Why people throw things at the police

Screen Shot 2015-10-19 at 09.21.45

Picture by Stephen Barnes

 

Do you like the police? Mmm, me neither…No, that’s not quite true. I liked them when they came, the night an intruder broke into our house (although I wasn’t so crazy about the half-hour it took them to respond to our call). Apart from that I tend to associate the police with speed traps, the instrument for officialdom that clamps down on my activities, the embodiment of Brendan Behan’s famous statement “There is no situation so bad that it can’t be made worse by the arrival of a policeman”. All that said, I realize we have to have policemen. And women. Any society needs laws and people who will identify those who are not following those laws. When you’re on the receiving end of this fact it can feel unpleasant, but if you’re honest you’ll probably concede (if only to yourself) that the cops are right and you’re wrong.

All of which brings us to the riotous behaviour of some 200 young people in Twinbrook on Saturday night. They fired missiles of different kinds at just about everybody, police included. Jennifer McCann, the local Sinn Féin representative, says the police intervention was totally inadequate and that the cops effectively stood by and let it happen.

So what can we say about this case? For a start, it happened in Twinbrook – an area that is quite different from, say, Malone or Cultra. In other words, it’s a poorer area. The second thing we can say is that almost certainly, none of the cops who appeared on the scene live in Twinbrook. And the third thing is, there are almost certainly a scarcity of enjoyable, involving activities for young people in Twinbrook. Apart, that is, from throwing missiles, preferably at the cops.

The truth is, police are a tough item to sell. Inevitably they are seen by deprived young people as the enforcers of a more well-off world. There are those who’ll identify this as bleeding-heart talk, that what those kids need is a good wallop to the side of the head and a longish period behind bars. Which may work as a very short-term solution, but it’ll be treating the symptoms, not the cause. Until young people are presented with other, more engaging things to do than the thrill of rioting; until they know the police as their neighbours, not an unfriendly outside force; until our society gets to serious grips with the legacy of resentment and injustice that the RUC have left us with, rioting like that in Twinbrook on Saturday night will continue. And, weather permitting, grow.

58 Responses to Why people throw things at the police

  1. neill October 19, 2015 at 8:32 am #

    the instrument for officialdom that clamps down on my activities

    Ok what dodgy activities are these the public deserve an answer!

  2. Iolar October 19, 2015 at 9:39 am #

    There is no excuse for rioting, just as there is no excuse for social and economic deprivation. If someone robs a bank, he/she will end up in prison. If bankers rip a country off, taxes increase. Prisons are full of individuals with problems associated with alcohol abuse and other mental health challenges.

    “But the banks are made of marble,
    With a guard at every door,
    And the vaults are stuffed with money,
    That people sweated for…”

    We have homelessness and food banks while others live in mansions, own ‘inherited’ estates, some walk to the House of Lords, claim expenses, take full advantage of heavily subsidised champagne and discuss the need for a nuclear deterrent. Drug dealers in paramilitary organisations are frowned upon, while the use of recreational drugs in certain walks of life are tolerated and form the staple diet for the so called, Red Tops. Debates about welfare cuts continue ad nauseum while private landlords live lives they have become accustomed to by virtue of Housing Benefit. Pipe bombs create havoc while a lot of people accept bombs dropping on hospitals and other areas populated by civilians as collateral damage.

    Young people do not always listen to an older generation and with some justification. Are they impressed with politicians as role models, politicians who care little about the needs of children with learning difficulties but who turn up in numbers for a debate on the love of money? Are younger people impressed with role models who feel obliged to hold their collective noses while interacting with political opponents?

    “Hate your next door neighbour but do not forget to say grace…”

    Young people subscribe to transparency in relationships and they have the ability to see through spin doctors with as many faces as Big Ben.

  3. Mary Jo October 19, 2015 at 10:14 am #

    Norman Mailer once suggesting introducing motorbike jousting in central park to enliven the lives young New Yorkers. I imagine he was thinking of white males who could afford motor bikes.
    N. Ireland style recreational rioting, on the other hand, needs little more than impassioned participants equipped with appropriate missiles. Here is an opportunity. With some serious sports sponsorship from Heineken and Red Bull and quality event management, recreational rioting could quickly spread Europe wide, especially in these austere times.
    The finest thing about recreational rioting is that participation is not restricted to teams. Anyone of any age can join in.

  4. Séamus Ó Néill October 19, 2015 at 11:33 am #

    My first encounter with a policeman was aged 8 when I got a painful and unnecessary “cuff” for riding a bicycle on the footpath ,the second a few months later when I witnessed my father and uncle receive a severe beating by the infamous ” B Specials ” at a roadblock and those memories are indelibly ingrained. However I’m wise enough to recognize the need for law and order but how their duties are performed and by whom is crucial to the acceptance of that force. An Garda Síochána seems to enjoy widespread approval because they ,especially in rural areas, are community policemen and don’t carry racist or sectarian baggage. Unfortunately here we’ve no such luxury ….67.20% of Police officers and 77.58% of Police staff still emanate from the Protestant or British community whereas we have an almost 50/50 population breakdown. These are car bound officers with virtually no contact nor craic with the people they are paid to protect….a build up of trust is impossible. That taken and the fact that they do have residual RUC baggage and don’t reside amongst the people make their task of integration and acceptance almost impossible.Show us impartiality and respect and we could make progress……but guard against unwarranted , unproven and inflammatory statements….we’re not to be taken for granted.

