The Sinn Fein reconciliation project has been one sided from conception and I believe it has got to the point where I don’t think anyone could argue it is anything but one sided.
On one hand you have Sinn Fein cow towing to the DUP, allowing them to block every single proposal that doesn’t meet unionist approval. If there is an Irish tinge to it then the veto of concern is used and abused. In spite of being told they are a stench to which senior DUP figures have to hold their noses to, Sinn Fein ignore this abuse and try to keep the relationship going. The put downs of course play to the unionist electorate who love seeing their political representatives showing strong leadership and taking a dominating role, hence the put downs such as rogues and renegades, having to leave a gatekeeper as if nationalism were some ignorant rookie who might mess the whole thing up.
But why is reconciliation so one sided?
As usual when seeking guidance I turn to google who describe one-sided as “unfairly giving or dealing with only one side of a contentious issue;”
Bingo, unionism is indeed behaving in a one sided manner.
I then noticed the synonyms: biased, prejudiced, partisan, partial, preferential, discriminatory, inequitable, unfair, influenced, slanted, unjust, narrow-minded, bigoted
Wow I thought, these could very well have been the synonyms for me that describe Irish Unionism to a tee.
Let’s face it, Sinn Fein may be partners in government with the DUP, but we all know who the controlling partner is. I wouldn’t quite call Arlene a femme fatale but Martin is going the right way to her taking on the role of his dominatrix, in a political sense rather than physical. A controlling relationship is not a nice experience and often difficult to get out off. Often one partner will begin to dominate and intimidate their partner, isolating you from the support of friends and family, applying criticism and put downs to break your confidence and controlling every aspect of the relationship.
Sinn Fein are being seen as weak and are losing support of their grass roots, their vote has gone down and will likely continue to go down as more nationalists become sick of unionist intransigence. Isolating a party from their grass roots support often kills a party. The DUP have no shortage of members willing to take pot shots and throwing out insults in the guise of humour towards Sinn Fein and nationalism. Even their leader was happy to call us rogues and renegades. Obviously she doesn’t consider nationalists fit for government but presently has no choice, hence the gatekeeper role during the hokey kokey.
The veto of concern has given the DUP are big stick which they have shown they are not afraid to abuse and will use it to dominate and enforce their control. Sure, it works both ways but nationalism refuse to abuse it back.
Another example of control was the withdrawing of funding for a new £1m state-of-the-art community centre in Co Antrim because of a row over the names of two IRA men on the gates into the planned site. The proposed new sports and community centre in Glenariff is due to be built within the grounds of Oisin Glenariff GAA club where the gates near the site bear the names Charlie McAllister and Pat McVeigh while the ground is named McAllister-McVeigh Memorial Park in their honour. The two IRA members were killed in 1922 – some seven months before the signing of the Anglo-Irish Treaty. Work on the Co Derry facility, including halls, a gym and 3G pitch, had been due to begin in January.
The DUP are intent on blaming republicans for starting the conflict and for every act of violence in Ireland over the past 100 years, a policy which the media and both states seem only too happy to support.
The best thing to do when in a controlling relationship, is to get out of it but would the nationalist parties agree to this?
More likely that the SDLP would jump at the chance to take on the roll, Colum has his leather pants with the bum cheeks removed and a nice red, white and blue paddle for whoever wishes to wield it all ready to go.
One thing is for sure, I and many others won’t be voting for this.
I will leave you with a quote from one of the founding Fathers of the United States who achieved their freedom from British rule:
“The alternate domination of one faction over another, sharpened by the spirit of revenge natural to party dissension, which in different ages and countries has perpetrated the most horrid enormities, is itself a frightful despotism. But this leads at length to a more formal and permanent despotism.”
– George Washington


Have to agree with you Jessica.
It seems Martin McGuinness and the rest of the Sinn Fein elite are quite prepared to bend over any time Arlene feels in the mood so she can kick their arses to her heart’s content – just because she knows they will allow her.
And as you say, this is why their vote is diminishing election after election, allowing the likes of PBP, never heard of previously in some circles, to suddenly have two MLAs.
