Two items in the media this morning caught my attention. The first was an article by Diarmuid Ferriter in the Irish Times, where he notes the various polls showing that not just unionists but Catholics/nationalists in the north wouldn’t be interested in a united Ireland, especially if it was going to cost them money. The other was a short item on RTÉ radio, just before the nine o’clock news, where they noted the outrage expressed by Senator David Norris over the non-appearance of Mairia Cahill at a debate with other candidates for the Seanad. Norris was in scorching form and received support for his views from a couple of other senators; but the commentator on RTÉ made it clear that this wouldn’t make any difference, any more than Catherine McCartney’s press release and letter to members of the Oireachtas wouldn’t make any difference. On Friday Mairia Cahill will be made a member of the Seanad.
I’ve given my views on the emptiness of the question ‘Do you favour a united Ireland?’ in an earlier blog. But what is striking about Ferriter’s piece is the extent to which the people of the south – and some in the north – appear not to care if partition is ever ended. A hundred years ago, the idea that the people in what is now Northern Ireland were not Irish would have been laughable. Now, if we’re to believe opinion polls, the majority in the north and in the south don’t see northern nationalists/republicans as Irish. References to ‘Ireland’ and ‘this country’ are almost as frequent in the south as references to ‘Northern Ireland’ and ‘this wee country’ are in the north. The lack of logic, let alone the morality, of disowning hundreds of thousands of your fellow-countrymen and women doesn’t seem to enter into it.
As to Ms Cahill’s elevation to the Seanad, despite her position in the dissident republican RNU: it makes clear that most southern politicians will use any stick, however muddy, with which to whack Sinn Féin – that’s Sinn Féin, the one political party on the island which unambiguously doesn’t believe that Irishness stops at Augnacloy.


Really interested to see if the ‘official’ commemoration ceremony refers to ‘the North’ and how the wishes of the rebels regarding Irish freedom have not been totally fulfilled –
The south has moved on and you and your community have not sadly accepted it.
Remind us who celebrates a battle in 1690 Neill?….
I don’t celebrate it at all.
“I don’t celebrate it at all.”
What are your views neill?
Do you support the orange order?
Do you feel they should be allowed to march through nationalist areas that make it clear they do not want sectarian marches?
Do you believe orange marches are even sectarian?
Would really like to hear your thoughts.
Your community doesn’t Neill?
Great.story.Jude.and.I.am.not.a.troll.
You.are.a.wise.man.Jim.
Jim
You have exceeded your word allowance. Please don’t do it again.
My.apologies.Jim.
Cheers
Reminds me of a film from a few years ago but I have appropriated the title and given a twist.
“No country for Northern Irish men”.
So true PJ, starting to feel like a second class citizen. love the Coen brothers though.
A concise piece Jude, and very well summarised. In company of Unionists and Nationalists alike, I never use the term “Northern Ireland”. I had a recent exchange today in which I refered to the six counties as the north. One of them is a good friend of mine who laughed ay the observation that that was ‘Provie talk”. Nah, you respect my Irish Identity, and I’ll respect your right to call yourself British. A sharp look was enough to let an antagonist know, that cross the line and revert to sectarianism, or call me a Fenian Bastard to my face, and a smack in the mouth would swiftly follow. The cafers are off their knees. Am Irish, and wish SF would stop tiptoeing around with the ‘Island’ tripe. We must refer to our country as Ireland if we see it as so, mindsets will not change if we remain semantically cowtowing around placating ever more intransigent Unionism. Well put Jude
Grma,Francis…
I bet you are really tough Francis the terror of your work place indeed.
Neill, I don’t take Sectarian Shite, and I don’t think anyone should, from wherever they hail from. I think this is a reasonable and measured principle to promote tolerance and harmony, wouldn’t you agree?
If you don’t agree Neill, say why you don’t, and do not revert to crude reductionist inanities. I have zero tolerance for sectarianism, and have punched an Afrikaner Unionist before for intimidatory language. It’s on my record, but what the hell, the Judge at least acknowledged the provocation before fining me. I’d do it again anytime Neill, and fear no-one who promotes such invective. Stick to the point Neill.