    • Ryan October 19, 2015 at 6:14 pm #

      Well said Seamus. That’s a major problem with the PSNI, it still doesn’t have enough Catholic officers. There needs to be another 50/50 recruitment programme and kept in place until the PSNI is 50/50 Catholic and Protestant.

      • billy October 19, 2015 at 6:55 pm #

        religion wont make no difference their still peelers,

      • neill October 19, 2015 at 8:02 pm #

        Why the populations are not 50-50?

  5. billy October 19, 2015 at 12:21 pm #

    painting a couple of jeeps a different colour changes nothing their still the same outfit,sf,and the sdlp were asleep at the wheel during talks.

  6. fiosrach October 19, 2015 at 2:56 pm #

    No billy they weren’t asleep. The SDLPare anybody’s patsy and Sinn Féin nua smelled the trough of power and money – which was what the intifada was all about. Revolution and United Ireland – are you mad?

  7. Perkin Warbeck October 19, 2015 at 3:20 pm #

    Your less than starry-eyed view of the policeman’s sometimes’ less than happy lot, Esteemed Blogmeister, reminds one of a comment once heard in one’s hearing in the dim and distant by a crusty old bald Garda from the stony grey soil of Monaghan.

    Made in the wake of a daring rescue by a young Garda who had rescued / arrested a would-be suicide from the Liffey.(Suicide is a criminal offence). And whom some shrill voices in the media were baying for some class of special award be made to the rescuer.

    Taking out his latest pay docket the older Garda finger-poked the docket and growled in tones Kavanaghesque:

    -This is the reward he gets. Every Thursday.

    The media, if anything, have grown more shrill on this topic. It’s almost as if Na Gardai Siochana are unpaid volunteers / oglaigh gan pha.

    Nor, one suspects, will it come between you and your beauty sleep, E.B., to hear that The Unionist Times tends to view the police with spectacles of a somewhat more rosy-hue. As a side dish obituary in last Saturday’s edish will illustrate.

    Recently deceased chap,name of Brian Stewart. Brian who? Or indeed, Who Stewart?

    Shadowy former acting boss of M16, it seems, whose links to the Free Southern Stateen were just as tenuous or even as elevenuous as those of the rather more upfront homicidal maniac Field Marshal Frederick Roberts of Kabul and Kandahar.

    The recent unveiling of whose bust in the Viking city of Verorafjoror in the sunny south east of the FSS was rubber-stamped by the Panjandrums of the Press on Liffeyside.

    According to the oleaginous obituary ‘Brian Stewart was a British spy who took a keen interest in Ireland and in his later years became known to history enthusiasts through his participation in several events in Trinity College, Dublin’.

    Roysh.

    Further down an fogra bais/ obituary: ‘According to TCD history professor Eunan O Halpin, Steward “was very keen on strengthening the RUC Special Branch, believing from his time in Malaya that the local people were the best people to collect and assess local intelligence”.

    (In the US of A, in the halcyon days of the hard-boiled whodunnit a detective was known as a Shamus. Be fascinating to find out if many or indeed any Seamuses were in the pay of the Shamuses in Norneverland).

    Incidentally, the TCD prof quoted above is often quoted (by himself) as ‘a grandnephew of Kevin Barry’. KB, of course, was the only martyr in Irish history whose life span was measured in summers rather the more orthodox years. Possibly due to the specific circumstances of his own,erm summary execution.

    It is often quoted by the distinguished prof, in a gesture of intellectual distinction and in the tones of: ‘go on, criticise me with a martyr in my family arms’. Perkie’s inner prof-watcher is at two minds as whether the party known as Prof O Halpin could be classified as a Democratic Eunan or as an Official Eunan.

    While it is made clear that Brian Stewart was the son of a ‘jute to mill’ millionaire laddie in Edinburgh it is not clarified if this influenced his later enthusiastic backing of the ‘shoot to kill’ policy by Ulster-Scottish laddies in Norneverland.

    Mention of Malay in the disarmingly smarmy obituary definitely did make Perkie’s inner peripatetic pedagogue sit up and take notice. Having spent some time in a high-rise apartment sitting out on his sun-dabbled balcony taking notice in a northerly direction across the Strait of Singapore.

    Of the forty shades of jungle fatigues in the Sultanate of Johur Bahru. The last occasion one visited the most southerly province of Malaya was to witness the son of, oddly enough, the son of a Garda Siochana card a sporting victory. That would have been Padraig Harrington who finally ended a career drought in the monsoon-prone golf course of the district.