People don’t vote for Sinn Fein to be publicly humiliated on a weekly basis, watching gestures of reconciliation thrown back in disgust, and never a thought of reciprocation.
Will Sinn Fein learn to grow some backbone before they start to follow the SDLP into political obscurity?
Sinn Fein and nationalists could easily play this game back if they wanted. They’ve blocked a community centre because they say the names of the IRA members on the gate cause trauma.
Its control freakery, domination and discrimination or as Arlene nicely calls it gatekeeping.
Know your place taig.
Sinn Fein could apply the sames rule to every British war memorial and have them demolished or removed. The same rule for grants anywhere a union jack or loyalist flag is flung. Orange Order parades to get the same treatment. Oh the trauma.
Start erecting Irish flags all year round as unionist councils.
The stoops bent for spad then refused a pact on orders from Dublin.
Reacting in a way even if its the only way to get some sense into them and justice for us is simply not in nationalists dna which encourages them even more.
You can’t beat them you join them.
What else just suck it up and hope the courts sort it out in ten years?
In the meantime nationalists controlled councils should show some solidarity and send them the money.
Its things like this I feel Sinn Fein have let go under the radar. It should be headlines for them until the money is released.
In the North Belfast where catholics make up half the population the FOUR leasuire centres are all located in loyalists parts, Shankill, Ballysillan, Grove Tigers Bay and Valley Rathcoole.
The mental image of Arlene Foster as a diminatrix……..that ones gonna haunt me.lol
*dominatrix
Sorry I spelt that wrong I was a little in shock lol
Maybe something subliminal, Scott, as diminatrix might be for one of the less educated variety!
Sherdy
I believe Arlene has a law degree.
Why do you persist in casual insult (and why is it always tolerated)?
You can’t equate an education with intelligence.
Like putting lipstick on a pig.
No pun intended giordanobruno.
Jim
Sherdy used the term “less educated”. It’s just more inaccurate (sadly all too frequent) nonsense intended to insult.
Now what pun did you make?
I agree wholeheartedly. We desperately need a party that will stand up for nationalists. SF and the SDLP are now just little puppies. We need a dog that bites. Is there any appetite for a new nationalist party here? Is there anyone who is interested in leading or setting it up?
“We need a dog that bites. Is there any appetite for a new nationalist party here? Is there anyone who is interested in leading or setting it up?”
We also need unity of purpose on the national question among the irish parties on this island and in particular within Dublin.
That is were reconciliation is needed the most, not with unionism who as we can clearly see have no interest in reconciliation or the principal of self determination.
John Major once accused John Hume and Charley Haughey of believing they could negotiate a united Ireland over the heads of unionism.
Well, that has never been more possible than it is today and less possible than it will be tomorrow, yet unionism are pulling the strings.
That is bad leadership.
What is also badly missing is a Taoiseach prepared to stand up for Irish citizens in the north and support from Dublin towards unity as well as cohesion among nationalist parties to do what is best for the Irish people.
It seems to me, all parties are looking out for themselves first.
Irish unity is not even on the radar at the moment
Screw everything else until it is I say
And can we honestly see this changing anytime soon? Not a chance! This is exactly what unionism is built on, the whole ethos requires it. Remember they are still a minority in Ireland and still hold the country to ransom, whether politically, socially or economically. They have given nothing to the island they live on.
Good synopsis Jessica of the Sinn Fein strategy. Clearly it’s not working, if they don’t change tact, there just evolving into a rougher version of the SDLP. I always voted Sinn Fein because we needed a tougher stronger party than the sdlp to put it up to unionism but if things continue as they are (god you can’t tune into the local news without the latest insult/barb or more importantly blocking a project in a nationalist area as you highlighted because of dup bigotry dressed up as some perceived insult or other).
I don’t mind martin laying a wreath at the Somme to the victims (which they were btw of that pointless slaughter of Irish men north and south) but did he get any thanks for it from any dup representative, I don’t think so. But it’s in government where Sinn Fein will have to confront dup bigotry, whether it’s with the Irish language act or investment in nationalist areas re jobs and infrastructure. Otherwise and I for one will stop voting for them or anyone.