Oh my point is quite simple not only do you claim to be tough you beat people up and you have a criminal record. My word your family must be so very proud of you.
I had a recent exchange today in which I refered to the six counties as the north. One of them is a good friend of mine who laughed ay the observation that that was ‘Provie talk”. Nah, you respect my Irish Identity, and I’ll respect your right to call yourself British. A sharp look was enough to let an antagonist know, that cross the line and revert to sectarianism, or call me a Fenian Bastard to my face, and a smack in the mouth would swiftly follow.
So you give your friend a dirty look because he said something you disagreed with you really are a class act. This is the difference between me and you just because I loath what some people say I wouldn’t practice violence on them. Sadly for you and luckily for the rest of us the IRA`s military campaign seems to be over as you sound as like you would have been a willing recruit.
No Neill, my friend laughed at the other two’s insinuation that being Irish is Provie Talk. My Unionist friend is a person of integrity, something not endorsed by many others who might otherwise have an an affinity with the Afrikaner. Call me a Fenian Bastard to my face, and someone is asking for trouble. You misrepresent my position as if allowing hate-provocation is acceptable, and combatting it is somehow degrading oneself. I think allowing the degradations of an eon in Ireland, that have fomented so much Sectarian Murder, is a horrible thing to allow. People have had enough of the Razor gangs, and Butchers….
Francis, I have taken out your last sentence. I think you’ll know why. Please, no more.
Don’t mind our Neill, Francis, he’s the type that wears a poppy to remember two imperialist wars dressed up as battles for “freedom” (all the while the country he declares loyalty to denied freedom to 1/4 of the World at 1 point) but then attacks people for campaigning for civil rights or people who took up arms against a state that was sectarian to its core. Just your traditional DUP voter, basically.
As for the reference to a “smack in the mouth”, why not? a little bit of pain never hurt anyone…..if you know what I mean….
“Don’t mind our Neill, Francis, he’s the type that wears a poppy to remember two imperialist wars dressed up as battles for “freedom” (all the while the country he declares loyalty to denied freedom to 1/4 of the World at 1 point) but then attacks people for campaigning for civil rights or people who took up arms against a state that was sectarian to its core. Just your traditional DUP voter, basically. ”
You could consider Neill as an essential contributor Jude, helps stop us losing focus on why we want and how important it is to get an end of british rule in ireland.
The people in the south understand very well what we have to put with. The southern politicians and media may be under estimating just how clued in they actually are.
I value neill’s contributions, particularly as he goes against the current of most posts. That’s not always easy to do. But I really do want him and everyone to lay off name-calling/slagging/whatever, and try to stick to making your argument as clearly and concisely as you can.
Ah good old Ryan the word Mopery could have been invented for you.
By some of your contributions your just basically a traditional SF voter.
Neill -look at your contribution – beyond name-calling, what are you saying?
Not as tough as you Neill, that’s for sure….
Ah I leave the rough stuff to you Ryan you seem much more suited to it than I.
Enough already with the rough stuff talk, please (I’m not directing this at you particularly, neill, so relax). That really is getting to the playground/corner gang level. Let’s discuss/argue like adults, OK?
It is said that a language is the most distinctive mark of the intellectual independence of any country. Attempts have been made and continue to be made to colonise minds in Ireland. The Statutes of Kilkenny were passed in 1366 in order to promote English culture among English settlers and resistance to an Irish Language Act continues to the present time. Irish scholars have a proven track record through the centuries, a trend that continues to the present day, without the need for military might, death and destruction.
The Penal Laws (1695) were, according to Edmund Burke,
“a machine of wise and elaborate contrivance, as well fitted for the oppression, impoverishment and degradation of a people, and the debasement in them of human nature itself, as ever proceeded from the perverted ingenuity of man.”
The red tops will continue with attempts to influence and sway public opinion on all things Irish, using crude stereotypes and caricatures. Daily references to the six north eastern counties of Ulster as a ‘country’ remain testament to fundamental insecurities concerning a national identity. Stereotypes accommodate insecurities, they do not aid understanding.
