It is interesting to read the different views on the outcome of the recent election, on what it means and no-one is denying that it was Sinn Fein’s day. It was indeed a watershed election and has the potential to change things in Ireland forever.
But having deliberated over it and given up on the number crunching as there is insufficient data, the biggest conclusion I come to is that I have been very wrong about unionism and that people like AG and Peter among others have been right all along.
The DUP do not represent unionism and possibly never have done.
The bottom line for me is that this election result seems to have leap frogged years of demographic change. Either there has been a bigger shift than expected in demographic change or there has been an increase in the number of Protestants who have voted for Sinn Fein
There has also undeniably been a huge increase in the number of UUP transfers to the SDLP which has undeniably cost unionism seats. It is hard to see how the loss of these seats to unionism is not directly linked to the example given by Mike Nesbitt over transferring to the SDLP.
Obviously I don’t know Mike, but he clearly has integrity in stepping aside when he gets things wrong and that has to be respected and a lesson to some political leaders on how to lead by example.
For me, his dream was to see his beloved UUP party back on top and representing unionism, and he tried desperately to make that happen. The problem was he was too desperate and made some bad choices to achieve it.
First of all, he tried bigotry to win back DUP votes but it failed and resulted in attacks on the Alliance party and a bitter and costly flags protest.
He tried a unionist pact with active loyalist paramilitaries who were intimidating large numbers of people in their community and who aren’t wanted by the majority and are abhorrent to middle unionism.
His party having failed embarrassingly in health while in the executive, he then tried instead shirking responsibility entitlements enshrined in the GFA to instead take the easier route of opposition and to simply criticise everything that the Executive did to garner votes. In the end he tried what he should have tried first, to reach out and work with nationalists.
The problem was he could not accept who nationalists chose to represent them but rather tried to persuade nationalists to drop Sinn Fein and move to the SDLP which in itself is arrogance.
Not surprisingly this failed and cost the UUP unionist transfers, but was indeed successful in increasing transfers to the SDLP. The Alliance received most of these middle unionist votes.
So we have Protestants voting for Sinn Fein of their own accord and with gentle leadership, unionists transferring to nationalists. It is hard to equate that with the actions of sectarian bigots.
The question for me is, does this mean the DUP are totally relying on the sectarian fear card to maintain their own electoral supremacy and if so, how can this ever deliver anything positive?
And if the reason for Sinn Fein’s success is not the demographic shift but the fact through reaching out, they are defeating this DUP illusion and gradually tearing down the walls of mistrust which divide us, then it seems pretty clear where we need to go.
There cannot be unity without trust. The biggest harm that partition is inflicting is economic and social failur,e and the return of the border will end the peace process which is what I believe an element within unionism actually wants, along with their partners in crime, continuity republicans. These people need to be isolated and not allowed to grow any support in either community.
If a united Ireland is the only way for the north to remain within the EU customs area, then that is what must happen along with a new federal arrangement with Britain to satisfy unionist concerns.
It seems to me that our common enemy is fear and mistrust, and a solution agreeable to this new middle ground emerging has to be pursued and encouraged.
If during these negotiations, the DUP remain intransigent in terms of Arlene stepping aside, showing respect, supporting an Irish Language Act and embracing equality, then I would like to see the UUP, Alliance and Sinn Fein proposing a voluntary coalition with Mike Nesbitt returning to the UUP and taking the role of joint first minister with Sinn Fein holding 4 seats at the executive, UUP 2 and Alliance 2. If I am right about Mike, then I believe he deserves this opportunity and we may yet all benefit from it.
This would require dropping St Andrews which the DUP reneged on anyway, and reverting to the original GFA where parties nominate and receive cross-party support on the Assembly floor.
Could these three parties work together and make politics here work? Would the UUP come on board and would Mike Nesbitt return to lead the UUP under such circumstances?
Mark, you are familiar with the legalities of these things. Is this even a possibility under the terms of the GFA? From memory in its original format it is.


Jessica,
The number crunching is well underway and detailed analysis will be forthcoming as the detailed information becomes available on the electoral office website. In particular myself and the legendary Faha, are now looking at what the implications may be for forthcoming elections if the level of nationalist voter engagement can be maintained.
