The inquisitorial Ruth

Screen Shot 2015-10-18 at 16.27.04

Picture by Laois Heritage

 

Aaahhhhh. That felt good.

I see in my absence my dear friend Ruth Dudley Edwards (gifted with three names while most of us stumble on with two) has been telling children what questions to ask about the Proclamation. It’s always good to see someone who knows that education should be student-centred. Dear Ruth’s father, who was History professor in UCD in my time (and hers), tended to be so busy striking theatrical poses, there was little time for student questions.

 

In total, dear Ruth gives the children nineteen questions to ask their teachers, with the twentieth being “Why don’t you want any more questions?” Well there’s an easy answer to that, dear Ruth. Because most of the ones you’ve given them are either limp humour or deeply daft.

 

Here are a few examples:

 

  • “Is it OK to start a revolution just because you want to?”
  • “Is God a Catholic or a Protestant?”
  • “Can dead people tell you what to do?”
  • “Why did the signatories have ‘full confidence in victory’ when the Germans hadn’t turned up and hardly any Volunteers had?”
  • “Didn’t Daniel O’Connell say that a single drop of blood was too much to pay for liberty?”

 

 

The first question implies that the Easter Rising was taken on a whim, that a bunch of men and women just got this sudden “Why don’t we have a revolution – right here!” notion. As a historian, dear Ruth knows this is rubbish. The Easter Rising was a calculated move by men and women who saw it as the only way to awaken the desire for independence in the Irish people.

 

The second question cited is a very old and wrinkled chestnut: Bob Dylan was asking it ironically in the early 1960s when he sang ‘With God On Our Side’. Of course both sides claimed God was on their side. That’s what armies and countries do. Check the flags and plaques in Canterbury Cathedral next time you’re there.

 

The third, taken literally, is of course wildly funny – if you like that kind of thing. But less literally, it is true that the heroism and sacrifice made by previous generations do inspire those who follow them – for better or worse. Look at the way Margaret Thatcher (once a good chum of Ruth’s husband) has inspired the present Tory government to do the things it’s currently doing.

 

The fourth suggests that dear Ruth hasn’t re-read the writings of Pearse recently. In them he makes clear that he believes those to come after him will be inspired to continue the struggle for national independence and will ultimately succeed.

 

The fifth question is easy – the answer is Yes. But since Daniel O’Connell had been dead nearly sixty years at the time of the Rising, and since the leaders of the Rising clearly saw Irish liberty in different terms, it’s difficult to know what dear Ruth’s point is.

 

Oddly enough, her thinking appears to run along a similar track to that of Pearse. Pearse saw the Rising as a catalyst which would ultimately lead to Irish freedom. Likewise, I doubt if dear Ruth believes her Sindo volleys will cause the collapse of Sinn Féin; but if enough like her keep lobbing the verbal grenades, the Irish people will ultimately reject the bad Shinners and come to realize how lucky they are in having the north-eastern corner of their country ruled by the folks next door.

 

55 Responses to The inquisitorial Ruth

  1. PJ Dorrian October 18, 2015 at 3:57 pm #

    I never listen to the baggage, when she comes on the radio goes off. I’ve felt this way since her rabid defence of Orangemen in the Drumcree Orangefest

  2. Bridget Cairns October 18, 2015 at 4:22 pm #

    Do you know what age group these ridiculous questions are aimed at. Teachers must be grossly insulted to even have to consider these in the curriculum. An insult to the intelligence of teacher and student alike. How desperate is RDE to be heard, coming up with this nonsense.
    Questions to be asked of RDE, should Britain have gone to war against Hitler, should a drop of blood be shed in pursuit of justice……………………..