    Mind you, it was another golfing aficionado whom one had primarily on one’s mind as one strolled around in the open sauna after the focused and goal-oriented golfer who learned to tell his niblock from his mashie in the Garda Golf Club in Rathfarnham.

    That would have been a former Sultan of Johor Bahru who, the more he practiced the unluckier he got. Till one fateful morning when he had just mulliganed/ freshaired his fifth tee shot on the trot and took some exception to the sniggers of his indiscreet caddy from the paddy fields.

    (XXX:for those of a little less than squeamish nature, see further details below).

    After the Churchill-Hitler War, and according to The Unionist Times Brian Steward ‘joined the British colonial service in Malay where he became an expert in anti-terrorism’.

    Thus, the late, lamented laddie’s time there coincided with, amongst a hundred atrocities or more, the Massacre of Bakang Kali when 24 villagers were riddled by the Royal Marines. Decapitation and mutilation of insurgents by the British Forces of Peace and Reconciliation were commonplace. And became a way of identifying dead guerrillas whom it was not possible to lug out of the jungle.

    In April 1952 a photograph was published of a remorseful Royal Marine Commando holding two insurgents’ heads, one in each hand. Though Brian Steward was an enthusiastic photographer it is not known if he is credited with this particular snap. Being one to mainly manoeuvre, of necessity, in the Dark Room of Reconnaissance.

    The obituary in The Unionist Times does not reveal this to its loyal readership.

    Possibly due to P.O.S. (Pressure of Space).

    (XXX Which caused the somewhat peevish Sultan of Bahar Johor to round on said caddy and whack him across the head with his mail-order Big Bertha. Till the caddy lay safely dead on the first tee.

    Perhaps,somewhat unsurprisingly, the Sultan was known (behind his back,mind) as ‘Moody’ which was a take on his actual first name, ‘Mahmud’. Unlike his more rigorously punished caddy it seems that the most the Sultan got from the local magistrate was a ‘rap across the knuckles’.

    See British-based judicial system in relation to Norneverland and Malaya for possible similariiies and doubtless differences..

  8. aRon October 19, 2015 at 5:06 pm #

    Fruitless rioting as a direct response to the legacy of resentment and injustice towards the RUC. That’s a new one.

    • Jude Collins October 19, 2015 at 5:08 pm #

      You see no link, aRon?

    • neill October 19, 2015 at 8:03 pm #

      spot on aRon

  9. aRon October 19, 2015 at 5:48 pm #

    Link? It’s a stretch befitting a yoga mat.

    Were these teens, born after the formation of the PSNI, protesting against the RUC and their methods?

    Headline should read “Teens riot, while parents don’t particularly care for the where-abouts of their kids”

    • Jude Collins October 19, 2015 at 6:32 pm #

      How do you know their parents didn’t care, aRon? I’m beginning to get a little concerned for the number of assumptions you appear to be making. But perhaps I’m wrong – you know these young people’s parents, then?

  10. Ryan October 19, 2015 at 6:46 pm #

    I have a niece who has friends in Twinbrook and she often takes the bus to go and visit them. My niece is only 13 but when I heard about this gathering I contacted my sister to let her know about it but thankfully my niece stayed in on Saturday night, because the last thing we’d want to hear is her being involved in drinking and rioting against the police. She wouldn’t be allowed near Twinbrook again if that was the case.

    Like many areas in the North, Twinbrook is a very poor area, it has very few facilities for young people, anti-social behaviour is a major problem amongst some of the young too. If they had more facilities, whether its football pitches or whatever, it would certainly help keep many off the streets. Needless to say the area needs more investment and job creation too.

    I’m only 25, so I was around 12 when the RUC was disbanded and the PSNI brought in. I remember the RUC and their dull, depressing, grey armoured vehicles when they passed through our area (I grew up just off the Falls Road near St Peters Primary School, which is still there and which I was a pupil of) and like most of the kids I use to rush out with friends to throw stones at the RUC landrovers. I knew nothing about politics or sectarianism and nor did I care, it was kids just being kids.

    Do I think the PSNI is different from the RUC? Or are they just the same old RUC? Yes and No. I think there has been changes in policing here but not enough change. There is still a core element of the old, sectarian RUC in the PSNI and that needs removed. Until that RUC element is removed and the PSNI engages more with the Catholic community, then there is always going to be an element of distrust against the PSNI from the Catholic community. These young people reflected that on Saturday night. I’m not saying that distrust was the main reason the police was attacked, I’m saying it certainly played a part.

  11. aRon October 19, 2015 at 7:10 pm #

    No need for the concern Jude. If its Saturday night and you don’t know where your kids are at, I’d say that’s a pretty good indicator of the level of concern given.

    • Jude Collins October 19, 2015 at 9:00 pm #

      Yes but how do you know they don’t know?

      • Argenta October 19, 2015 at 9:40 pm #

        So Jude,are you implying that the parents know where their children are and are quite happy about it?