In Londonduring the Rugby World Cup all the pubs showing the Championships
sported the flags of all the nations recognised by the ordinary Londoner.
They included one flag not flown by the IRFU, the National Flag of Ireland.
In my sixth decade on this planet and I have been in all 32 counties….all our cities ,most of our towns and definitely hundreds of our pubs and I have yet to be asked my opinion by a pollster . I have proffered my opinion many times ,sometimes well accepted, sometimes not ! None of my family or extended family have been approached either. Where do they lurk ,do they maybe carry out their surveys in the newspaper offices who request these polls.I mainly confine myself (wisely) to nationalist areas in the six counties but in my jaunts around Ireland I have very rarely encountered opposition to the re-unification of our country.In my opinion polls are as meaningless as counting sand…..if you carry out one in West Belfast you’ll get a specific result….same with Dublin 4…different result ,but still as inconsequential.
The reason the staters do not care about the north eastern counties is very simple. Whilst we were living under the collective jackboots of the B Specials/UDR/Unionist Party/RUC/Orange Order/Brits, they were getting on with their lives. Had the above mentioned lovelies set foot in the twenty six for any sustained length of time the old guns and grenades would have been taken out of their boxes. Dublin would have a Bobby Sands Street and the trains would be pulling intoMaire Drumm Station. Hypocrites.
Excellent, Jude and well put, Francis. There’s little a swift punch in the mouth will not speedily resolve. A couple of things come to mind:
Padraig Pearse lived his entire life under British rule. Did that make him any less an Irishman?
Having to fight ( in argument terms) for ones Irishness every day, I believe makes us as, if not more Irish than our southern counterparts, who take it all for granted.
Ironically though, there is a grain of comfort taken from partition and that is not having to listen to the sectarian arguments from unionists in the Dail. Like having the swings closed on Sundays.
Lastly, my Irish passport provides me with written confirmation of my Irish citizenship ( not that I required it). I may be subject to British rule, but I am an unadulterated citizen of Ireland. That can never be taken away.
Thankfully it is nobody’s gift to declare who should be or not be called Irish. If you are born on this Island you are Irish; it is no more complicated than that.
However there are some who hail from the southern part of this Island who give the distinct impression in their obsequiousness to all things British as wishing that the Brits had never left.
I thought it showed incredible good will in particular from the people in the south, for so many willing to take us in warts and all as things are at present being an economic disaster, 36% was it.
The reality is, if we dont get our act together I doubt it will be as high when it comes to the crunch.
I dont want to be a charity case from either london or dublin.
I believe unification will benefit the economy of the whole country but no one is even talking about potential benefits yet.
There are those who would hold us back economically to prevent unification, at least for as long as england are prepared to foot the bill.
But for how much longer will that be do you think and what happens after the money runs out?
Do we demand Dublin simply pucks up the tab? I dont want that.
I doubt anyone on this island believes the north is not irish, but it is an economic disaster case and has bitterly divided inhabitants.
Who else would want us seriously?
well this deal thats going down is looking 25yrs ahead so thats 2040.
You’re right there, Belfastdan. You try and remove the royal prefix from, The Royal Dublin Horse show, and you’ll find out pretty quick how embedded the west British obsequiousness is in our capital city.
That we are Irish is not in question. The southern government hold no monopoly on this term. People living in the north could also make the equally ludricous claim that people in the south are not really Irish and that we in the north are the true Irish. The truth is that anyone living on the island has a right to this identity. What is in question is our independence. The majority of those within the southern and northern administrations seem to favour Britain and other nations dictating the rules by which our society is governed. Fine Gael are very much swayed by what their EPP (European People’s Party) overlords think on matters of economy and governance. As well as Fine Gael, The European People’s Party also include the true heirs of General Franco in Spain in the guise of the Partido Popular and Angela Merkel’s Christian Democratic Union. As for the main unionist party’s they do exactly what they say on the tin. They favour a union with Britain whereby others make their decisions for them. What we have to convince people both north and south is that we can thrive as an independent nation. In the mean time we can be working on the cultural and linguistic aspects of our Irish identity as well as building a stronger society and creating cross-border links at a non-political level.