You’re more than welcome to pop in for a nosey and feel free to comment.
https://bangordub.wordpress.com
The bottom line bangordub, is if we lose the momentum to achieve change and end the cycle of orange and green elections moving towards bread and butter issues and dealing with each other respectfully then the next time out could revert back to how it was last may.
I would prefer to see meaningful change for the better and I am willing to try to change myself to help make it happen
I transferred my vote to the SDLP after UUP. (It would never have gone to SF and I don’t think many did from the Unionist community)
This is a very honest post, regarding the realization that not all Unionists are Pailseyites….or bigoted… I wonder how many SF / SDLP voters transferred in reciprocation?
But what has this been rewarded with? Triumphalism from Republicans.
I think the earth has moved politically, perhaps not in the way you think. Everyone I spoke to at the weekend would NEVER (never never) transfer their votes outside of Unionism again. The election proved that it IS a head count and Unionism will circle wagons and move towards (back to ) a single Unionist Party.
That is exactly what I am saying Joe.
If unionists don’t see any return for their investment in reaching out, they will revert back to how things were, which would be a shame.
I can only speak for myself, but I transferred a vote to the UUP in an effort to see off the DUP candidate in my constituency, so transfers do go both ways. As Boondock says below ‘Lets not forget in Upper Bann and East Derry the UUP transfers actually helped SDLP oust SF’ – Unionism would do well to note this. Had those two seats gone to SF instead of the SDLP we would be looking at 29/28 in favour of SF and Michelle O’Neill as First Minister. As bad an election as it was for Unionism, it could have been worse.
I don’t believe there has been any ‘triumphalism from Republicans’ outside of the general jubilation that comes from a successful election although I accept that my perspective is perhaps a different one to yours. It is worth bearing in mind that Irish nationalists have waited a long time for this day, and that the Northern Irish state has not been kind to them.
Expecting an election here to be anything other than a sectarian headcount seems baffling to me. Northern Ireland’s SOLE raison d’être was to create a state which gave an inbuilt majority to Unionism. It is a sectarian state. Nearly 100 years later that majority has gone, and is unlikely ever to return. The formation of a single Unionist party would merely be a tacit acknowledgement that the game is up.
Those of a protestant/unionist background are not one single homogenous culture – the 20 year old pro-choice woman has little in common with the 80 year old Presbyterian Orangeman – so the creation of a monolithic Unionist party seems massively reductive to me. Given that it would likely be lead by the OO/RBP/Evangelical wing of Unionism it would offer little to those who do not adhere to this ideology. The problem with circling the wagons is that life eventually just carries on around you.
“Northern Ireland’s SOLE raison d’être was to create a state which gave an inbuilt majority to Unionism. It is a sectarian state.”
By that reasoning, an all-Ireland state’s SOLE raison d’être was to create a state which gave an inbuilt majority to nationalism and would be a sectarian state.
I’m going to bed MT, although I do enjoy our little chats.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Irish_general_election,_1918
That was particularly frustrating for me.
Had Sinn Fein got just 1200 more 1st preferences off a 69 year old who does nothing for nationalists outside the well to do areas that had already retired with a handsome pay-out then they would have been the largest party with the most seats.
I hope the Delores fan club in Craigavon are proud off themselves.
I gave a Unionist a vote for the first time in my life out of respect for Mike Nesbitt. It was the saddest sight to see him walking out of that count centre alone. I think things just happened too quickly and hope exceeded expectation. I think Sinn Fein genuinely want things to work and people voted SF because M McGuinness has tried hard to make things work. The DUP had a particularly nasty bunch this time who were very provocative. It would be a pity if things returned to what they were but I don’t share the general consensus that we are at a watershed moment. I hope I’m wrong.
I wonder when republicans will emancipate themselves from their death cult and reciprocate?
We shall overcome.
speaking of partners in crime..three men from albania have been arrested in the north in possession of a loaded gun two of them only arrived in dublin last week and claimed refugee status.will you leave the country open to these continuity robbers and murderers.good comment though on leaders knowing when to step down.
Wow.
I doubt Protestants voted SF.
As for been wrong etc.
The vote for the DUP went up remember.
so many inaccuracies in this piece.
As for the election itself.And leaving the article aside.
I am NOT Triumphant,
I view it as I do Brighton and the Grand Hotel.( remember that one ? )
Close… but No cigar.