        • Jude Collins October 20, 2015 at 2:29 pm #

          I have no idea, Argenta, wether the parents know or care where their children are, or even if the children have parents. And I’ll bet you £20 now you don’t either. So enough with the conjecturing, OK? Anyway, this ‘Parents, do you know where your children are?’ has a 1950s ring to it. Parents are very important to a child’s life. So is the society they grow up in, the friends they have, the prospects on offer to them, the alternatives to lobbing rocks at the cops. And of course the cops have the job of keeping the peace. Part of that is pre-empting situations where the peace is likely to be disturbed. I gather there’s a case that they didn’t do much pre-empting at Twinbrook. But it’s a bit more than ‘I blame the parents’, that’s for sure.

      • aRon October 19, 2015 at 9:55 pm #

        So you are suggesting that caring parents are happy in the knowledge that their 12 year son or daughter is engaged in anti-social behaviour and that this is linked to said childs disdain for the RUC?

        • Jude Collins October 20, 2015 at 2:18 pm #

          Cor. Don’t remember saying that, aRon. But you’ve clearly detected me doing it. By the way, ‘said child’s disdain’ – I like that. Darlin’ words…

          • aRon October 20, 2015 at 3:01 pm #

            That’ll be the selective memory…

            Certainly you implied a correlation between teen anti-social behaviour and the legacy of the RUC…

            Any thoughts on the frequency of solar flares versus the passenger numbers on the Rathlin Island ferry?

          • Jude Collins October 20, 2015 at 3:11 pm #

            My word, you’re witty, aRon. Keep them coming…

          • aRon October 20, 2015 at 7:39 pm #

            And there was me thinking you didn’t read every comment.

  12. Emmet October 19, 2015 at 8:44 pm #

    My wife, who is Australian, noticed something which seemed very odd to her. While in Ballyshannon (Donegal) with a group of my friends at a music festival when a policeman (guarda) approached us and told us we couldn’t have alcohol on the street. Everyone was very polite, finished what they could of the drinks and binned the cans and apologised to the guarda and wished him a quiet shift. My wife was shocked. Later she told me she was worried when the policeman approached us thinking that my friends ‘would kick off’. She said all of my friends were very caring friendly considerate people but when it came to the police they acted like hardened criminals. I told her about my experiences with the police. She asked why didn’t I complain so I told her what had happened to families who did make a fuss. I think she understood our hostility from then on.

    The public perception of the police hasn’t changed, and recent events have shown the police are not impartial. Sadly large elements of society are alienated from the police and will continue to attack it when the police ‘interfere’. Some of these people are ordinary people who in normal circumstances would be completely law abiding. They are also alienated by Sinn Fein’s support for the psni, and could end up being the next generation of ‘active’ republicans. Sadly Patton was a chance to change things for the better but we are slipping slowly back to the past.

    • aRon October 19, 2015 at 10:01 pm #

      “The public perception of the police hasn’t changed, and recent events have shown the police are not impartial.”

      Emmet, The PSNI are constantly thrown into no-win situations:
      Policing Orange Parades – Attacking are kulture so they our
      to…
      Arresting known republicans, while acting on evidence – Political Policing

      If this is the impartiality you speak of then long may it continue.

      • Jude Collins October 20, 2015 at 2:16 pm #

        aRon, if the police are ‘acting on evidence’ when they arrest ‘known republicans’ …Why do they then release them?

        • aRon October 20, 2015 at 2:54 pm #

          Evidence enough to bring them in for questioning. Questioning leads to to gathering further evidence, which in turn can be used to hopefully catch leading culprits. Didn’t you watch “The Bill”?

          …wouldn’t call it political policing. Just following up on a line of investigation. Long may it continue.

          • Jude Collins October 20, 2015 at 3:13 pm #

            I’m happy to say I’ve never watched The Bill. Liked Minder, mind you.Btw, how do you know they had “evidence enough to bring them in for questioning”? And if they had, why didn’t they charge them with something? Just askin’, like…

          • Jude Collins October 20, 2015 at 3:14 pm #

            And your views on internment, aRon?

          • aRon October 20, 2015 at 3:47 pm #

            I would really recommend you watch The Bill.

            I would of thought that not all evidence leads to a conviction, but is enough to suggest that a person may have links to another person. Six degrees of separation. I would hope that the PSNI continue following up on their lines of investigation. Again, wouldn’t call it political policing.

            And how do you know that such persons brought in for questioning have no links or evidence to share?

          • Jude Collins October 20, 2015 at 5:34 pm #

            Well if they had links/evidence to share, wouldn’t they be prosecuted? Or are you suggesting they’re turned? Six degrees of separation is used to show you can link anyone with anyone. Sounds about right. And if you don’t think there was political policing in the arrest of GA or B Storey, you’ll have to give yourself a wee shake, aRon…

          • aRon October 20, 2015 at 3:50 pm #

            “And your views on internment, aRon?”

            How is this linked to anti-social behaviour in West Belfast?

            From the news, those involved in rioting were as young as 12 years old. I don’t recall a state of internment in 2003.