  3. Mark October 18, 2015 at 5:22 pm #

    Dear Jude, your repetition of certain questions posed by RDE is welcome, especially as I always avoid blueshirt and stickie media, however, would it not be better to repose questions with further questions, excepting Q. 2 which has only one answer, God being God is neither, we worship him, not the other way round.
    Q. 1, Is it OK to start a revolution just because you want to? Yes, if it’s ok for Menachem Begin to revolt against the British mandate in Palestine, or for ISIL to seek the return of the Caliphate removed by Franco-English colonialists? Bear in mind, RDE has written widely in support of the occupation of Palestine.
    Q.3, Can dead people tell you what to do? Well, you could of course just go back to Menachem above and referencing to Moses, Abraham etc. In the alternative, if we fail to listen to dead people, will we not avoid make the same mistakes of the past, like first to second world war’s?
    Q. 4, Why did the signatories have ‘full confidence in victory’ when the Germans hadn’t turned up and hardly any Volunteers had? Why should they not have? Or, why did Micheal McDowell’s grand-father cancel the better attended rising on the previous morning with concentrations of Oglaigh throughout strategic locations of Ireland, including mid and south Ulster, therefore better able to undertake operations against the EOF (english occupation forces)
    Q. 5, Didn’t Daniel O’Connell say that a single drop of blood was too much to pay for liberty? Yes, reference your own question about listening to dead people above. However, didn’t Shane O Neill say earlier ‘Ireland was taken by the sword and Ireland shall be won back by the sword’. O Neill had greater victories than O Connell so who was greatest and more likely to be listened to?

  4. M E Moore October 18, 2015 at 5:48 pm #

    Here’s another question to add to your list Ruth. Why keep on living in a country you detest so much?

    • PJ Dorrian October 19, 2015 at 9:23 am #

      She lives in London and insults us from there. One would have thought she could have found something in English politics to occupy her head

  5. Jim October 18, 2015 at 5:54 pm #

    Jude, ignore her; she’s demented!

    • neill October 19, 2015 at 8:28 am #

      Many people think Jude is demented isn’t it strange that you always think your political opponents are wrong?

      • Jude Collins October 19, 2015 at 8:32 am #

        “Many people think Jude is demented” – you may be right, neill. Or, of course, wrong. So how do you know?

        • neill October 19, 2015 at 9:17 am #

          Time answers all questions Jude

          • Jude Collins October 19, 2015 at 10:43 am #

            Well said, neill – that has quite a ring. Now, speaking slowly, please: what does it mean?

        • neill October 19, 2015 at 11:05 am #

          When I first read your blog I thought it was a satire blog only to be shocked when I found that you actually believe what you write.

          • Jude Collins October 19, 2015 at 11:43 am #

            Ach Neill – that’s a nice ‘Welcome back’. Which bit shocked you most?

          • Ryan October 19, 2015 at 5:27 pm #

            Did you really think it was a satire blog Neill? or is it just a case where you deeply disagreed with Jude’s point of view because it wasn’t a Unionist one?

  6. Iolar October 18, 2015 at 7:26 pm #

    Perhaps children should be encouraged to interrogate another Proclamation in 1917 as the sentiment expressed by RDE says more about the lack of intellectual independence in Ireland in 2015.

    Pearse in ‘The Murder Machine’ stated,

    “…There is no education system in Ireland. The English have established the simulacrum of an education system, but its object is the precise contrary of the object of an education system. Education should foster; this education is meant to repress. Education should inspire; this education is meant to tame… .”

    The reference to the German nation is derogatory and insulting. RDE will recall that the Windsor family came into being on 17 July 1917 by virtue of King George V’s proclamation, a proclamation that changed the name of the British Royal Family from the German Saxe-Coburg and Gotha. Perhaps children might be interested in the ‘war of the cousins’, a war fought to the last drop of thousands of conscripts, while some of the Royals…sorry, I almost forgot about the watershed.

  7. Perkin Warbeck October 18, 2015 at 8:39 pm #

    On February 2, 1815 the pacifist D. O’Connell plugged John D’Esterre at Bishopscourt, outside Naas, County Kildare. Just to watch him die.

    Me Duel and Darling Daniel

    D’Esterre was no Stallone called Sylvester
    Took pistol ball in the hip, began to fester
    That royal fawning Daniel
    At dawn sipped as spaniel
    Drops from dropped D’. the pestering jester.

    October 18, 2015 the pacifist D. O’Connell is still one up on the fierce warmonger, P. Pearse.

  8. Ryan October 18, 2015 at 8:59 pm #

    Oh, poor Ruth, I see her obsession with the shinners and the founders of modern Irish Republicanism hasn’t eased since I last tweeted her. It really is unhealthy, not to mention weird, to go onto her twitter feed and see: Sinn Fein, Sinn Fein and yet more Sinn Fein every time.

    If you were a complete stranger to Irish History and dear Ruth was your teacher, can you imagine the view you would have on Irish History after the lessons ended? Sure Ireland was a utopia of peace and justice under British rule! The Irish “famine” was just one big misunderstanding! the British didn’t mean to export 4 times as much food during the “famine” years compared to the years before! The Leaders of the Easter Rising rebelled for the fun of it! And of course the Catholics in the North of Ireland had a great quality of life under Unionist Stormont, it was that Gerry Adams that started all the hassle! The Orange Order aren’t anti-Catholic, they are just Pro-Protestant! Just ignore the Kick the Pope bands and the Anti-Catholic banners.