“But it’s in government where Sinn Fein will have to confront dup bigotry, whether it’s with the Irish language act or investment in nationalist areas re jobs and infrastructure. Otherwise and I for one will stop voting for them or anyone”
They need to review reconciliation policy and include more focus on coming down on bigotry from any quarter hard, the Irish language act and investment in nationalist areas re jobs and infrastructure should be conditions for remaining in coalition with the DUP.
Let it collapse and go to another election, if the people see them doing something positive and standing tough, their votes will go up. I would vote for them again if they show they can deliver and deal with unionist intransigence strongly. There would be a nationalist first minister then.
“But why is reconciliation so one sided?”
Becaus, vis-a-vis the two sides SF and the DUP, only one side murdered and terrorised. SF have a lot further to travel to meet in the middle than does the DUP.
You ever heard of Ulster Resistance whom the DUP armed and the thousands of innocent people those weapons injured and killed?
“You ever heard of Ulster Resistance whom the DUP armed and the thousands of innocent people those weapons injured and killed?”
I’ve heard of them, but the DUP didn’t arm them.
Jude was worried about defamation earlier.
So the DUP set up a paramilitary organisation and allowed it to come under the control of loyalists without knowing they were no longer in charge? Hard to believe.
Theres a picture of Peter Robinson holding or testing a weapon before the arms shipment came from Israel that looks exactly like the weapons brought from Israel by UR after that visit. Getting kinda spooky.
Given the DUP history and association with loyalists does it not point to something more sinister in the making or is this just another coincidence?
Pull the wool from your eyes.
Even if I tried I dont think I could defame the DUP any more than they defamed with bullet and grenade the bodies of innocent men women and children using loyalist proxies to pull the trigger.
“So the DUP set up a paramilitary organisation and allowed it to come under the control of loyalists without knowing they were no longer in charge?”
Not to my knowledge. What was this?
“Theres a picture of Peter Robinson holding or testing a weapon before the arms shipment came from Israel that looks exactly like the weapons brought from Israel by UR after that visit. Getting kinda spooky.”
Holding a “testing weapon” on one occasion doesn’t equate to running a 27-year murder campaign that claimed the lives of over 1700 souls.
“Given the DUP history and association with loyalists does it not point to something more sinister in the making or is this just another coincidence?”
No it doesn’t. And again I would suggest that you are careful in the very serious accusations that you appear to be making. Remember what happened to Phil Flanagan (if that’s his name) from.Fermanagh.
“Holding a “testing weapon” on one occasion doesn’t equate to running a 27-year murder campaign that claimed the lives of over 1700 souls. ”
MT, you don’t give a damn about any one of the souls you refer to, you are simply using them as statistics to justify your bigotry.
“MT, you don’t give a damn about any one of the souls you refer to, you are simply using them as statistics to justify your bigotry.”
I do give a damn. I respect human life and support human rights: that is why, unlike you, I oppse terror.
I don’t have any bigotry, therefore it’s not possible for me to justify it. On the contrary, I’m opposed to bigotry: that is why I’m against murder and terror. You, on the other hand, supported murder and terror. I should say that suggests bigotry on your part.
“On the contrary, I’m opposed to bigotry: that is why I’m against murder and terror. ”
Lets just leave it there, I also am totally opposed to bigotry, murder and terror.
So let us just agree, that intolerance is wrong and all use of violence to get our way is totally wrong and will always be wrong.
Can we agree on that?
“But why is reconciliation so one sided?”
Becaus, vis-a-vis the two sides SF and the DUP, only one side murdered and terrorised. SF have a lot further to travel to meet in the middle than does the DUP.
============================================
MT that is a blantant lie.
From Willie McCrea holding hands with King Rat Billy Wright through to the Inspector Nixon RUC Bully boy through to “Ulster Resistance” the third force who gave their share of South Africa BOSS guns to other Unionist terror groups
Said guns were used in the murder of over 230 people
Over 229 of which ha no involvment in the IRA.
Through to Ian Paisleys “pals ” ( Noel Whelan ) in the UPV ( look them up ) who started it all off with bombing
electric and water cross boarder services.
You Sir L.I E.