NUANCE
The n-word is probably the key, Esteemed Blogmeister, to understanding what the Free Southern Stateen is about these enlightened and electrifying days.
N for Nation, of course, but more to the point, the n for nuance word. A nuanced Nation sorta thingy, like. Unlike the dark past when uniformity as in one size fits all was the order of the day, or rather night when we were living in a pre-electricity period and were compelled to dress in the dark.
In the contemporary FSS we are more into subtlety, tinges, shadings, gradations, niceties, soupcons even.
We are, you see, a far more, erm, sophisticated lot entirely. We know this because we say so ourselves and insist on endlessly telling ourselves so, on radio, in papers, on the floor of the Irish Parliament itself.
Yesterday, for instance, was a pink-letter day for the n-word: when the nuancy boys and girls gathered below the crystal chandeliers of Dublin Castle to celebrate in a restrained and dignified way the mudslide, oops, landslide victory in the recent rainbow neverndum.
And as the same crystal chandeliers lit up the paintings on the wall and the marble statues stood stately in St. Patricia’s Hall, the p word was palpable. Pride wafted through the restrained assembly as Charlie hugged Charlie and Charlotte embraced Charlotte.
Gra is the Law ! LGBT is the Dli !
At long last the shackles are rent in twain as horses are now free to moo, cows to neigh, dogs (even those in the street) are at liberty to miaow and cats (not least those in the alleyways) have been given the green light to bark. And, of course, apples have had those draconian restrictions lifted. They have, finally, carte blanche to pick and choose which ivy tree to grow upon.
We have, opined the Yawnaiste, while addressing the fawn-coloured mudia, oops, media, grown up and matured as a nation, not unlike a good whine.
No doubt, somewhere over the Rainbow at Dublin Castle the sprite of gay icon supreme, Judy Garland was beaming down delightedly.
Or, was she?
This question is begged along with the following: will this timely crowd which is laughing loud help to dry each other’s tears when the new wears off the crystal chandeliers?
Aye, there’s the rub.
Consider the following: when, in July 1951, Judy Garland sang ‘Pretty Girl milking the Cow’ on the state of the Theatre Royal in Dublin she went to the trouble of familiarizing herself with the original version in leprechaun. This she achieved by singing the ballad phonetically.
Seemingly, the lady who was later, for whatever impenetrable reason, to become a gay icon (her six husbands would seem to indicate that she herself was a devoted follower of the body music of Hetero Tull – toil duine a bheatha / each to his or her own) made a highly peculiar assumption. To wit, that Ireland, being a state whose constitution stated that Leprechaun was the First Official Language this gesture would be, like, the most natural thing in the world.
Imagine !
Somewhat akin to the House of Armani assuming that every Charlie south of the Black Sow’s Dyke is a fancy boy in tight pants and every Charlotte dresses down in the de rigeur dungarees of the Dworkin Class.
For what it’s worth, incidentally, folklore has it that ‘Cailin deas cruite na mBo’ is the only melody to have had a cover verson recorded by humankind from the original leprechaun . It was to cross the musical frontier from fairyland to Tin Pan Alley.
Perchance, that is the reason why Judy G became a gay icon. Either than or because her name in the Wizard of Oz was Dorothy Gael, oops, Gale.
Gay, not Gaelic as the Yawnaiste keeps reminding us; she who is seemingly aiming for the sobriquet: ‘Cailin deas cruite na Votai’ / ‘Pretty girl milking the Votes’.
Good, too, to see serial election flop, the distinguished Fianna Failure, Noel Whelan of Ubiquity PR, hop on the winning Vaigin Banna / Bandwagon for once.
To conclude, with two brief examples from the nuancy news items in today’s (gasp) Irish Independent on Diwali Day.
In reporting how allegations of pedophilia have been levelled against (gasp) a former, erm, respected cabinet minister in the F.S.S., John Downing is up to namechecking and at length too, the otherwise unrelated RC clergy and the SF party. Lest we forget, lest we forget, at the going down of the sun and in the morning.