    Everyone knows dear Ruth has her own agenda and part of it is trying to sink Sinn Fein, which she is failing at miserably. Its interesting to know her husband knew Margaret Thatcher, it all makes a lot more sense now. Dear Ruth herself told me she was British and Irish. I don’t think any of us are left in any doubt which one she favours…..

  9. jessica October 18, 2015 at 9:16 pm #

    Perhaps she should focus on the education of the English children.
    In particular economics.

    Is it ok to spend billions of English tax payers money to occupy another country against the wishes of the vast majority of its people where you will never be accepted?

    Is it ok to spend billions of English tax payers money to occupy another country against the wishes of the vast majority of its people when the majority of the English and indeed British people would prefer it actually had its own independence and to which a high percentage them actually think it does already?

    • neill October 19, 2015 at 9:21 am #

      I am sorry Jessica but you really are obtuse.

      Is it ok to spend billions of English tax payers money to occupy another country against the wishes of the vast majority of its people where you will never be accepted

      The clear majority of people in Northern Ireland wish to remain in the union or did you subtly forget that?

      Is it ok to spend billions of English tax payers money to occupy another country against the wishes of the vast majority of its people where you will never be accepted

      Sorry how exactly are you occupying a country when the clear majority wish to remain part of the Union.?

      • jessica October 19, 2015 at 11:01 am #

        “The clear majority of people in Northern Ireland wish to remain in the union or did you subtly forget that?”

        I have no problem with that. In fact I think we should make hay while that remains the case.
        i.e. get as much out of it as possible.

        I have a problem with unionism allowing us to suffer economically just for the privilege of being british as presently seems to be the case.

        “Sorry how exactly are you occupying a country when the clear majority wish to remain part of the Union.?”

        Partition divides the whole island of Ireland against the wishes of the majority of its people. How is it not occupation just because it benefits one community in the occupied territory?

      • Ryan October 19, 2015 at 5:36 pm #

        Ahh, Neill, enough of the cherry picking. The vast majority of the people of Ireland wanted Independence from Britain and were against partition, was democracy upheld then? British Government presence in Ireland, any part of Ireland, is against the wishes of the vast majority.

        And no Neill, the Anglo Irish treaty back in the 1920’s wasn’t democratic either because the British threatened a “terrible war” if it wasn’t accepted by Irish Republicans.

        The Northern statelet was gerrymandered to secure Unionists a majority, which will eventually be undone due to the demographics changing. That is not democracy and there’s no escaping from that fact.

        • jessica October 19, 2015 at 8:05 pm #

          Unionism is on the second stage of grief, denial / anger.

          northern ireland is a country, rogues and renegades, holding of noses and stench about the place.

          The third will begin when nationalism has an electoral majority.

          There is only one road and we are all on it together.

        • neill October 19, 2015 at 8:06 pm #

          Northern Irelands exists now and will be round for a very long time to come get used to it folks as much as it annoys you that is a fact

          • Jude Collins October 19, 2015 at 8:59 pm #

            Something that hasn’t happened yet can’t be a fact, neill. You mean it’s an opinion – yours, to be exact.

    • kopabergcentral October 19, 2015 at 10:24 am #

      When the country is 1.56 trillion in debt, what’s a few billion here and there? And when the bankers did such a fantastic job of running the economy into the ground, the solution was simple, crank up the printing presses and pump out the fiat currency, but give it a fancy description like quantitative easing to make it sound sophisticated. That’s one thing Bankers are good at, using bamboozling terms to keep everyone in awe of their spectacular misdeeds.

      • jessica October 19, 2015 at 10:47 am #

        “When the country is 1.56 trillion in debt, what’s a few billion here and there? ”

        That’s the spirit.
        They have a bit to go yet to make up for the neglect they inflicted here.
        Squeeze every penny out of them while we can I say.

  10. Emmet October 18, 2015 at 9:21 pm #

    My Answers:
    1. Only if you have tried everything else to get rid of RDE.
    2. I think he changed sides when RDE came along.
    3. If it is RDE then no, you can just ignore her which is what most people did when she was alive.
    4. They did gain victory, sadly for RDE. (Please try to get over it Dudley)
    5. Yes but he hadn’t come across people like RDE before.