Thank you for providing your Unionist Duality to violence for all to see.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Noel_Doherty
Edit.
Should be Noel Doherty.
“MT that is a blantant lie.”
It’s not. On the contrary, it’s true.
“From Willie McCrea holding hands with King Rat Billy Wright through to the Inspector Nixon RUC Bully boy through to “Ulster Resistance” the third force who gave their share of South Africa BOSS guns to other Unionist terror groups”
See above. (And Nixon was dead decades before the DUP even existed.)
“Said guns were used in the murder of over 230 people.”
Opposed by the DUP. While at the same time SF was supporting murders.
MT you should take a hard look at who the DUP have associated with, Billy Wright, various loyalist paramilitaries in particular during the UWC strike, and not to forget Ulster Resistance!
“MT you should take a hard look at who the DUP have associated with, Billy Wright, various loyalist paramilitaries in particular during the UWC strike, and not to forget Ulster Resistance!”
One member standing on a platform with Wright and others playing toy soldiers with red berets is not the equivalent of 1700 murders and years of terrorism.
“One member standing on a platform with Wright and others playing toy soldiers with red berets is not the equivalent of 1700 murders and years of terrorism…”
=============================
It hasn’t been one member though has it.
Read about the UPV and the link I posted about Noel Doherty.
How about the Unionist strike against Sunningdale.
Paisley worked with Unionist terrorists. That’s hardly “condemning” them is it.
Wrong C word.
It’s condoning it.
How about the banners “celebrating ” shankill Butchers that the DUP march under during their Orange Culture Fest.
As for condemning it.
The DUP speak out of both sides of their mouths.
And for someone like yourself who is a self proclaimed “moralist ” against “terror”
You don’t seem half bothered about the blood the DUP is steeped in.
“terrorists” in government???
I should say so.
Your High Moral tone is more like faux outrage.
You need to decommission that before you get taking serious.
“t hasn’t been one member though has it.
Read about the UPV and the link I posted about Noel Doherty. How about the Unionist strike against Sunningdale. Paisley worked with Unionist terrorists. That’s hardly “condemning” them is it.
Wrong C word. It’s condoning it.
How about the banners “celebrating ” shankill Butchers that the DUP march under during their Orange Culture Fest.As for condemning it.The DUP speak out of both sides of their mouths.”
Sitting on the UWC with loyalist terrorists and some guy in the 60s never supported by mainstream unionists and since disowned doesn’t equate to a 27-year terror campaign involving 1700 murders.
Not aware of “the DUP” or anyone elsemarching under Shankill Butchers banners. And even if they did it’s not equivalent to murdering people or planting bombs.
“Not aware of “the DUP” or anyone elsemarching under Shankill Butchers banners. And even if they did it’s not equivalent to murdering people or planting bombs.”
Lets just ignore that it was unionism who started killing people and who planted the first bombs in the 60s. Not a single person would have died if unionism hadn’t started it.
There is no justification for conflict or any killing, but unionism has yet to acknowledge these facts. Unionism started and committed all of the killing and bombing here between 1966 and 1969.
Do you need reminding of the DUP’S past sinister links with loyalist terrorist groups and specially one i.e. Ulster Resistance which they were foundational in forming during the 1980’s? The SF leaders to their credit have traveled a lot further in terms of peace-making and reconciliatory policies than the current unionist political leadership who would have us believe that they have nothing in the past or present to apologize for. But like the three proverbial monkeys, they remain dumb, blind and silent to their own inglorious and pernicious past in creating the conditions which in the first place gave rise to the 30 year long troubles .
“Do you need reminding of the DUP’S past sinister links with loyalist terrorist groups and specially one i.e. Ulster Resistance which they were foundational in forming during the 1980’s? The SF leaders to their credit have traveled a lot further in terms of peace-making and reconciliatory policies than the current unionist political leadership who would have us believe that they have nothing in the past or present to apologize for. But like the three proverbial monkeys, they remain dumb, blind and silent to their own inglorious and pernicious past in creating the conditions which in the first place gave rise to the 30 year long troubles .”