The exhurbance about this election reminds me in a rather nauseous way about the tomfoolery that flows whenever the Oirish Soccer team loses…Again.
Don’t forget Irish history.
Coming in Second.. is nothing NEW. for Nationalism
Nothing at all.
Only a Gombeanista would think different.
BTW . Above I had to make reference to the Oirish Soccer team.
To prove a point.
I detest Soccer.
I detest Irish Soccer
And I detest Sports Methaphors.
Please don’t make me have to write another one….ever.
In other words wise up.
Which bit is inaccurate oz
Jessica.
You’re wrong about protestants voting for SF.
SF got close to the DUP as a result Nationalists voting.
I very much doubt you will find more than 1 to 2 % of Protestants voting for SF. ( this is not new )
Also as per the DUP Not representing Unionism.
Their overall vote went UP.
So that is wrong also.
Despite all the scandals.
I suspect people voted SF this time due to Martin McGuinesss’ ill health.
particularly evident in Derry and the Foyle etc.
Jessica,
I doubt very many protestants voted sF.
The usual 1 to 2 %
And the DUP Do represent unionism. As they got a higher number of votes this time round.
I think that there has been an increase in the number of protestants who voted sinn fein
Why shouldn’t protestants be voting for sinn fein?
Unionists transferred to nationalists against the advice of the Dup
We have to start looking at things differently if we are to unite this country
Heard Gregory Campbell on the radio earlier and the mood is softening over a Irish language/minority languages act.
The main sticking point to even kick off negotiations seems to the if Arlene Foster stays or goes in the interim. Both parties are digging their heels in over that one, but my question is it really worth it if they can get movement elsewhere?
Let’s be honest the inquiry will decide Arlenes fate. If it’s bad her position is untenable, if it exonerated her she can rightfully stay as FM.
It isn’t sinn fein digging in over Arlene, the nationalist community will not tolerate her coming back into any executive first minister or not
And do you think that redline of Arlene not being first minister is worth holding on to if there is a willingness to move on things such as the ILA?
If SF don’t budge and the DUP don’t budge then there’s no alternative other than direct rule.
I am just telling you how it is
There are far more people furious with Arlene than want an irish language act
If sinn fein accept Arlene as some sort of grubby deal it will cost them in the long run
What happens then in a few months time IF, and it’s a big if, the public inquiry finds no signs of corruption?
Would SF demand that she still can’t be nominated FM.
So virtuous. Do you understand Unionists’ reluctance to work with terrorists now?
They’re not.
“The bottom line for me is that this election result seems to have leap frogged years of demographic change. Either there has been a bigger shift than expected in demographic change or there has been an increase in the number of Protestants who have voted for Sinn Fein”
Jessica, he reason nationalists made gains because there was a higher turnout of nationalist voters. There’s been no ‘great demographic leap’ and Protestants haven’t been voting for SF.
“There has also undeniably been a huge increase in the number of UUP transfers to the SDLP which has undeniably cost unionism seats. It is hard to see how the loss of these seats to unionism is not directly linked to the example given by Mike Nesbitt over transferring to the SDLP.”
Nesbitt may have encouraged additional transfers but there have always been lots of unionists who would transfer SDLP before DUP and this number will have increased because of RHI, Foster’s arrogance and general incompetence, over use of POC and anti-gay and anti-abortion stances. This would have happened regardless of Nesbitt.
“Obviously I don’t know Mike, but he clearly has integrity in stepping aside when he gets things wrong and that has to be respected and a lesson to some political leaders on how to lead by example.”
I don’t think he should have resigned. He was at the state of a new project and partnership with the SDLP and led the UUP to a vote increase despite the St Andrews handicap they now face every election.
The hysteria over mike and his transfer comments is ridiculous. I reckon all those uup transfers got nationalism one whole seat ie lagan valley. People need to stop trying to make out that all 16 unionist losses are down to mike. Lets not forget in upper bann and east derry the uup transfers actually helped sdlp oust SF and actually save the DUP from the humiliation of having fewer seats than SF. Poots and co should take another look at their sums
The unionist losses are down to the DUP and in particular Arlene Foster who showed nationalists that unionism still looks down their noses at us, that they still see us as second class and that our needs come second to their british fixation.