          • Jude Collins October 20, 2015 at 5:31 pm #

            Just thought you might like to add it to stiffen your law-and-order tone…

          • aRon October 20, 2015 at 5:49 pm #

            I don’t think you can be prosecuted for having evidence. Only if the evidence you have incriminates yourself. Seriously, you need to watch The Bill…

            And if you don’t think GA or B Storey would have knowledge or evidence pertaining to IRA murders, you’ll have to give yourself a wee shake, Jude…

          • Jude Collins October 20, 2015 at 5:54 pm #

            How do you know that last bit, aRon? You seem to be remarkably well-informed…

          • aRon October 20, 2015 at 6:32 pm #

            I see what’s happened here. Could it be that we have the same source who has been playing us off against one another? My source has been feeding me information of GA and BS criminal involvement all the while he’s been feeding you nonsense of political policing. We’ve been had. How embarrassing. NB: Never trust a word that comes from the mouth of Jamie Bryson.

          • Emmet October 21, 2015 at 9:33 am #

            Seriously aRon you can’t understand why impartiality is questioned?? Few examples:
            10,000s of union flags and illegal loyalist paramiltiarly flags flown from lamp posts. Police- a community matter not police’s responsibility. A man waves a Irish flag and is immediately arrested and charged. A few weeks later a republican is arrested placing suicide awareness posters on a lampost- police a criminal activity. Over 50 deaths at hands of loyalists- police ask press to stay away from Loyalist sword victim’s funeral in case the public see unionist MLAs or paramilitary involvement. Republicans provide guard of honour for Peggy O’Hare, police carry out massive security operation arresting many. As for the McGuigan murder, no police force can be so incompetent they arrest 30 republicans and release all without charge. Sorry aRon not plausible, not even on the Bill. I could write a book on PSNI impartiality but I feel I waste my time explaining it to you. Loyalists have killed much more than dissidents. I will bet anything you like, The PSNI have stopped and searched many times more republicans than loyalists. Are the police even bothered about loyalist activity. If i had any doubts I would do a freedom of Information request but I am pretty sure I know how the PSNI operate by now- basically the same as the RUC but with a much better sense of PR.

          • aRon October 21, 2015 at 2:47 pm #

            I hear what you are saying aRon. Now can you follow up that statement with actual evidence? Cue tumbleweed.

            “10,000s of union flags and illegal loyalist paramiltiarly flags”.
            I’m not a legal gent but don’t think flying a Union Flag in the UK is illegal.
            I’m not sure what “paramiltiarly” means. Soz.

            On the Peggy O’Hare Funeral, I could of sworn I heard a volley of shots fired? Must be my hearing. Too many nights spent in a nightclub.

            The PSNI obviously had enough evidence for arrest, otherwise they would be breaking the law. Something they would then have to explain to Gerry Kelly and the Policing Panel. It’s called line of questioning.

            Are you suggesting that the McGuigan murder was at the hands of Loyalists? And that thanks be to political policing, the PSNI are only focusing on Republican thugs opposed to the loyalist thugs that clearly carried out the murder? Or would you prefer that the PSNI arrest and question no one?

            If someone is killed in my street, I don’t care if the PSNI arrest 100 people and release everyone of them, if it means gathering enough evidence to convict the 101st arrest.

            “The PSNI have stopped and searched many times more republicans than loyalists.” Please provide evidence.

            Here’s what I think. Both sides of the community are blighted with a small group of thugs. These thugs are involved in murder, extortion, drugs, punishment beatings et. al, and the PSNI do their best to clamp down on this sort of crime. And I would like to think that such investigations were not leaked to the media and that the PSNI just got on with it without the need to give you, Emmet a regular update.

            For the record, I don’t think you could write a book.

          • Jude Collins October 21, 2015 at 3:14 pm #

            What makes you think Emmet couldn’t write a book, aRon? And I must add, your faith in policing is almost touching. Has it ever occurred to you that there could be a police force/service that might arrest people for political reasons? If it hasn’t, I suggest reading the history of the first fifty years of this state. For starters. Then you could read the history of the RUC during the period of the Troubles.

          • aRon October 21, 2015 at 3:48 pm #

            I can believe that there could be a police force/service that might arrest people for political reasons, sure. I just don’t think that is the PSNI.

            Any book recommendations charting the history of the PSNI?

          • Emmet October 21, 2015 at 9:03 pm #

            For the record aRon, I could write a book if I had time (of course I would edit more carefully). You have ignored the paramilitary flags issue because of a typo? Do a freedom of information request if you have any doubts aRon- it would be hard hard to find out where stop and search powers have been used. I read an article saying more stops and searches were carried out in the Ardoyne than the rest of Belfast combined. With the Peggy O’Hare funeral republicans were being harassed who had nothing to do with it. You really must stop getting your view of reality from the Bill. People get arrested with no evidence at all! Besides, evidence is judged to be evidence by courts. You are missing the point anyway. I understand the perceived bias of the police. It does exist, I am however not sure if it is systematic or a few bad apples, but I do know it will spread and become systematic if the bad apples aren’t identified early enough.