Ulster Resistance was toy soldiers and the DUP jumped ship as soon as it attempted to get serious. Ludicrous to attempt to equate it to a 27-year PIRA terror campaign.
And yes SF have of course travelled further: they have much further to travel.
“Ulster Resistance was toy soldiers and the DUP jumped ship as soon as it attempted to get serious”. Yeah, it got serious alright, as this group along with their fellow loyalist terrorists in the UVF and UDA benefited from a huge shipment of arms during the mid-eighties made financially possible by a major bank heist by the UVF in June 1987. The money was used to buy 206 Vz. 58 assault rifles, 94 Browning 9mm pistols, 4 RPG-7 rocket launchers and 62 warheads, 450 RGD-5 grenades and 30,000 rounds of ammunition which arrived at Belfast docks from Lebanon in December 1987. These weapons were responsible for the murders of hundreds of people, innocent Catholics in the main. The DUP claimed that they broke their connection with their creation in 1986 but this is just another unconvincing attempt by them to try to distance themselves from violent situations that they were instrumental in creating. Members of Paisley’s Free Presbyterian church were directly involved in terrorism e.g. Billy Mitchell was one of the founders of the reformed UVF during the mid-sixties and James King from Killyleagh, Co Down, was arrested with 2 other members of the Ulster Resistance along with a South African diplomat in a Paris hotel in 1989 during a mission to procure a major shipment of arms. Paisley helped form the Protestant Volunteer Force during the sixties and there were close associations between them and the UVF. The links are there for those who care to look. I’m not arguing that the DUP were involved in a constant stream of violence but they fomented the conditions that helped make it possible and indeed established close working relationships with loyalist terror groups during the various decades of the troubles. This can be said of the UUP So with a checkered history to say the least, the DUP are not in a position to lecture others regarding support or direct involvement in violence. At least the present day Sinn Fein leadership have made a quantum leap regarding seeking a peaceful resolution of our difficulties. I wonder can the same be said of the hypocrites in the DUP, TUV and the UUP(despite hopeful noises from Mike Nesbitt)?
“I’m not arguing that the DUP were involved in a constant stream of violence ”
Therefore you accept that SF has a much longer journey to make than the DUP.
Incidentally Jude is getting concerned about defamation so be careful in the allegations you’re making about the DUP and arms shipments etc.
“Incidentally Jude is getting concerned about defamation so be careful in the allegations you’re making about the DUP and arms shipments etc.”
Keep telling yourself that pompous ass. I doubt Jude is worried about being sued by DUP gunrunners.
No, peterp, but I don’t like abuse bereft of argument, no matter who it’s directed at. Please observe…
“Only one side murdered and terrorised” – I’m confident SF would disagree here – did they murder and terrorise?
“Only one side murdered and terrorised” – I’m confident SF would disagree here – did they murder and terrorise?”
The Provisional republican movement, of which it is the political representative, murdered nearly 2000 people and ran a terror campaign for 27 years. And, of course, many members of SF personally murdered and terrorised and its leaders were leading terrorists.
The British killed as many if not more or slightly less than the IRA. BOO HOO.
Unionists cheered on the British army from a safe distance as they murdered and ran amok in nationalist areas and were happy for loyalists to do the dirty work. Counter terrorists as Robinson called them. You understand what hes saying there? That loyalists were not the bad guys and arming counter terrorists well they’re COUNTER terrorists not actual terroists ya know.
“The British killed as many if not more or slightly less than the IRA. BOO HOO.”
No they didn’t.
“Unionists cheered on the British army from a safe distance as they murdered and ran amok in nationalist areas and were happy for loyalists to do the dirty work. Counter terrorists as Robinson called them. You understand what hes saying there? That loyalists were not the bad guys and arming counter terrorists well they’re COUNTER terrorists not actual terroists ya know.”
The DUP and UUP positions are opposed to murder and terrorism from.any source. SF still seeks to legitimise PIRA terror while saying terror by others waa wrong. That is why SF has the longer journey to make for reconciliation.
“The DUP and UUP positions are opposed to murder and terrorism from.any source. SF still seeks to legitimise PIRA terror while saying terror by others waa wrong. That is why SF has the longer journey to make for reconciliation.”