Mikes gesture did influence some unionists to vote nationalist and whether or not it was the intention, it was the result.
There has to be an opportunity here and it would be a shame if it was lost.
It was the DUP who made this mess, it is the DUP who should suffer, not Mike or his party or anyone else.
If we want real change then all of the parties have to stand together against the DUP to deliver it.
Mike has shown the way, Will everyone else have the courage to follow it up and not give the DUP another chance to spread their hate?
Form a voluntary coalition without the DUP in it.
Unionists reluctant to work with terrorists? Such as the UDR, the UDA, the Third Force, appearing on platforms with Loyalist paramilitaries, allocating money to fronts for loyalist paramilitaries, funding UDA “Community workers”?
Yes Brian so they tell us.
As for willie McCrea sharing a stage with All round nice guy and salt of the earth Sectarian psychopath Billie Wright.
We’re not supposed to know that.
And as for the Belfast Smella graph and their Unionist terror chums ” graduated response ” over the fleg.
Well that’s just ancient history.
As for the Vanguard Movement and that Bill Craig fellow asking people to ”
“We must build up the dossiers on the men and women who are a menace to this country, because one day, ladies and gentlemen, if the politicians fail, it will be our duty to liquidate the enemy.
And the enemy been people who are not “loyal”
Unionism falls in the Joseph Goebbals school
of the Bigger the Lie the more often if should be repeated school of journalism
It’s shocking the duality of unionists about the place.
The following is taken from MT’s post.
”Jessica, the reason nationalists made gains because there was a higher turnout of nationalist voters. There’s been no ‘great demographic leap’ and Protestants haven’t been voting for SF.”
How do you know MT? Evidence please.
“The following is taken from MT’s post.
”Jessica, the reason nationalists made gains because there was a higher turnout of nationalist voters. There’s been no ‘great demographic leap’ and Protestants haven’t been voting for SF.”
How do you know MT? Evidence please.”
Are you being serious?
1. Differential turnouts in nationalist majority areas compared to unionist majority areas.
2. The mathematical impossibility of huge demographic change occurring in the space of ten months.
For someone usually so pedantic about evidence, you are pushing this line with very little substance in terms of evidence MT.
I am curious, would it annoy you to learn that protestants had been voting for Sinn Fein MT?
Is that not the direction we are going in to remove the orange and green groundhog day from society?
“For someone usually so pedantic about evidence, you are pushing this line with very little substance in terms of evidence MT”
It’s your theory. Up to you to provide evidence of Protestants voting PSF.
Well, Sinn Fein have been reaching out to unionists for 10 years in spite of being poorly treated and disrespected in return.
They have respected the british identity in Ireland and are trying to build bridges and break down the divisions between our communities.
So what I could give you us reasons why protestants might vote for Sinn Fein.
It will lead to a better future for all of us and more importantly for our children.
It will lead to better governance and hopefully better living conditions and prospects for people in impoverished areas which exist in both communities.
Perhaps it will help lead to us being one community, an Irish community and happy in our own land.
It will help Sinn Fein promote their message which is to build bridges not burn them as the DUP would prefer.
For slow learners like myself it is only sinking in now after this election has shown what is possible through building and encouraging positive relationships and showing respect rather than scorn.
Would you be disappointed to learn that protestants were voting for Sinn Fein MT?
So you’ve no evidence?
You don’t need evidence to voice an option on the question I asked you MT.
Would you be disappointed to learn that protestants were voting for Sinn Fein?
“You don’t need evidence to voice an option on the question I asked you MT.”
Of course not, but you weren’t ‘voicing an option’. You were suggesting this us what happened.
“Would you be disappointed to learn that protestants were voting for Sinn Fein?”
Of course. I’m disappointed that anyone could.vote for such a despicable movement.
Why do you feel sinn fein are behaving dispicably?
opinion
mention today about wages being stopped will soon concentrate minds in the competition to see who can implement english tory rule in ireland.money or the withdrawal of it always seems to have that effect.
Nationalist vote up 73k. Unionist vote up 28k Others up 7k.
Alliance vote was up 24k but that was a consolidation of various independent/other votes and a modest increase in turnout.