  11. giordanobruno October 18, 2015 at 10:00 pm #

    Jude
    Inquisitorial.

    • Jude Collins October 19, 2015 at 8:28 am #

      Quite right, gio. Thanks for correction.

  12. Séamus Ó Néill October 19, 2015 at 10:20 am #

    I have never been too concerned about the thoughts ,however perverse ,of double barreled Ruth. The sign of an intelligent person is their ability to control their emotions by the application of reason and I think she fails the test miserably….she is on a perpetual ,teeth grating, rant ….not only about Sinn Féin ,but really anything that fits in with her West Brit mentality. I think maybe she should answer some questions….
    1 , If she believes in democracy , why ,when Ireland voted overwhelmingly for Sinn Féin and freedom in 1918 were we not allowed to take our rightful place amongst the nations of the world.?
    2, If the said party is such a despicable bunch of untrustworthy reprobates ,why are they the largest party in Ireland?
    3 , Does she believe that the people of Ireland ,if they are indoctrinated long enough, would fall for or swallow her revisionist claptrap?
    4 , Does she believe that through The Belfast/Good Friday agreement we are entitled to seek the legitimate re-unification of our country by peaceful means?
    5 , Does she believe that the artificial entity of ” Northern Ireland “created
    undemocratically by the threat of terrible war and maintained by force is likely to survive in it’s present festering state?

  13. giordanobruno October 19, 2015 at 10:22 am #

    I don’t see much in the way of considered response to her points here. Just the usual ad hominem which appears whenever her name comes up; “baggage” and “demented” for example. Even a gratuitous insult aimed at her father by Jude.
    The first point as listed by Jude is a very fair question.
    Did the men and women behind the rising have the support of the people for revolution? Or should we not ask?
    The third and fifth point as listed here are actually part of the same point in RDE’s piece and make more sense that way.
    She is saying why revere the beliefs of one group of dead people and dismiss the words of another.
    Perhaps O’Connell was wrong about a single drop of blood being to much to pay for liberty. Perhaps it depends if it is your own blood or the blood of others being spilled!

    • Jude Collins October 19, 2015 at 10:34 am #

      “Gratuitous insult” eh, gio? I promise you, it was well-earned. As to having a majority in favour of revolution – don’t you think it might be slightly self-defeating to conduct a census on same? As to why revere (or learn from ) the beliefs of one group of dead people rather than another: fairly obviously because some groups preach tripe and other groups talk sense.

      • giordanobruno October 19, 2015 at 6:48 pm #

        Jude
        I felt it was gratuitous because it seemed to have nothing to do with RDE’s article.
        But that is not that surprising as the overwhelming response here has been to belittle her rather than address her argument. Why is that ok?
        On the rising, my understanding is there was little evidence of mass support for such action before hand. RDE seems to be making a similar point to one you frequently make yourself about the main parties in the South and their commemoration of the rising.
        From the article:
        “Let the ‘children of the nation’ ask the adults why it was okay for a tiny and unelected minority to use arms then but not now?”
        Surely a reasonable question.

        • Jude Collins October 19, 2015 at 9:02 pm #

          That’s a fair question except that it makes the idea of any revolution impossible.Anywhere. Ever.

          • giordanobruno October 19, 2015 at 9:45 pm #

            Jude
            The Hungarian revolution in 1956 was inspired by mass demonstrations, which spread across the country. The Velvet revolution in Czechoslovakia had widespread public support.
            In both cases the momentum was behind the revolutionaries.
            In Ireland beyond Dublin the rising was disorganised and limited. It was only in the aftermath when the executions started that public opinion became engaged.
            But agree or disagree,I don’t see what is wrong with RDE encouraging young people to ask questions and not simply accept the mythic portrayal we now have.
            Should anyone questioning the validity of the rising be mocked and abused?

          • Jude Collins October 20, 2015 at 2:24 pm #

            Well now, gio – you’ve a funny notion of abuse if you think I’ve abused dear Ruth…”In both cases the momentum was behind the revolutionaries”. Yes. And in 1918, the Irish people showed whose side they were on. If you pause to read even some of what Pearse wrote, you’d know that he was aware the Rising would be crushed but that it would trigger a revival of Irish nationalism. Anyway, it’s a angels-on-pinhead argument – did the revolutionaries have public support before, during or after their Rising. As to dear Ruth – I’ve made it clear in my blog that I applaud her for the notion of child-centred education. It’s just that the questions SHE says they should ask are either daft or aimed at discrediting the Easter Rising. She has of course a right to do that – a right she’s been exercising for some time – but equally others like myself have a right to point out that we disagree with her and find some of her ideas …um…odd.

