Their effect on elections is totally minimal. I would say ,based on electoral work for decades that they would,nt cost SF half a dozen votes on an electoral register of over 2000.
Foetal fatal abnormality means many things to many people, Michael. This is because it is not defined in any medical textbook. To legislate for an undefined medical condition will open the door to full implementation of the 1967 abortion act.
Pro abortion groups know this, which is why fatal foetal abnormality is the spear head for their campaign to change the law.
No one can know for sure if a child will survive outside the womb, and that is the insurmountable problem.
I don’t think I’d see that as a ‘problem’, Gearóid. I like the truth of what you say because it contradicts those who think they can make medical predictions about life and so think taking life is better. Something twisted there.
The constitutional question is not being decided in this election, nor is it even a major issue.
In fact Jude has stated more than once that this election should be about RHI all the way.
Why could voters not vote on other issues in the knowledge that they can still vote however they please in the event of a referendum
Surely this is as good an opportunity as we will get to vote on other issues including RHI, rather than just straight down the traditional divide.
And with the SDLP and the UU forming common cause there is even more opportunity to break down the old sectarian voting patterns.
As for abortion I can understand how it would be the most significant issue for those who believe life begins at conception. In fact I cannot see how it could not be since they must logically believe that hundreds if not thousands of innocent lives are going to be deliberately taken. What could be more important?
I am in favour of abortion being available myself so it is not a dilemma for me but I don’t see how one could take that view (against all abortion) yet vote for a party that would allow those lives to be taken.
If it is murder then sincerity is hardly a mitigating factor
fiosrach
Yes if there was a majority of Nationalists/Republicans in the assembly it might be put to the SOS that it was time for a referendum and personally I think it would be a reasonable viewpoint. It seems unlikely though given the numbers.
In the meantime the UU/SDLP opposition while they are not truly non-sectarian I agree,at least offer a chance for people to think outside their usual boxes.
On abortion are you of the view that is murder or perhaps manslaughter?
Would you not find it impossible to vote for a party that was advocating mass murder of the innocent?
(Yes, to save the whataboutery, just like the unionists)
Advocating?
fiosrach
What is your view.
Should those who consider any abortion to be killing the innocent not make that number one consideration? What could be more important?
You have to vote for the party that meets most of your aspirations or else don’t vote at all.
I’m not saying that it’s unreasonable or unlikely. Just that it was the UU reason for the pact. It didn’t work so we’ll try another angle. Mike is nothing if not resourceful and he has found a collection of dummies to work with him.
Mike Nesbitt said on Radio 2/3 Ulster that the reason he made a pre election pact with the DUP was that if a majority of MPs returned were not unionist then this would be taken as a signal by the Britishers to run a Border poll. And secondly, where did you ever get the notion that the SDLP and the UUP were not sectarian?
maybe after the election with direct rule a good possibility we can get this place dragged into 2017.people around the civilised world laugh at the draconian laws still in place here,no abortion shops,no sex shops,no paying for sex,no gay marriage ect,never,never,never,never.lol but as bob would sing the times are a changing.
Protestant agrees with Catholic Bishops.
Catholic sounds like a Protestant: “Besides, despite what the bishops say, Church teaching for Catholics is always trumped by the individual conscience.”
Catholic Bishops sound like Catholics.
In other news, the Pope is a Catholic; isn’t he?
are we to believe that SDLP voters do not avail of abortions?
I don’t think that’s Jude’s point, Bridget.
What one of his points does appear to be, however, is that one can be against the termination of a human life and yet vote for candidates who would support the implementation of a law which would allow that.
In this election, if I am offered the choice of Unionist candidates who are pro-abortion, they will not receive my vote.
PF
I think your observation is well and succinctly made.If I read Jude’s blog and follow up responses correctly,he seems to be saying that no one is more anti-abortion than him,but at the same time feel free to vote for a party that is not unsympathetic to an abortion position.He also suggests that the Northern bishops are implicitly advising Nationalists to vote S D L P which in his world is abhorrent given his obvious Sinn Fein sympathies.Is anybody seriously suggesting that in 2017,Catholics will meekly obey the contents of pastoral letters from the Hierarchy? Surely that era has passed!
Argenta
There comes a point, and it has more or less arrived for me, when a choice has to be made between one’s preferred national identity, and one’s morality.
PF
I don’t share your views on abortion, but you at least seem to be consistent in your thinking.
Why is it not a dealbreaker for everyone who feels as you do, given that it presumably means the murder or at least manslaughter of innocents
Could the constitutional issue really be more important?
I am proudly Catholic, but have always proudly disagreed with God’s management team.
fiosrach, you;re just an old cynic, when has the Irish Catholic Church ever just followed the money, eh, no, wait, I was in Maynooth last weekend.
The British paid for Maynooth, Mark, so they could supervise the loyalties of the priests that were being let loose among the peasants and to ensure they tend the line.
Toed
I know, and not only Maynooth
The majority of people don’t really think about the abortion issue; they just go with the flow or are led by the nose on this topic. However I believe it is unfair to demonise those people who are fervently opposed to abortion. They have the right to speak and should not be mocked or dismissed as eejits. I also believe that if documentaries were made and instances of abortion were filmed I would guess more people would have an opinion on this issue. Seeing what you are voting for really could be a game changer; it would certainly sharpen ones focus on the issue.
As for the Catholic Church and their bishops? Well they can just do one. I couldn’t give a flying fxxx what they think or say. Abortion isn’t about religion it’s about morality.
Yeah, I can see real problems for people if they have to watch video of women washing down a pair of pills with a glass of water. And then repeating that a scene again a few days later.
Oh the propaganda coup that would be for the anti-abortion lobby would just be… erm… what are you on about, because it’s more than little bit obvious that you don’t have clue number one about abortion.
The abortion problem is trivial to solve. If you don’t like abortions, don’t have one. If you want to impose your view on someone else well then you can take a long walk off a short pier.
exactly.
So you have no views on the subject, gendjinn?
Indeed I do and my views apply solely to whatever womb I may have. They have little relevance to anyone else’s womb and I would certainly not impose them on anyone else.
If only the religious were capable of similar levels of respect. Alas.
Morals are not the sole preserve of the religious. Many people of little or no religion find abortion repugnant.
gendjinn
“They(your views) have little relevance to anyone else’s womb and I would certainly not impose them on anyone else.”
Do they have any relevance to what is in whatever womb you may have – I mean I hadn’t sealed we were talking about aborted wombs.
Oh, and what about secular opponents of abortion, or is it only religious people you would like to see drown themselves?
“Morals are not the sole preserve of the religious. Many people of little or no religion find abortion repugnant.”
Exactly.
“The abortion problem is trivial to solve. If you don’t like abortions, don’t have one. If you want to impose your view on someone else well then you can take a long walk off a short pier.”
So you are all for abortion and suicide then? Nice. With views like this you make he DUP more appealing.
“Oh the propaganda coup that would be for the anti-abortion lobby would just be… erm… what are you on about, because it’s more than little bit obvious that you don’t have clue number one about abortion.”
It was only a suggestion but reading through your hostility to my suggestion I suspect your sanitised version of an abortion is disingenuous to say the least and furthermore suggests there are aspects to abortion that you would like to remain hidden which speaks volumes.
“I hadn’t realised” (Predictive type is such a pain at times.)