All this on a 65% turnout. The GFA turnout was 81% so there are plenty more out there to mine. Every year the majority of those that die are Unionist and the under 18s are Nationalist. It is simply a matter of tick, tick, tick. Brexit is the final nail. Any chance of Catholic Unicorns making a home in the UK ends with the exit from the EU. Based on the Lucid Talk tracker poll there is a growing chunk of Unionism that is warming to UI/EU over UK/Brexit.
In the face of a hard Brexit a border poll in 12 to 18 months is winnable. Two years into a hard Brexit a border poll victory is guaranteed.
Regardless of Brexit Nationalism will be an electoral majority in ten years.
When article 50 is triggered, Ireland will need to look after its own interests and by that I mean all 32 counties led by Dublin.
The EU have offered a smooth transition for the north through a unification referendum, it would be unfeasible for anyone to deny us that referendum.
Over the two years of negotiations, Ireland will have some big decisions to make.
Whether we unite under the UK and abandon the EU putting all of our faith in the UK who still denies being a combatant in a conflict it along with unionism started, that still calls us terrorists and that still protects its state murderers.
Or if we might be better off respecting the majority wish to remain in the EU and discussing how better off we might be united outside of the UK but within the EU.
That referendum would need to take place before 2019 and I doubt any bookmaker would back it to fail.
But I would not want that referendum to be a sectarian headcount but an expression of informed opinion based on reliable and fact based economic appraisal and international declarations of support for Ireland undertaking a new beginning especially from the US our largest export partner.
we had the referendum last year,brexit starts in a couple of weeks and stormont has no plan in place as mike pointed out several times in his interviews.maybe after ten years or so after a hard border being in place it might feature in a border poll,then again they might like the benefits of brexit especially when they see the way the south will be left as europe falls apart at the seems.
What odds are you giving that right now SF is demanding a border poll as part of the return to Stormont deal?
In ten years time when Nationalism has 10 of the 17 MPs, 50 MLAs, and is a majority on Belfast City Council as well as on a majority of councils. How will you feel about a UI when Sinn Fein is running the six counties? Because that is what the Union will look like.
paddy power will give you 9/2 if theres a border poll called by the end of 2020,that good odds if your so sure,have your shirt onit.
I am more concerned with the plans Dublin has billy.
The DUP caused Stormonts problems because Arlene couldn’t accept good honest advice from Martin McGuinness
The option of rejoining the UK is a non-starter. How many famines did Ireland have under British administration? How many did India? And elsewhere in the British empire? Compare to the number of famines occurred in England during the same period?
Partition is the problem, until it is gone the problems besetting Northern Ireland will not be solved and the tribal headcount will continue. If the place was going to work, it would be working by now. Brexit is going to hammer that point home ruthlessly.
Re-unification is the only viable remaining solution, time to be getting on with it.
Re-unification is more inevitable than ever and getting on with it is exactly what I want to see happen.
But there remains a protestant majority in the north and I would rather not wait 10 years for that to reverse but to resolve the problem now while unionism is strong and agree a settlement that the middle ground will feel comfortable with.
Part of this will be how to merge too disparate economies when one is a right wing thriving economy even if poorly governed and wasteful. I don’t see the south accepting unification if it means a total swing to a marxist socialist state however and the referendum will be a single 32 county affair requiring consensus on both sides.
I very much do not want you to be my enemy at any stage in the future but I do want a new Ireland to be a strong vibrant economy with opportunities for both our children in Ireland and those overseas that they may come home and I will fight for that.
So what if there is a “Protestant” majority in the six counties? There won’t be one in the 32 and I am still waiting for a single Unionist to point to a single clause in Bunreacht na hÉireann they object to.
This is a grasp the nettle firmly situation. Read Wilhelm Reich’s piece on the Mass Psychology of Fascism, along with the wiki entry on Limbic Resonance. The best way to handle the north, is vote to unify asap. Move in quickly, firmly with bucket loads of southern Gardai. Just how it was handled in 1922/23 during the civil war – a much overlooked and amazing accomplishment by the Free State govt.
You are obviously smart and passionate but not aware of how little you actually know. And you tend to be more interested in being right than hearing what the other person is saying. It is the age old curse of youth. And if we are fortunate we live long enough to grow out of it. Which is all wisdom really is, being lucky enough to survive long enough to accumulate enough mistakes to realise your errors.
How many non-fiction books do you read a month?