          • jessica October 20, 2015 at 2:28 pm #

            “Should anyone questioning the validity of the rising be mocked and abused?”

            The validity of the rising???
            So should germany invade britain and occupy its territory, you would question the validity of any militant uprising by the british to remove them?

            You are entitled to your opinion, but we too are entitled to mock such suggestions after viewing them in a wider context.

          • giordanobruno October 20, 2015 at 5:36 pm #

            Jude
            It is true I suppose that you mock her rather than abuse her, but once again the comments below your piece are quite nasty, and I calling someone demented adds nothing to a discussion. But hey it;s your blog!
            Yes I know Pearse felt their blood sacrifice would reignite Irish Nationalism but then he was clearly demented!
            I don’t think it is angels on the head of a pin stuff to wonder if support for violent revolution came before or after the action. That is a bit close to the end justifies the means for my liking.

          • Jude Collins October 20, 2015 at 5:41 pm #

            Why oh why oh why do I spend time responding to you, gio? Fatal attraction?? “The comments below my piece” – are these mine or someone else’s? Be precise, please.”He was clearly demented” – now that’s what I call rational argument. As to revolution – would you say the French Resistance had the full support of the French people? How did they know? This notion of revolutionaries checking the popularity of revolution among the populace is Monty Python stuff…

          • giordanobruno October 20, 2015 at 10:50 pm #

            Jude
            “checking the popularity of revolution is Monty Python stuff”.
            Yes who gives a toss what the people want, eh?

        • jessica October 19, 2015 at 9:32 pm #

          “Jude
          I felt it was gratuitous because it seemed to have nothing to do with RDE’s article.
          But that is not that surprising as the overwhelming response here has been to belittle her rather than address her argument. Why is that ok?
          On the rising, my understanding is there was little evidence of mass support for such action before hand. RDE seems to be making a similar point to one you frequently make yourself about the main parties in the South and their commemoration of the rising.
          From the article:
          “Let the ‘children of the nation’ ask the adults why it was okay for a tiny and unelected minority to use arms then but not now?”
          Surely a reasonable question.”

          “On the rising, my understanding is there was little evidence of mass support for such action before hand.”

          That’s right. There was no stomach for violence especially among the catholic population hence so many protestants involved in seeking irish self rule.

          It was doomed to failure from the start and went ahead quite deliberately as a blood sacrifice to persuade the population to get off its knees.

          The leaders knew very well in advance how they would be treated by the british but laid down their lives anyway.

          Their mistreatment and execution led to the majority of the population over 75% to vote for sinn fein and self rule.

          Democracy was thwarted and a sectarian state created to appease unionists.

          It was initially meant to be all of ulster but the border boundary was broken to help gerrymander a sustainable unionist population.

        • jessica October 19, 2015 at 9:41 pm #

          “But that is not that surprising as the overwhelming response here has been to belittle her rather than address her argument. Why is that ok?”

          Lets see, unionist culture basically started and ended with the battle of the boyne and has hardly moved on since.

          But lets go out of our way to criticise republicans for letting history dictate their actions of the present.

          Is that not a bit like, do as I say not as I do?

          • giordanobruno October 20, 2015 at 5:27 pm #

            jessica
            I’m not sure what unionist culture has to do with my comment, or even what unionist culture is to be honest.
            I just feel it is a better discussion if people don’t simply hurl insults such as calling someone demented. Don’t you?
            Why not just address her points and rebut them with argument.
            That’s all I meant regarding the mockery.

          • Jude Collins October 20, 2015 at 5:43 pm #

            Hey gio – “I just feel it is a better discussion if people don’t simply hurl insults such as calling someone demented. Don’t you?” (staggers off-stage, overcome with mirth)

          • jessica October 20, 2015 at 5:52 pm #

            gio, I suggest you go read some of her work before defending her.

