In 1943, when de Valera’s Ireland languished in the doldrums, most of Europe was booming.
Involved in that boom were 25 year old Squadron Leader Peter Elliot of Britain’s Bomber Command, and 23 year old Lt August Geiger of Germany’s Luftwaffe. While flying his Halifax bomber over Holland on March 2 1943 Squadron Leader Elliot and his plane were shot down by Lt Geiger, and he and his crew were killed.
The local Dutch villagers recovered 5 bodies and bought coffins for them and arranged Christian burial. The Germans sent a military party to fire a salute over the fallen men. Their leader spoke – “Comrades, for such I can call you, for after death all contrasts disappear, rest soft in this cool earth.” As the Germans took such things in good spirit a couple of months later the British sent 1,000 bombers to blitz Cologne.
If Britain’s armed forces have ever treated Irishmen who fell fighting them with such gallantry it should be recorded. But it would probably take the genius of the late “historian” Peter Hart to conjure up such a record. In March 1988 when Michael Stone murdered three mourners at a Republican funeral, he was armed with two pistols and bombs which were part of a large consignment donated by British “Security” Forces to the UVF and the UDA. The British acquired them from South Africa’s Bureau of State Security run by Mrs Thatcher’s racist friends. “Security Force” onslaughts on Republican funerals had a long and sordid history, at least from the days of Lloyd George’s days in 10 Downing Street.
None of this can justify the IRA’s bombing of the Enniskillen Remembrance ceremony.
If the leaders of Fianna Fail, Fine Gael and the Irish Labour Party were sincere about reconciliation they would visit Belfast’s Milltown Cemetery and lay wreaths at the
Republican plot, for those buried there, well or ill-advised, were dedicated to the ideals that motivated De Valera, Collins, W T Cosgrave and James Connolly in 1916.
The Irish Defence Forces should honour Liam Lynch and Michael Collins, but also Charlie Kerins and Sean South, and Bobby Sands. If they have any regard for the memory of Tom Kettle they will even honour the Invincibles. I can recall reading in the 1960s of the then IRA Chief of Staff claiming that they were “today’s Invincibles.”
Exactly 22 years before I was born British troops murdered Lawrence Kennedy in the Phoenix Park as he was going about his lawful business. No relation of mine, so far as I know.


looks bad draft dodgers laying wreaths,
In November 1920 Michael Collins risked his life to attend the removal of the bodies of Brigadier Dick McKee and Vice-Brigadier Peadar Clancy who had been murdered by
Crown Forces in Dublin Castle.
In my youth I was a Sunday Soldier and Sunshine Patriot in the FCA and, like my
comrades considered myself part of the Army in which Collins, McKee and Clancy played
such heroic roles.
Each November we assembled in Dublin Castle and marched past the City Hall where
Dublin Brigade veterans took the salute.
Such State Remembrance has been long discontinued. And some serving and former
members of the Defence Forces appear eager to dishonour Mckee, Clancy and all our
patriot dead.
Donal, you are obviously an historian of some standing, have you written your book yet or am I just an ignoramous unaware of your greatness.
I am not a historian. I got Honours in History and Geography combined in the Intermediate Certificate in 1957.
But I a keen amateur student of history. We used have the Irish Press most days, the
Sunday Independent, and the Evening Herald or the Evening Mail. When the Sunday Press
was established in 1949 and and the Evening Press in 1954 we got the one every Sunday
and sometimes the other. The INDO was largely anti- Fianna Fail and had correspondents like
Piaras Beaslai who had played heroes’s in the Anglo-Irish war. But the paper was more Catholic than the Pope.
The Evening Mail had been a Unionist paper. During the Anglo-Irish war it had done its own
honest reporting while The Irish Times had printed Dublin Castle handouts as the unvarnished truth. We never had the Irish Times in our house until Douglas Gageby, whose
allegiance was to Ireland, became Editor.