Why is it held to be obvious that a chaotic, unplanned market is always superior to a centralized, planned economy? In the US medicare spends 97% of its budget on health care, 3% on administration. The private health insurance spends 80% on health care and 20% on admin. And that’s because the ACA capped the 20%, it was higher before. Why was it that in every single instance of public utilities that Thatcher privatized the cost to the public went up and the quality of service went down. Now the trains are being renationalized, I remember when you could take a train direct from Holyhead into Paddington station.
What works for clothes, cars, books, kettles does not work for water, heating, electricity, roads, armies.
But much, much more important than any ethical, moral or philosophical question is that capitalism causes climate change. Climate change will kill all life unless capitalism is reigned in.
Survival trumps all else. Your children, my children and their children will DIE unless the course is radically altered. But “marxist socialist state” is bad, well that’s Cuba and it is a hell of a lot better than being dead.
They didn’t do much to help in 1969, so I wont hold my breath for a southern invasion now, but I will thank you for the response.
To be honest I can see where you are coming from, I am an opinionated git and a bit of a mouth but I certainly don’t think I know it all and I don’t read any books whatsoever fiction or otherwise. Whatever opinions I express are my own and influenced by many including people like yourself who take the time to engage with me.
My interest is not about being right, I have little interest in that whatsoever, what I do have is a strong desire to be free of british rule and I would consider myself to be more screwed up in the head over it than a know all. But as I say, I can see how you might have come to than conclusion.
Believe it or not I do listen to others a lot actually, and I am not afraid to admit when I am wrong or change my views when someone makes more sense than I do.
Though I am stubborn so I don’t always catch on right away and it can take a few goes.
It is when I hear people like Eamon McCann talking about nationalising Moy Park I cringe as it makes far left politics sound fanatical and abhorrent to me.
That sort of nonsense talk will do unification more harm than good.
I would be quite keen on Jeremy Corbyn and I agree with you about the health service being better back in the day when there were sisters on the wards to run a tight ship.
What is wrong with the british national health service is it is underfunded to deliver those sort of service levels.
Thatcher made england a wealthy nation, took industry and shored it up in the south and made London a wealthy financial capital of the world, but profits were not redirected back into public services and the funding of the health service was not increased above the rate of inflation which meant operational costs over wages and pensions increased dramatically along with the demands of a rapidly growing population also living longer while funding did not increase to match this.
But I am not really interested in what britain do with their NHS, I am more interested in making Ireland a wealthy country so we can build an Irish National Health Service that will look after our own people with Irish priorities not british. Let the Tories do what they want in England, they can screw the BNHS into the ground for all I care. If we don’t like it we can always opt to leave via referendum which is what I want.
I don’t see capitalism as an ideology. I can see how corporate greed which may be inspired by capitalism can damage the environment and I am very much opposed to this and very keen on Ireland investing in and developing renewable energy. I fully believe that Ireland could be 100% self sufficient on renewables and could develop this into an exportable industry which would help further reduce the negative impact of climate change.
My preference would not be for Ireland to be reunited by force but through a genuine honest debate involving the worlds best economists and strategists, members of both states as well as local businesses and churches etc… I don’t care what britain wants for or from Ireland, only that they honour their agreement to accommodate self determination and afford us the opportunity to make an informed choice over unity and building a new Ireland.
No Jessica, they did precious little in 69 to their continued shame. I can tell you that the country was ready to march in but Lynch decided not to. For a moment at least, but that passed and soon it was only the brave 10% that would express anything approaching pro-Republican support until the GFA. I remember when stating the Birmingham 6 were innocent meant you supported terrorism because you were spouting Republic conspiracy theories. However, it will be different once a border poll is won.
You gotta read, you gotta stand on the shoulders of giants. You got to pour as much knowledge into your mind as possible. It’s the fastest way. Definitely got to thrash ideas out online and in person, but that is no substitute. You got to continue your education or you will end up in your own bubble.
Grab a copy of Bertrand Russell’s A History of Western Philosophy (should be easily available 2nd hand) and read the Greeks, I’d skip the Christians and pick up with Descartes, Leibniz, Spinoza. He gets dodgy around Nietzsche so duck out there but it’s important to continue reading up through Derrida through the 20th century.
