The late Paddy Devlin was quite a colourful bully of a character. Having been an IRA man in his youth, he later turned on republicans and became a vehement opponent of the Hunger Strikers campaign to have basic political status restored. His colleague Gerry (later Lord) Fitt helped to bring down the Callaghan government and usher in Margaret Thatcher – and all her ‘delightful’ tactics towards little old Ireland. Some SDLP figures were supportive of Internment when it was initially introduced. I bring Devlin up for a reason – he, not I, predicted the ultimate demise of his old party, the SDLP, long before it is now happening. Paddy told reporters that a rotten right wing conspiracy existed, whereby the Church Hierarchy were stuffing the SDLP full of devout middle-class school-teachers and members of Catholic secret societies, who would do whatever the clergy wanted. This bluffed nationalist people into thinking they were voting for moderate ‘social democracy’ when in reality they were getting ardent social conservatives with a counter-revolutionary agenda. Many of the other big figures within it likewise departed – from Brian Feeney to Paschal O’Hare.
For a lack of vision is one thing, but that added to by a dwindling number of members and voter-base, is really just a recipe for disaster. These people don’t stand for anything, they model themselves on the millionaire Democrats in America and fully accept the economic status quo. Their ranks are made of a class of Machievellian-wannabes who wouldn’t just cut their grandmother’s throat for high office, they would cook and eat the old girl as well. During the conflict, people always suspected a very circumspect relationship between the SDLP and the British State/MI5. Recently released Northern Ireland Office papers show how senior securocrats were very concerned about the nationalist people throwing their allegiance increasingly behind Sinn Fein over the “greying” Catholic toffs. I wonder why? These people never wanted peace at all, despite lecturing on its merits now; no no! Seamus Mallon and others regularly attacked John Hume for his efforts at dialogue with republicans and there were plans to oust him as leader; desiring instead to continue with the conflict for the sake of their then electoral position.
Three of their former leaders, McDonnell, Ritchie and Durkan, are set for electoral execution on the back of Colum Eastwood’s vanity project towards any potential pacts. I’m glad he didn’t do a pact, because now he really will accelerate his party’s demise and confine them to the history books where they belong. Even if you aren’t a Sinn Fein voter, there can be no denying that their candidates are far more representative of ordinary people than the wannabe-bourgeois failures which the SDLP keep asking you to salary/pension (with some ending up in the British House of Lords).
I know a few young people in the SDLP, and there are a very limited number of young people in it indeed. They have told me that the only reason they are in the SDLP as opposed to Sinn Fein is because they wouldn’t want to work for the ‘average industrial wage’; and believe that they have a better chance of a well-paid political career at the expense of the taxpayer, with Colum Eastwood’s lot. Which confirms exactly what most people suspect, that politics to these people is simply an enhancement of their CV. It’s not an ideological clash of ideas, the desire for national reunification, but a prospective wage slip waiting to be cashed off of the labour of the poor. Ask them what they think of Irish unity and the mask will slip – they don’t much fancy that because there wouldn’t be too many of them elected in that changed landscape. Likewise, they love giving away Irish sovereignty to the European Union because they think it will thwart any future left wing ambitions advanced by Republicans in government.
I’m university educated, but you can’t have a whole party of “academic worthies” being patronisingly cerebral towards voters. You need a broad base of support, made up overwhelmingly of working class people, not university cliques detached from the real world. So whether it’s in Foyle, South Down or South Belfast, you remember come polling day that Colum Eastwood himself gave his transfer vote to a party which has oppressed/slaughtered our people, which has derided legacy inquests (including Bloody Sunday’s in his native Derry), which has blocked same-sex marriage, which is pro-austerity and which is now advancing the Brexit agenda. His vision of “equality” is the kind you get at the dentist on gas and air. All for the sake of merc’s and perks. By contrast, YOU have the choice to elect republicans in the same socio-economic circumstances as you, sending their kids to the same schools, living in the same areas, enjoying the same cultures, possessing the same concerns (about health, education and jobs) and wanting the same things from life. The vast majority of you have absolutely nothing in common with Dr. McDonnell, Margaret Ritchie or Mark Durkan, besides where you might attend church on a Sunday. The basis upon which you should vote is very simple – your social class. Elect people who really stand up for your material interests, the national interest and European interests; and show the British government that we aren’t some borough of England.


Paddy Devlin was a very likeable man. As a very young man I remember him getting his not inconsiderable bulk between myself and an inebriate thug, a “journalist” from the Irish Independent and ex- soldier in the Rhodesian army TV who was threatening to assault me. He was a great debatee and I saw him eviscerate a certain Paul Rogers of the Strategic Policies Institute (or something like that)leaving him trembling and almost in tears.He carried a gun in 1969 and sought help from Captain Kelly. I was bitterly disappointed in him. Not for opposing the hunger strike per se (the IRA initially opposed it) t, but for his lack of empathy with these helpless yong men. And when the iconic “socialist” took a peerage my hurt new no bounds. RIP.
‘knew’
Fitt was always a Tamanny Hall gouger, nothing he did would have surprised me.