          • aRon October 22, 2015 at 3:29 pm #

            Emmet, I agree with you on the flags. No need. I would take every flag down from every lamppost. And it really does annoy me that the PSNI do not do more, but to be honest I don’t think they would have the resources to go lamppost to lamppost. For the most part these flags are put up by idiots against the wishes of those who live in the area. I’m thinking Ormeau Road as one example. Think also a confederate flag was flown outside the house of young black kid in East Belfast, which his club East Belfast FC banded together to quickly remove it.

            “I read an article saying more stops and searches were carried out in the Ardoyne than the rest of Belfast combined. ”
            Emmet, you presented evidence to me that would suggest otherwise. There have been more arrests in South Belfast than the rest of Belfast.
            …and you wonder why I think you could not write a book.

            “evidence is judged to be evidence by courts.”
            Are you suggesting that prior to every arrest an officer must first present his evidence or rationale for arrest to a court? Noooooooooo, that’s not how it works sweetie.

            “I understand the perceived bias of the police. It does exist, I am however not sure if it is systematic or a few bad apples, but I do know it will spread and become systematic if the bad apples aren’t identified early enough.”

            Surely as the PSNI moves towards a police service that has as many Protestants as Catholics, that the systematic bias that you speak of would die away? Though it would help if bombs were not planted and republican protests not staged at PSNI recruitment days.

          • Emmet October 22, 2015 at 8:58 pm #

            I think you have presented evidence that proves you wrong Aron. You said there have been more arrests in South Belfast. I actually think a stop and search that leads to an arrest is acceptable and shows the powers are working. Therefore the stops in S. Belfast would be legitimate (in general terms). Now listen carefully aRon- you really aren’t getting this. In West Belfast stop and searches generally lead to less arrests, and when the people stopped complain they are facing daily harassment the figures stack up: a smaller proportion of stops in West Belfast lead to arrests. I don’t think you understand stop and search powers aRon. It is also only one measure to look at police bias. In England the power comes with the responsibly of recording the community of each person stopped to avoid systematic discrimination. In the north there is no such requirement which makes it difficult to accurately assess.

            Again with the flags issue you miss the point. I am complaining about impartiality- statements made by the police as well as actions say a lot the community. Police saying illegal flags on lamp posts are a community concern not a police matter is not in line with their actions against nationalists (ie arresting the republican for placing suicide awareness posters on lamp posts, and arresting a person waving a tricolour at a group waving union jacks)

            You also don’t understand the legal system despite watching the Bill. It is not up to the police to evaluate evidence. The courts do judge evidence not the police. Ask an expert if you don’t believe me.

            I agree that balancing the religious split might prevent discrimination. If we ever get a normal society it won’t matter what religion the police are to be impartial. That should be our real goal.

          • aRon October 23, 2015 at 5:00 am #

            Emmet, I have presented no evidence only quoted the evidence that you presented here – http://www.psni.police.uk/2014-15_fy_stop_and_search_report__internet_.pdf

            You said:
            “more stops and searches were carried out in the Ardoyne than the rest of Belfast combined. ”
            You were wrong. More stop and searches happen in South Belfast. And your evidence proves that.

            You said:
            “In West Belfast stop and searches generally lead to less arrests, and when the people stopped complain they are facing daily harassment the figures stack up: a smaller proportion of stops in West Belfast lead to arrests.”

            When does someone not complain when they are being arrested? And how do you know they face daily harassment and only as a republican? Did you question those stopped and searched in East Belfast?

            And here is what your evidence tells us:
            Persons Stopped/Persons Subsequently Arrested %:
            North Belfast= 8.9%
            West Belfast= 7.8%
            East Belfast= 11.4%
            South Belfast= 10.2%

            So your annoyed because there is 0.9% less arrests in West Belfast than anywhere else in Belfast and that it is political policing?

            Isnt the Shankill in West Belfast? How can you break these figures down by political persuasion?

            “In the north there is no such requirement which makes it difficult to accurately assess.”
            Exactly, how can you tell if an arrest is political bias if you are unaware of the demographics of those being arrested? errrr? wtf?

            “arresting the republican for placing suicide awareness posters on lamp posts, and arresting a person waving a tricolour at a group waving union jacks”
            On the suicide prevention posters – do you have a link to the article? What has being a republican got anything to do with it?
            My dad got a parking ticket the other day. He may be considered a unionist. But I’m not telling people that he got a parking ticket for being a unionist.

            As for the flag waving, show me the article? Is this it(http://www.belfasttelegraph.co.uk/news/northern-ireland/man-accused-of-waving-a-tricolour-and-shouting-up-the-ra-at-twaddell-released-on-bail-31384803.html)?

            So he shouted “Up the Ra” while waving a tri-color at a loyalist protest. Clearly an upstanding gent.

            …its not like any fleggers have not been arrested on the Loyalist side. Is this political policing? – http://www.theguardian.com/uk/2013/apr/03/union-flag-protests-arrested-northern-ireland
            They do get treated the same.

