‘Let’s Open an encouraging new chapter urges the Guardian’ by Joe McVeigh

As already noted on this site, the Guardian yesterday (Feb20) devoted the leading editorial to Brexit and Ireland. The Guardian is a pro-British newspaper which favours the Labour party over the Conservatives. I suppose we should be thankful for getting such attention in a Saxon newspaper. However, the writer seems to think it would be better for the north if the SDLP and the Unionist party were running the show! He hopes that the people will go out to vote for middle of the road parties! He does not think SF is up for it! And it would be too much to expect Ms Foster to stand down.

The editorial states that Ms Foster would not resign because to do so would be seen by Nationalists as a victory and by Unionists as a defeat. The fact is that Arlene Foster was not asked to resign her position as First Minister by Sinn Fein. She was asked to step aside for the duration of an Inquiry and she refused. The editorial continues: “Sinn Fein therefore collapsed the executive and fresh elections were called. Yet there seems little likelihood that the outcome will soften the current rigidity between the two sides. Ms Foster cannot afford to bend on the RHI row..a renewed stand-off seems inevitable which might in turn trigger renewed direct rule…It (DR) could be avoided if the two main parties-or the UK government- wanted to avoid it badly enough. The problem right now is that they don’t. But a stand-off would also be avoided if Northern Ireland’s voters prized the peace process highly enough to vote for parties that were more flexible about wanting it to work. Both the nationalist SDLP and the once mighty Ulster Unionists should offer that option, as the Alliance party does. All should encourage second preference voting across sectarian lines in the proportional representation system. It is time for this to happen. It would open an encouraging new chapter for Northern Ireland if it did.”

Some months ago the Guardian gave space to Arlene Foster to write in favour of Brexit. I wrote a reply but they said it was too long. I shortened it considerably to the required 250 words but they never published it.

That was before the hullabaloo about RHI. I am thinking they will have to give her some space now to write about Gerry Adams and how terrible it would be if SF became the largest party in the north of Ireland. (By the way, I was told yesterday by an Ulster Unionist councillor who called at my door looking for me to vote Ulster Unionist! that I should never refer to this place as ‘the north of Ireland’. I was told that is ‘republican language!! I asked if I should use ‘the six counties and he went apoplectic.)

Anyway, back to the Guardian newspaper which probably sells about three dozen copies in the north of Ireland. The writer of this nonsense in the Guardian seems to think that a government coalition of SDLP and the ‘once mighty’ Ulster Unionist party would open a new chapter. Just ignore the will of the majority of the people as in the Brexit vote. Those who vote for SF and who advocate a re-united Ireland should not be in government according to this warped thinking.

The editor of the Guardian should know by now that there is already another encouraging new chapter being written about the future of this small island. That’s why the only concern of Arlene and the DUP is SF –sorry correction- Gerry Adams and SF. I didn’t hear her saying anything about People before Profit?

13 Responses to ‘Let’s Open an encouraging new chapter urges the Guardian’ by Joe McVeigh

  1. Brian Patterson February 21, 2017 at 5:20 pm #

    I stopped buying the Guardian when Henry McDonald became their Irish correspondent.

  2. giordanobruno February 21, 2017 at 6:19 pm #

    Nonsense.
    How would a government of coalition between the SDLP and the UU be ignoring the will of the people if that is what the people vote for.
    What is a pro British newspaper?One that is published and read in Britain?
    In what way should it be anti British?

    • jessica February 21, 2017 at 10:01 pm #

      What the people vote for, is indeed the will of the people.
      When a newspaper tells the people who they should vote for to meet their best interests, that is something else entirely.

      • giordanobruno February 22, 2017 at 7:35 am #

        jessica
        All newspapers do this at election times.
        Are you saying none should be allowed to express their view?
        That would be hard to enforce.
        Should the Andytown News be prevented from encouraging people to vote SF too?

  3. MT February 21, 2017 at 6:26 pm #

    A very confused article.

  4. fiosrach February 21, 2017 at 6:49 pm #

    Is that good or bad,MT?