The speaker Up There is the late PA Mag Lochlainn, President of NIGRA (the NI Gay Rights Association) for longer than any other incumbent – and anything but, “grey”, or a “toff”, and not much of a “Catholic” either.
Where I live I got suspicious of the SDLP at an early age…they were the parish officials , the plate collectors at mass , the administrators in the SVDP , and although there is absolutely nothing wrong with these charitable acts , it gave them access to the financial affairs of other people in the parish ….which of course should have been private and confidential , but wasn’t …..they were the people that got themselves elected onto every committee…..they were the eyes and ears and knew everything. These were also the people seen talking to the RUC on a regular basis….and on very friendly terms
When Sinn Féin arrived on the scene there resentment was palpable…. they started a whispering campaign with their knowledge….initially it worked but rapidly backfired….thankfully the majority are outed and gone but it left a bad aftertaste , a worthy lesson about the closeness of friends and enemies !
” their resentment” applying to the SDLP
Donal seems to be overlooking Martin O’Millionaire and his £37k a year chauffeur.
And of course, the fact that Sinn Fein have abandoned their Average industrial wage’ pledge.
PBP, Gerry Carroll, PBP, SDLP, PBP, Gerry Carroll, SDLP …… would I be right in guessing another PBP article is due soon?
Donal seems to fancy himself as a Shinner attack-dog.
Or obedient lap-dog.
Apart from a Dublin cost of living adjustment,the AIW policy still stands and SF MLAs recieve about half of what other MLAs get.
‘Fraid not Michael.
It was quietly abandoned at the last Ard Fheis.
The Dublin TDs wouldn’t stand for it anymore.
Ps. PBP still have it as sacrosanct policy.
Maybe because Eamonn McCann was making so much money from British press he didn’t need the money.
Emmet.
Have you any evidence to support that smear?
Ps. Which “British Press” are you most objecting to?
Pps. Am.in right in thinking that the Shinners once.done.an article for Playboy?
Didn’t object (in the comment anyway). Evidence- articles in British press- google it maybe? So you think McCann writes for those papers for free?
Not sure about a playboy article- I don’t think Sinn Fein have a journalist who works for play boy though. Maybe you are confused, maybe playboy did an article on Sinn Fein? Anyway don’t read it, do you remember reading an article in it?
Keep up the immature politics- attack Sinn Fein, attack Shinners, attack… It will win you lots of votes, I promise.
@ Emmet.
So the simple answer is that you don’t have any evidence to support your claim that Eamonn McCann was making so much money from “the.British press” that he didn’t need his.MLA wage.
Ergo, it is yet another baseless, potentially libelous smear emanating from a Sinn Fein zealot.
And then, irony of ironies, you complain of attacks against Sinn Fein.
Norn irony,perhaps?.
Or unadulterated self-delusion.
You decide.
But what is becoming clear is that a Sinn Fein United Ireland is going to be a scary place for free-thinkers.
Your elected representatives, aided and abetted by self-appointed attack-dogs such as yourself and Donal Lavery have absolutely no respect for Truth, Balance or Fairness.
You seem to live in your own wee Green bubbles lashing out wildly and blindly at anything and anyone who challenges the hypocrisy, the inconsistencies, and the lies of Sinn Fein.
Everyone, except the puritanical Green elite, are to be smeared, vilified, ostracised.
It doesn’t matter if its Eamonn McCann, or Bernadette Devlin, or.Gerry Carroll, or The Dark, or Ciaran Nugent – it doesn’t matter what role they.have historically played – if they have a differing view to the ever-changing orthodoxy of Comrade Gerry No Beard, then the attack dogs will bite.
You should be thoroughly ashamed of yourselves. You won’t be, of course. You’ll convince yourselves that Mother Ireland will be pleased with her loyal sons, as they lie and bully their way to a united Ireland built on blood and bones.
And when you get there, you’ll realise that it wasn’t worth a piss because nothing will have actually changed.
And when you point out the blindingly obvious, the attack-dogs will be coming for you….enjoy.
Kevin Connolly have you any evidence I am a Sinn Fein zealot? What if I told you I didn’t vote Sinn Fein 1 at the last election. Your claim looks libelous- (my claim was not!)
Evidence from quick google search shows articles from following newspapers penned by McCann:
Belfast Telegraph, Guardian, Derry Journal
According to Wikipedia he also worked for the Sunday World (WTF really?)
Therefore the claim is not libelous unless you can prove he worked for free (cue laughter). Also the comment started with ‘maybe’ therefore is merely proposed as a possibility- you did read and understand the term ‘Maybe’ didn’t you?
I think I love freethinking so I would not want to give it up- but to be honest the only person I can see try to stop free thinking is you (a PBP supporter).
You accuse people of being bullies then write “Comrade Gerry No Beard”. You don’t offer Ireland anything at all, and thankfully most people can see that. I don’t agree with many things that Sinn Fein do but they have the biggest vote on the Island. You use the term ‘Shame Feign’ in something reminiscing Gregory Campbell’s mockery of the Irish language. The base politics you have displayed make me wish I did vote Sinn Fein and is a good reminder why nationalists can’t trust People Before Profit.
@ Emmet.
I despair.