That there was no such namechecking accredited to the Methodists and the Media, both of which exalted institutions have had their little peccadillos in this regard, need not necessarily be put down to pressure of space in the Indo. More a matter of nuance, dear boy, nuance.
Then there was the diffident article by the poster boy of the science of economics in the FSS: Dismal David McWilliams . Whose headline shrieked in a measured way: ‘THE HEROES OF 1916 WERE ECOOMINICALLY CLUELESS’.
And there was Perkie’s inner bog oak monolithic to be thinking that all the heroes of 1916 had succumbed to lead poisonig in the Stonebreakers’ Yard of Kilmainhham Jail.
Perhaps it was, after all, a near-death experience these economic illiterates had suffered. Or – worse ! – a near-debt experience?
Btw, Dismal David McWilliams is, according to his own modest self, the same prophet who foretold the loss of profits at the tail end of the Celtic Tiger. Though, in fairness, going backward, it is only recently that the soothing soothsayer has been reminding all and sundry of this fact.
Meanwhile, what one deeply regrets here is the loss of all those would be John M. Keynes, potential Adam Smiths and ichoate Milton Friedmans who, in joining the Dublin Fusiliers (out of economic necessity, be it noted) were lost to the art of beancounting in the mud and the blood of Flanders.
Ah, the nuance of that.
Taimse im chodladh is na rooster me.
Think I’ll give this blog a miss from now on unfortunately Jude. I agree with you on a lot of issues and I do like the opinions offered, especially the ones which are different to mine. I just can’t be bothered even scrolling past another long-winded call-it-what-you-want post from PW, never mind reading it. Is he/she really contributing to the blog of the day, or just amusing themselves. Either way I won’t be reading again. Bored with those contributions. Good luck.
Sorry to lose you, ASR, but I must disagree with you on Perkin Warbeck. Perkin is a law unto himself and decides what matters he will touch and how. I find his writing orginal, stuffed with glancing references, glorious, like a jazz clarinetist running wild. Of course, if you don’t like him, you don’t have to read him. There’s all that other wisdom by other posters, not to mention (blushes and kicks post) my own… Anyway, as you may have noticed, people on this site make up their own minds. You’re welcome to return at any point and I personally would value hearing more of your own thinking on matters. Beannachtaí Dé…
I think you are a bit harsh ASR concerning perkin warbeck. I enjoy his contribution on this blog. Usually there is humour to his writing interspersed with useful info and of course the odd handy bit of gaeilge. Long may it continue.
It’s all about accents. I can feel closer emphatically with someone who has the same accent as mine, even though our views maybe polar opposites, compared to someone from the deepest, darkest, south of Ireland whose outlook on life maybe similar.
“It’s all about accents. I can feel closer emphatically with someone who has the same accent as mine, even though our views maybe polar opposites, compared to someone from the deepest, darkest, south of Ireland whose outlook on life maybe similar.”
Sounds more like a deep rooted hatred there KC.
Accents very by county, Ballymena, Derry and Belfast all have very different accents?
Perhaps a smaller island would be more suitable for you.
I’m very sceptical about poll’s in general. They are usually unreliable. Just one example is back before the British General Election where nearly every poll showed that there would be no out right majority won by any political party at Westminster. The results were very different, the Tories won a majority, a result very few polls predicted.
Now in this poll on Irish Unity, done on both sides of the border, there was only 2000 people questioned. Needless to say 2000 people hardly reflects the opinion of nearly 7,000,000 people across Ireland. Not only that, there is currently no campaign being pursued by any Pro-Irish Unity party to promote Irish Unity. And in the current economic climate, where down South are going through severe austerity and the North is as big an economic cesspit as ever (the benefits of being in the UK, eh?), the main thing on peoples minds is not Irish unity or keeping the Union but jobs, providing for their families and getting through tough times.