We didn’t need academics with fancy theories to explain Ireland’s recent history as our
adult neighbours had lived through it. Men who had fought in the Great War, IRA veterans
of the Anglo-Irish War, “Treatyites” and “Irregulars” lived cheek by jowl and their children
played and inter-married together.
On the Hill of Howth we bought our milk from a farmer who used lead an Orange Parade in
Howth every year. One of his seven sons was the sole member of the local GAA club’s
Vigilance Committee charged with enforcing the ban on “Garrison” Games. At least
one of the local Gardai played football for Ben Eadar’s and Rugby for Suttonians RFC,
He was a Kerryman named de hOra under one code and Hoare under the other. A Cute
Hoor, you might say.
Our closest neighbours were Protestants, and good neighbours they were.
As for my writing, I can only quote Touchstone, of his intended bride, Audrey, in “As You
Like It” –
“A poor thing, but mine own.”
My grandchildren, in their youth and innocence,.believe I’m a great man. When they stop
believing in Santa Claus, I think they’ll snap out of it.
Bridget, one can be aware, but still be an ignoramus.
With what we now know with clear evidence of collusion and the role of highly placed informers such as stakenife, who were protected and allowed to murder with impunity by the state, it does make me wonder about who exactly gave the go ahead for the remembrance day bombing in Enniskillen, who would even think that this was a legitimate target, given the high risk of civilian deaths, who gained most from it propaganda wise etc, certainly not the republican movement, who almost certainly lost support because of it. It does beg the question would the Brits sacrifice innocent protestant lives in the certain knowledge of the inevitable public backlash against the IRA and would certainly hurt Sinn Féin electoraly?
I’m shocked by your cynicism. Would a British Government load a passenger liner with
munitions and choose to put it in the vicinity of an enemy submarine?
Would an Irish Government hinder investigation of the wreck lest the question was
properly answered?
In the 1950s an American Admiral concluded that the sinking of USS MAINE was
accidental.
Did the US Government know that at the time of its sinking? They used the accident
to attack Spain, seize the Philippines, Cuba and Puerto Rica.
As I say, I’m horrified at your cynicism.
Joe
Are you saying that the I R A weren’t responsible for the Enniskillen Remembrance Day bombing?It seems a bizarre theory to advance after all these years.
Problem was IRA did not fight like a the German army. Don’t recall WW2 tales of German soldiers knocking heroically on front doors,asking children if their ‘Daddy was home’ only to shoot Daddy multiple times in front of said child. Or the favoured Iron Cross tactic of slipping into a bar, planting a bomb, and telling the local punters they had more time to kiss their ass goodbye than sup up their pint. Nor Recall Hitler sending over his legions of under car booby trap bombers that may or may not kill an entire family the next morning, but that didn’t matter as they were long gone. Such heroics. The Pride and adulation of a Nation is deserved all round.
Never heard of Anne Frank? a German child who lived in Holland
Poland? The Warsaw Ghetto.
Russia?
You probably spend too much time reading your tattoos to seriously
study the world we live in.
last time i was in the dam there were signs all over the place pointing to anne franks house..not a bit of wonder the germans found her,
Very good!!! (Well, it made me laugh…..)
True, much easier to drop incendiaries from planes onto civilians, including children. Actually, just shooting your enemy is more decent.
KopperbergCentral, a very partisan rant there…..all war is ugly but the Brits have surpassed almost every other nation in their barbarity of which I’m sure you’re aware ( if you read collective history and not just an abridged sanitized version ). Joe McIvor may just have hit the nail on the head ,as Enniskillen is still being used 31 years later for nefarious propaganda by unscrupulous politicians of every hue. . Every single death that could be used was used and is still being used by Britain to justify their illegal presence here…..who pits Catholic against Protestant …Nationalist against Unionist…..it’s not Sinn Féin. Bloody Sunday ,Ballymurphy ,McGurks bar ,Dublin,Monaghan etc etc the unending list of death and destruction courtesy of these ” impartial “peacekeepers.
What about the Special Ops crowd who were dropped behind enemy lines to kill or sabotage and the withdraw, leaving the locals to be punished by the Nazis?