          • giordanobruno October 20, 2015 at 10:46 pm #

            Jude
            I guess I should have put more exclamation points after my comment about Pearse I was (obviously I thought) trying to illustrate the silliness of using abusive terms like that.
            You are the boss of the blog Jude, which is why I am pointing out that your man not ball rule is strangely only applied for some posters (usually unionist) and not for those who mock say RDE or the Queen or Willie Frazer not for their beliefs but in purely personal terms.
            jessica
            To reiterate, I am not defending her I am saying she has a right to her opinions and we should try to debate the opinions rather than attack the individual.
            It’s not that hard and it makes a more worthwhile discussion.
            Or we could all just slag each other off like children.

          • Jude Collins October 21, 2015 at 8:36 am #

            I think you’ve a good point, gio. I am remiss in that regard – although sometimes mockery comes intertwined with the point being made. If you point me to an example/examples of that, I’ll be happy to attend to them. And I’ll try to be as impartial as a warped, biased, cynical old codger like myself can be…

          • jessica October 21, 2015 at 8:48 am #

            “To reiterate, I am not defending her I am saying she has a right to her opinions and we should try to debate the opinions rather than attack the individual.
            It’s not that hard and it makes a more worthwhile discussion.
            Or we could all just slag each other off like children.”

            Do you really think her comments are worth discussion gio?
            Is God a protestant or catholic? That is just stupid in my opinion
            Occasionally, mocking has a therapeutic value, I think this is one of these occasions.
            If she came on here herself, that would be a different thing altogether and courtesy would apply.

          • giordanobruno October 21, 2015 at 9:32 am #

            Jude
            I have no desire to be the boy running to tell tales to teacher.
            Take a wee look through the comments on this piece.
            There is plenty of comment about RDE herself, not so much about her views.

          • Jude Collins October 21, 2015 at 10:30 am #

            Look gio – I’m not ‘the teacher’ (thinks: wish I was) and you’re the one that’s raised concern about these kind of comments, so I assumed you’d be keen to help cope with them. I try to check things aren’t libellous or too obviously abuse but I’m sure I’m fallible, maybe even lop-sided in my editing of them. So if you’re not satisfied, why would you see yourself as a tout? Re dear Ruth, I think a lot of people are exasperated by her because she continually bashes anything nationalist.

          • giordanobruno October 21, 2015 at 9:43 am #

            jessica
            Jude posted a piece about her article, so presumably that is what we are invited to comment on.
            Not all her questions are worth discussion perhaps, although they make more sense when read in the actual article rather than as Jude has edited them.
            The validity or morality of the rising like any other historic event is open to question surely?
            Some people have doubts about whether it was justified and whether it might have been counter-productive. Now you disagree with them but surely it is valid to present the argument and discuss it without resorting to mockery.
            There should be no sacred cows!

          • jessica October 21, 2015 at 10:40 am #

            “The validity or morality of the rising like any other historic event is open to question surely?”

            I dont know what you mean by validity.
            Some good people gave their lives for their country and for a cause which they believed in.
            I think the people of ireland are grateful that they did, what more validity do you think is needed?

            There will be plenty of validity for all to see with the commemorations next year.

          • giordanobruno October 21, 2015 at 12:12 pm #

            jessica
            Yes you think that. Others do not.
            Some think events might have unfolded more favourably if there had been no rising. After 100 years we still have a divided Ireland.
            Now that can only ever be a game of what if, but people are entitled to ask the question are they not?
            Or do you think the rising has some untouchable status in Irish history and should not be criticised?

          • Jude Collins October 21, 2015 at 1:17 pm #

            Let me suggest an answer, gio – Jessica will no doubt provide a better one. The Rising of course does not or should not have untouchable status in Irish history. But neither should it become the target for heavy fire from those opposed to nationalism/republicanism – and a read through dear Ruth’s article makes clear that she is agin it and wants others to be agin it. All historical events, all human actions have a complexity to them; but there are those we can see which were noble and those which were base. That doesn’t mean people can’t criticise the noble or elevate the base, but it doesn’t make them right either.

          • jessica October 21, 2015 at 1:22 pm #

            Gio, I didn’t know you were a back to the future fan on this special day.

            History is history, there is so many things we could criticise, if I could go back and do my own life over I could do a much better job,

            But now ive said that, would I…? I wouldn’t have the experience I have now, so if I went back in time, I might just make the same mistakes over again, or worse.

            Lets not mess the space time continuum gio, we have enough problems in the present.

    • Emmet October 20, 2015 at 7:14 am #

      I was forced to have considered responses to RDE during my education. I will never feel the need to consider a statement made by her again, and I will stick to it. She is up their with Willy Frazer in my estimation.