So I wouldn’t take that poll done by the BBC and RTE too seriously. What the likes of Sinn Fein must do now is do as well as they can in the Southern elections next year and hopefully be in Government by 2021. In Stormont Nationalists, in the long term, are heading for a majority and the First Minister post (which is no different to the Deputy post in terms of powers but still very symbolic) as long as SF can engage and get the numbers out to vote. Weaning the North’s economy off the public sector is essential to Irish Unity. As time goes on the border will become irrelevant as the North and South’s economy, etc integrates, that can only make Irish Unity more likely.
But obviously what we ultimately will need for Irish Unity is a border poll and THAT is what matters, not asking just 2,000 people their opinion
with a bit of luck we could be out of europe shortly,what chance then for borders.
“with a bit of luck we could be out of europe shortly,what chance then for borders.”
Neither Scotland or Ireland will be out of Europe.
The tories are divided on it, but i doubt the english people would even leave.
It could break up the UK though.
I would rather see Ireland as part of a british block within europe including both islands.
The UK needs updated with less emphasis on kingdoms less the territory of that kingdom will be greatly reduced.
“What the likes of Sinn Fein must do now is do as well as they can in the Southern elections next year and hopefully be in Government by 2021. In Stormont Nationalists, in the long term, are heading for a majority and the First Minister post (which is no different to the Deputy post in terms of powers but still very symbolic) as long as SF can engage and get the numbers out to vote. Weaning the North’s economy off the public sector is essential to Irish Unity. As time goes on the border will become irrelevant as the North and South’s economy, etc integrates, that can only make Irish Unity more likely.
But obviously what we ultimately will need for Irish Unity is a border poll and THAT is what matters, not asking just 2,000 people their opinion”
Well said Ryan and very true
Never underestimate the ‘murder machine’. It has evolved itself not only in the classrooms but across the media. The machine indoctrinates people in Ireland and indeed Britain at a very young age to embrace royalty and all its imperialist trappings. Simply put irish republicans need to stop playing fair and take the machine on at its on game and that starts in the classrooms. Otherwise as Jessica mentioned above when it comes to the crunch, numbers will indeed be low. Keep politics out of sport,education etc? Absolute rubbish. Poppy anyone?
“Simply put irish republicans need to stop playing fair and take the machine on at its on game and that starts in the classrooms. ”
There is a good reason unionists fear a museum of the history of the troubles, even one based only on facts and worded by respected historians.
They don’t want their version of history to be rewritten.
The irish flag should by flying over relevant nationalist controlled state buildings here, not on lamp posts.
I think the question of a United Ireland in the 26 counties passes through two filters with vastly different answers.
I’ve been living in the Republic for the past 13 years and through one filter, anyone I’ve ever talked to on the issue is quite supportive of the idea and I’ve never met anyone who would oppose it (at least not in conversation with me), even in the leafy suburbs of Dublin 4 and Dublin 6.
The other filter is the ‘official’ answer from the political parties and state organs in the Republic. They’re coy on the idea and will never vocally support it. Even the ‘Republican Party’ Fianna Fail passes the issue off with meaningless guff from Mehole Martin:
“I would love to see a united Ireland. But how does one define what one means by a united Ireland? I would say a genuine unity of people who can work in harmony, meet in harmony, engage in harmony and break down the barriers”
For a long time, the political parties in the Republic have been partitionist, whereas the people aren’t. I think these parties need to be called out, do they really support their fellow Irishmen in the North, or are they happy to remain as gormless partitionists.
“For a long time, the political parties in the Republic have been partitionist, whereas the people aren’t. I think these parties need to be called out, do they really support their fellow Irishmen in the North, or are they happy to remain as gormless partitionists.”
There is a lot of good will in the republic, not only for reunification but for taking unionist concerns on board.
It has not been taken seriously or discussed in any meaningful way at all.
I suppose until the immediate economic issues from britain no longer willing to waste money here are sorted, there is little point.
But hopefully soon we can start talking about how best we can help grow the economy throughout this island for all our benefits, and not have the media simply throw out the pathetic question, can dublin afford to pick up the tab as if we have any right for anyone to be paying our way.
There is a reality check for all of the people in the north coming down the road on this very issue.