            Courts use evidence to convict. Police use evidence to arrest and question. if evidence is insufficient, no charge will be brought forward. Learned that from CSI.

            When’s the book release?

          • Emmet October 25, 2015 at 4:39 am #

            You completely miss the point of the statistics Aron. I will try one time but after this I am giving up on you. The fact that stop and searches in West Belfast lead to less arrests gives some legitimacy to the claim they are using the powers to harass people. If you don’t understand this please try before continuing your debate. On the ardoyne stop and searches- the article only dealt with stop and search under the ‘terrorism powers’. The vast majority of stop and searches in s. belfast are drugs related.

            As I also admitted the figures in the north are hard to analyse because they do not require recording of community background as they do in England but the geographic region makes it clear enough. Yes the Shankill is is the west as the short strand is in the west- both relatively small populations though.

            I don’t think you know much about the legal system here either. Evidence is not always required, people can be found guilty of terrorism on the sole word of a PSNI officer, but that is another issue.

            If you can’t see the injustice of a community activitst being arrested for putting a poster on a lamp post because the police say it is a criminal issue, while at the same time saying putting UDA flags on a lamp post is a community matter then their is no point having a debate with. Look for the articles, I don’t really rely on the mainstream media for stories.

  13. giordanobruno October 20, 2015 at 8:02 am #

    Jude
    This seems like an attempt to shift the blame for rioting onto the police.
    They did not intervene says Jennifer McCann, but imagine what she would have said if they had intervened. No win for the PSNI.
    Where are the local community leaders? Where are the parents?
    Is there any notion of personal responsibility here at all?People are surely primarily responsible for their own actions.
    Yet your angle is all about the PSNI, who after all, did not start the riot!
    Perhaps what is needed is jobs and opportunity for young people in West Belfast to divert them from these kind of activities.
    Who has been representing West Belfast for the last 30 years?
    What about a wee piece on that issue sometime?

    • Jude Collins October 20, 2015 at 2:09 pm #

      Ok – as I’m busy – I agree with everything you say. OK, gio? But what about you doing a guest blog some time, rather than asking me to do another??

  14. Emmet October 22, 2015 at 6:13 am #

    Here aRon check the statistics. East Belfast – 787 stop and searches and 90 arrests. West Belfast 1,580 stop and searches with 127 arrests. a larger percentage of searches in E Belfast led to arrests (mostly drug related). From the PSNI’s own figures see link http://www.psni.police.uk/2014-15_fy_stop_and_search_report__internet_.pdf. Now aRon if you have any intelligence you should be able to see my point with hard facts.

    • Emmet October 22, 2015 at 6:25 am #

      ARon- your grammar is atrocious
      ” I could of sworn”

      • aRon October 22, 2015 at 3:02 pm #

        “it would be hard hard to find”

        Do you mean “very hard”?

        • Emmet October 22, 2015 at 9:00 pm #

          Again aRon, you point out a typo. You have missed my point again!! I am suggesting you shouldn’t point out errors to denigrate someone, especially when you obviously have some weakness with your grammar and punctuation.

    • aRon October 22, 2015 at 3:17 pm #

      Emmet, Let’s take a step back…here’s what you said:

      “The PSNI have stopped and searched many times more republicans than loyalists.”
      You have shown me no evidence to suggest that more Republican’s have been arrested than Loyalists given that the statistics are not broken down by idiocy…In fact there were more arrests in North and South Belfast than in East and West. Seriously? Its Politicial Policing alright. Stop and Searching all those innocent people in the Four Winds area and for what? Its shackin’ so it is…

      “On the Peggy O’Hare Funeral”, are you suggesting that it is acceptable for people to open fire in a Public area? Or are you saying that PSNI were “harassing” the wrong people? Had they been “harassing” those who had fired the shots, would it still be political policing? From the video the gentlemen firing the shots are not the easiest to identify so if the PSNI were speaking to the wrong persons then I can forgive them.

      Are you suggesting that the McGuigan murder was at the hands of Loyalists? And that thanks be to political policing, the PSNI are only focusing on Republican thugs opposed to the loyalist thugs that clearly carried out the murder? Or would you prefer that the PSNI arrest and question no one?

  15. Emmet October 22, 2015 at 9:07 pm #

    Again you missed a point. The funeral- lots of people not involved had their houses searched and family members harassed. This is wrong. Eg. a child walking to school should not be stopped and searched because their uncle is a republican activist.
    Also on bias, someone shooting in the air does not deserve more attention than loyalist crime which kills and injures people. Maybe if teh police allowed more media scrutiny of the loyalist funeral I spoke of we would see more paramilitary involvement there.
    “Are you suggesting that the McGuigan murder was at the hands of Loyalists?”
    Not sure what you are talking about here. Please read more carefully, rather than concentrating on the words try to read the sentences. You really don’t understand peoples’ arguments.

    • aRon October 23, 2015 at 4:27 am #

      “The funeral- lots of people not involved had their houses searched and family members harassed.”
      How do you know who was involved if those firing the shots had their faces covered?