You do realise that there is a difference between being a Staffer, and a Free-lancer, don’t you.
I’m fairly sure that Jude Collins has also written for the same publications, and appeared for broadcasters such as (heaven forbid) the BBC.
Are you going to launch spurious attacks on him?
“the biggest vote on the island” – you seem incapable of even regurgitating SF propagandist nonsense accurately.
Fine Gael and Fianna Fail have the biggest vote on the island. Some simple maths would show you that.
You are perfectly at liberty to spout your smears, and outright propaganda.
I am equally at liberty to correct you.
If referring to the Divine Leader as “Gerry No Beard” upsets your delicate sensitivities, I have a few other suggestions.
How does “Lord Gerry of Ballymurphy” suit you?
Ps. People Before Profit are not nationalists.
We do not prostrate ourselves for either a Green Tory vote or an Orange Tory vote.
We leave that to you.
Kevin, wikipedia says he worked for, regardless I merely stated ‘maybe he was making so much money…’. Would not matter if he was freelance, still making money from. If Jude criticized the ‘machinery of capitalism’ and the ‘cogs of oppression’ then went on to make money from them a few years later then yes I would mention it (not really a spurious- maybe I can’t criticise your messiah!)
224,000 + 295,00 = 519,000 votes – Simple Maths tells me Sinn Fein equalled the FF vote.
I don’t care what you call him, it doesn’t suit me at all- again with the name calling- people will forgive me me for repeating- please grow up.
You say you aren’t nationalist but call for 24th April to be a national holiday celebrating the Easter Rising- hmm I sense another contradiction being spouted by a PBP attack dog.
I never said PBP are nationalist, I said nationalist voters need to be wary of them. Do you think for yourself or just repeat lines from Socialist Worker meetings?
I suggest that you ask Jude directly who he writes for, and how much he gets, and then smear him accordingly.
You forgot to mention Fine Gaels vote…..is there any good reason for that?
The Easter Rising was led by Irelands greatest socialist, and the Irish Citizen Army.
The Shinners had nothing to do with it.
Which line did I repeat from the Socialist Workers Party?
FFS Kevin, read my post 2nd/3rd line.
I miscalculated, as did you. However, you made the ‘simple maths’ error and then had a go- unfortunately for you your simple Maths was obviously too complicated for you because you were wrong.
If memory serves me correctly- the flag raised was green, white, orange so as much you say Sinn Fein had nothing to do with it had less to do with PBP. (Bet you any money someone that took part in the rising joined Sinn Fein though).
Also not sure you can claim the ICA led it (150-300 members?), they were pushed into it along with the volunteers. Most of the volunteers would not have been socialist. As much as I admire Connolly, I can’t say he led it (although he was a leader).
Your love of the rising and dismissal of nationalism are contradictory. As is your idealisation of the 1916 violence but abhorrence of the 1919 violence.
@ Emmet.
I still can’t see you acknowledge that Sinn Fein are not the biggest party on this island. Can you do that basic thing please?
I said that Sinn Fein had nothing to do with the Rising – indeed Arthur Griffith (SF) sat it out at Eoin McNeills house (SF) fretting about their future careers. Griffith would later describe it as “miserable”.
Yet Sinn Fein have now appropriated it as their own. And are delighted to screw as much kudos and money out if it as they can.
You are correct of course insofar as there was a huge influx of reactionaries and religious types to the Sinn Fein flag.
Griffith and O”Neill did indeed get their chances to destroy the very notion of a Republic when they voted for Partition, the very Partition that Sinn Fein claim to be against today.
Go figure.
Well they are the biggest party in terms of members, however in terms of voters they are the second biggest party.
The modern Sinn Fein are nothing like the old 1905 party which pushed for the Austrian Dual monarchy system. When Britain blamed Sinn Fein, lots of people joined and made republicanism popular- this is when Sinn Fein became radicalised and the SF we are more familiar with today evolved. Sinn Fein do not claim the Rising so please get over it! They just happen to be one of the only parties that have commemorated it. It was a nationalist republican movement, just like 1916 was a nationalist republican rising.
No political party was involved in the Rising- it was an armed insurrection not a vote.
Can you address how you think the rising violence and the violence of 1919 are different? I really don’t understand how you can condemn 1919 and 1916- many of the people involved in 1916 were fighting in 1919.
@ Emmet.
So you’re finally admitting your previous claim was nonsense. Good. Let’s move on. I’m bored rigid with it.
I’m also glad that you are aware Sinn Fein started as Dual Monarchists, then evolved into anti-Monarchists, and in recent years have come full circle by curtseying and toasting the Queen, and of course, Charlie, the Colonel-in-Chief of the Paras.
Yet another example of rollover, amnesiac “republicanism” for you to ponder.
@ Emmet.
Of course, your claim that Sinn Fein are one of the only parties that commemorated the Easter Rising is complete bunkum.
The Irps, Sticks, Eirigi, Saoradh, are just a few of the armed groups that commemorate it.
And If it’s elected political parties you want, you can go all the way from Fine Gael, to FF, to Labour, to AAA, to PBP that commemorate it.
But it’s only Shame Feign that have commercialised the legacy.