  5. Eolach February 21, 2017 at 7:12 pm #

    MT ,”A very confused article”…..I don’t think something inanimate like print can be “confused”…..CONFUSING ,…. to the reader, perhaps ? , and I’m not just being pedantic. Yes , Gio ,the Guardian is a British newspaper and when it’s writing about the affairs in another country it should at least try to be impartial….appear at he minimum to be an honest broker and maybe perhaps present some facts .It is the continual interference of Britain ,most notably England , in our affairs that has left us in this sectarian cesspit. As long as England gives succour to Unionism ,corruption and racism will abound….Unionism never could and never will be to stand on their own two feet….they will never be able to say to themselves ,Sinn Féin !!!

  6. jessica February 22, 2017 at 8:08 am #

    Not at all gio.
    This site is an outlet for those trying to balance the one sided view of establishment media which is so blatantly anti Sinn Fein it can be sickening.
    Yet that seems to irk you even though there is plenty of anti Sinn Fein views on this site also.

    After 10 years of Sinn Fein reaching out to unionism and all of the problems that made the institutions unworkable coming from the unionist side, not one broadsheet supported the only arrangement that hasn’t been tried. Sinn Fein / UUP. Why?

    Fortunately people are becoming immune to media bias.

    • paddykool February 22, 2017 at 8:56 am #

      Yes ..we might as well nail this one again .Just to be clear. Sinn Fein tried their damnnest to make an accomodation across the community and make the thing work. There are too many examples of that and Martin McGuinness ‘s outreach is well documented.So let us start right thereThe DUP did no outreach ; indeed they did the exact opposite and bad-mouthed nationalism at eevery opportunity.Let’s stick to the facts of why the Executive ended.It didn’t end because of Sinn Fein or the UUP or Alliance or the SDLP or the Greens. It ended because of a whole series of scandals emanating from the DUP.Then the very office of FMDFM was put into a tailspin by the leader of the DUP , Arlene Foster who was tainted by the RHI scandal and got herself into a vile spat with one of her own colleagues over it.She was asked to step to one side momentarily to save the status of the office and instead went off on a solo rant further damaging it .she was very obviously out of control at that point.She had to be removed and the only way available, every other party having left her to talk to the wide blue heavens , was to close the office door.
      Those are the cold facts that everyone wants to quickly forget.All this talk about the Sinn Fein and the DUP not being to work together is nonsense.The DUP couldn’t do the very things the office required and that is why the whole thing crashed .They were incapable of making that stretch unto the future and they still are.Let’s not pretend that it was anyone else’s fault.Had any party…even the UUP acted like the DUP did , then the result would have been the very same .The DUP had no respect for the office of FMDFM, so if they are voted into power again the question will still be ..are they capable of making the stretch?

    • giordanobruno February 22, 2017 at 9:43 am #

      jessica
      I am unclear.
      Do you think newspapers should be allowed to take an editorial line on which party they think people should vote for or do you think they should not?

  7. Brian Patterson February 22, 2017 at 8:48 am #

    You can be sure the “Guardian” editorial was heavily influenced by – if not actually written by – the paper’s ‘Ireland correspondent’ Henry McDonald. A visceral loather of all vestiges of Irish Republicanism.

    • fiosrach February 22, 2017 at 10:49 am #

      Did Henry McDonald not used to be an Official republican?

  8. jessica February 22, 2017 at 10:01 am #

    If you put it like that then no, not so blatantly absolutely not.

    But more than that, I think the media have a responsibility to behave impartially and in the best interests of the people. When they use or indeed abuse the influence they undeniably have to assist one particular group of people then where do we draw the line.

    I am all for free speech and freedom of expression but when it becomes one sided and especially when negative partiality is expressed then it becomes counter productive and indeed borderline abuse.

    We do not need any more opinions, what we are short of is facts.

    I want to see proper debate on what the best future is for Ireland, unity or partition.
    I want expert recognised economists to provide the opinions, not broadsheets.
    I want political parties to be a part of that but not leading that.
    I want businesses to be afforded their views as the employers and wealth creators our economy relies on.

    The idea that businesses rely on the state more than the state relies on business is fallacy and needed to be clarified. Without private enterprise, our standard of living would nose dive.

    There is too much opinionated bullshit already. We don’t need more from our media, we need intelligent and informed debate.