Or read up limbic resonance, the triune brain the book “A General Theory of Love” covers this ground really well. This also shows you how we end up with sociopaths and other maladapted ways people interact with the world.
There is plenty of money, there always has been. It is just that some kids have to go to bed hungry so some other people can have a second yacht. I think it is unacceptably immoral for the latter to exist while the former does. The total public debt of all governments, states, cities, etc is $60 trillion and the total wealth of the 1% is $120 trillion. A one time 50% capital gains levy that removes global government debt, that would transform Africa, it would free up tremendous resources in all public governments, at all levels. And the the 1% would still have $60 trillion.
If I am honest at the moment I wouldn’t have the time, but my comments are more gut reaction to current events than a researched opinion.
I am aware of the unjust distribution of global wealth to the 1% and that globalisation has further polarised this and created a new class of proletariat taking us backwards while the richest get even richer.
And your language now is less frightening to me and in fact I could support you in seeking this type of change.
Can I suggest to you, that perhaps toning down the language and being less anti capitalism more anti abuse of capitalism might help your cause garner more support.
I am working class and grew up in a republican community where I experienced the army and RUC raids of the late 70s and early 80s first hand. I left school at 15 with no qualifications. I started off at the very bottom doing some under appreciated work and was very poorly treated.
My parents taught me about discrimination here and told me that Catholics had to try twice as hard to get half as much.
So I stuck it out and gradually worked my way up into better jobs which included 11 years of factory work in portadown where Catholics faced blatant and in your face sectarian discrimination which would be totally illegal now and result in huge fines. I then decided to educate myself then and took it upon myself to get a degree which I paid for myself with no support and qualified over a 6 year period via open university without leaving employment.
This allowed me to get a better job but even then was taken advantage off because of no prior experience and I ended up earning less going back to working below the minimum wage for a period and unpaid at all for overtime but I did gain invaluable experience over those years which were a struggle and depressing.
After 5 years of this I got a break and got into a company where I was treated decently which was never lost on me about treating people fairly. I had to laugh at young graduates coming in and complaining about pay and conditions. They didn’t know they were living.
Through hard work I was promoted and worked my way up into consultancy and after another 6 years I was confident enough to setup my own company which I did with the help of my previous employer who respected hard work.
When you say working class, believe me, I have worked damn hard to get where I am and I will not accept anyone saying because I now have my own business I am no longer working class. I still work hard to make sure there is enough money to pay my employees wages.
Sorry for the spiel, but we do need to know where each other is coming from.
I remember hearing about how Jacobs factory in Dublin used to provide housing for its employees.
That resonated with me and it is something I would like to do myself if fortunate enough to get into a position where we can afford to.
I get what you are saying completely, but capitalism is not only big corporate business, some working class people are employers and treat their employees fairly not as the slaves as described by Marx. In fact the vast majority of companies in Ireland are small scale employers and contribute more than large business to the economy.
Capitalism is not an ideology and private domestic businesses can help alleviate and reverse these problems if encouraged to do so. What is required is new thinking not old thinking.
I’ll give you two chapters to read Jessica and if you can get your head round it you’ll have all the knowledge you need: Matthew 5-7. Read those other books if you wish but don’t assume you’ll solve any issues, you’ll just sound smart and interesting. There are plenty of intellectuals about but they haven’t done anything about poverty or injustice and they never will.
You wont find God in any book Dominic
God lives inside everyone, we hear Him as a child but as we grow we learn to ignore Him
If we want to find God, we first need to empty our cup
You won’t find Justice and fairness in a book either Jessica and that was my point. I agree with emptying ourselves to find God and that os what the Beatitudes tell us to do. Well done on building yourself up to were you are and you don’t seem to forget were you come from which is unusual for self made people.
That was taught to me at home Dominic
We sometimes underestimate the importance of a good family life, especially in our younger years
I agree with you there Jessica
I’m sure we will soon be hearing from Unionist politicans how every able bodied male is now joining the UDA and how unhappy the UVF is. It is so predictable you could set your watch by it.
Which is why we need to marginalise whoever chooses to take that approach and beef up the middle ground which sinn fein are clearly now taking the lead in
The middle ground walked out of the count centre alone Jessica
Not a very positive assessment Dominic
Also not one I would agree with
When Martin McGuinness tried to move to the middle ground everyone left. Arlene put a stop to that.