      “Eg. a child walking to school should not be stopped and searched because their uncle is a republican activist.”
      Your right. Do you have a news paper article you can point me to?

      “Also on bias, someone shooting in the air does not deserve more attention than loyalist crime which kills and injures people.”
      I would imagine the PSNI are investigating many crimes on a daily basis. Just because you do not see it, doesn’t mean it doesn’t happen.
      The Peggy O’hara funeral certainly got more media attention because the youtube video went viral. I’d blame the person who put the video on youtube, not the media for picking up on it. I’m sure the loyalist funeral you speak of would of got the same attention if some other brain-child had only thought to pull out his iphone and film the episode.
      I thought this discussion was about the bias of the PSNI…now your on about the media? I wouldn’t give any air time to any idiots who wish to fire shots off at a funeral. But I’m not in broadcasting so I have no control.

      i’ll try again…

      Emmet:”As for the McGuigan murder, no police force can be so incompetent they arrest 30 republicans and release all without charge. ”

      Aaron:
      Are you suggesting that the McGuigan murder was at the hands of Loyalists?
      Or are you unhappy that thanks be to political policing, the PSNI are only focusing on Republican thugs opposed to the loyalist thugs that clearly carried out the murder?
      Or would you prefer that the PSNI arrest and question no one?

  16. Emmet October 24, 2015 at 10:31 pm #

    aRon, All I will say on your first question that is that everyone knows that a larger portion of people harassed had nothing to do with Peggy O’hare’s funeral. Also know this, the police weren’t seriously trying to catch the people who fired the shots, they had no real evidence. They were very interested in finding the people in military clothing- I assume they were going to be charged.

    If you search the local newspapers you might find some reference to it. However if you rely on your view of reality to come from he media then I am not surprised you are so ill informed, People in the community see the intimidation by the PSNI. Even people who completely disagree with the dissidents’ strategy are starting to feel sympathy for individuals based on the treatment of the dissidents’ families.

    “I thought this discussion was about the bias of the PSNI…now your on about the media? ”
    I never mentioned the media. I am talking about the bias of the PSNI. I have given you solid evidence that backs up the harassment and impartiality theory. I knew there was impartiality from many of the stories I listed. You continue to claim the PSNI are biased yet you point to no evidence.

    I really don’t understand the last part of your post:
    “i’ll try again…

    Emmet:”As for the McGuigan murder, no police force can be so incompetent they arrest 30 republicans and release all without charge. ”

    Aaron:
    Are you suggesting that the McGuigan murder was at the hands of Loyalists?
    Or are you unhappy that thanks be to political policing, the PSNI are only focusing on Republican thugs opposed to the loyalist thugs that clearly carried out the murder?
    Or would you prefer that the PSNI arrest and question no one?”

    The murder may well have been loyalists, criminals, brits I have no idea and never claimed to have any. My point is arresting 30 (for one murder????) and none of the men arrested leads to a conviction shows one of 2 things: 1. Incompetence or 2. They are just picking up anyone they wrongly suspect of being involved with no real basis for the arrest (a bit like the wrongful stop and searches in Nationalist areas I have given you).

    If you want to continue your ardent defence of PSNI please provide some evidence that shows they are giving loyalists more attention than dissidents (they have killed more than dissidents, are more numerous and daily are involved in crime). I await your evidence with enthusiasm. I really don’t think you can provide evidence (I wish I was wrong) but I am intelligent enough to see what goes on.

    • aRon October 26, 2015 at 6:43 pm #

      Emmet, you seem to know an awful lot about who and who wasnt involved in the Peggy OHara funeral shootings. Care to share this information with the PSNI to prevent the apparent unwarranted arrests of innocent people?

      You mentioned the media. Republicans posted a youtube video, not a newspaper reporter. Gun shots were fired in public. Instant media attention. condemn the gun shots, not the fact that the PSNI followed up on it.

      The truth is Emmet, that unless you are a PSNI double agent, you have no clue what investigations are being carried out, information gathered or evidence behind arrests. No clue what so ever.

      You have presented no evidence that tells me that more nationalists are harassed more so than loyalists. You presented to me that there are marginally less arrests per stop in search in West Belfast vs the rest of Belfast. Big woop. You presented no evidence that breaks those figures down by political persuasion for an area that also includes the loyalist shankill.

      You presented me with a story of a man who was arrested for going out of his way to drive up to an interface waving a tri color and shouting “up the ra” with the aim of fostering good community relations? Wise Up!

      As I have stated, there is no way to prove political bias as arrest sheets are not broken down by demographics.

      200 loyalists were arrested at the flag protests. Was that political policing?

      Your logic seems to be based on, if a loyalist is arrested, then the charge was warranted, if a nationalist is arrested then it is political policing.

      The law of the land is based on innocent until proven guilty. If the PSNI are guilty of political policing as you say then the onus is on you to prove it. You have been unable to do so.

      Best get someone to proof read that book…