If Unionism really believes that, why are the DUP in coalition with Sinn Fein at all?
You are making really pathetic excuses for the bad behaviour still coming from unionism even though society has moved on. Only the aging unionist population could possibly spout such ridiculous statements. You are an endangered species MT, thank God.
I take it the reason other unionist voices are not backing you up is it would be too embarrassing to side with you.
“If Unionism really believes that, why are the DUP in coalition with Sinn Fein at all?”
Because the system of government requires it.
“You are making really pathetic excuses for the bad behaviour still coming from unionism even though society has moved on.”
I’m not making excuses, pathetic or otherwise, for bad behaviour. Unlike you, I’m against bad behaviour.
“Because the system of government requires it.”
That is also good, we should respect the will of the people and the choice of government the majority choose to represent us.
* “Protestant Volunteer Force” should have read “Ulster Protestant Volunteers”
Therein lies the problem MT, your comment says it all
“Therein lies the problem”.
Don’t ignore the elephant in the room. Don’t run away from the truth, Ciaran.
Jessica, I get what you are saying. But when Gerry Adams comes out with “The point is to actually break these bastards” and the “Trojan horse of the entire republican strategy” – I feel this only serves to undermine the strides the republican movement have made towards reconciliation – it provides unionism with a weapon to beat SF with – reconciliation must be genuine and made with good intentions (I have no doubt many of the gestures are). Reconciliation is a two way process and Unionists aren’t reciprocating at the same level as republicans – what’s the alternative? What if Unionists continue to fail to engage in reconciliation?
The past is a big sticking plaster for Unionism and until we get some mechanism in place to adequately deal with it, the future is in jeopardy – every day we are hearing about inquests of past events that continue to haunt our society – fresh start, will there ever be a fresh start? Is a fresh start even possible in the North with all the past hurt and suffering on both sides?
I thought it a positive move last week, Peter Weir, making a visit to an Irish language school, particularly after Gregory Campbell’s disrespect towards the language.
But then again, if all this “reaching out” is potentially having damning consequences on SF’s vote, why would Unionists reach out? To date, very little acts of reconciliation hasn’t really damaged the DUP vote!!!
“The two IRA members were killed in 1922 – some seven months before the signing of the Anglo-Irish Treaty.”
Both men were killed on 24th May 1922, some 5 months AFTER the signing of the Anglo-Irish Treaty (December1921). I’ve also noticed a few newspapers stated they were murdered during the War of Independence – this is factually incorrect as a truce occurred on 11th July 1921.
“But when Gerry Adams comes out with “The point is to actually break these bastards” and the “Trojan horse of the entire republican strategy” – I feel this only serves to undermine the strides the republican movement have made towards reconciliation – it provides unionism with a weapon to beat SF with – reconciliation must be genuine and made with good intentions (I have no doubt many of the gestures are). ”
Gerry Adams has always tried to keep grass roots on side. I think his biggest error here was believing it is possible to break the bigotry of unionism in the first place.
I so think you are right though, for Sinn Fein there is no going back.
They are committed to reconciliation and it would be madness for them to change tact now. They are now a mainstream party in the republic and will have a major role to play in rebuilding a new Ireland with new political parties to lead us. The days are numbered for many of the traditional parties in both parts of this island.
Gerry Adams should stand aside before he is forced out. Martin McGuinness is the most sincere politician on this island and I expect will be our next president in 2018.
But Stormont can go to hell for all I care. It should be turned in to a museum of bigotry and to represent the politics of failure.
“Reconciliation is a two way process and Unionists aren’t reciprocating at the same level as republicans – what’s the alternative? What if Unionists continue to fail to engage in reconciliation? ”
To keep saying there is no alternative is ridiculous. This is Ireland one of the most creative countries in the planet who’s people have done so much for other nations and yet so little for our own. I could throw out loads of suggestions off the top of y head. Are you saying we are incapable of coming up with an alternative?
The GFA provides an international commitment to allow the people of Ireland to self determination and to unite the island as they see fit does it not?
Unionism is a minority on this island and I believe already a minority in the north of there was something worth voting for. They already admit to relying on Catholics not all to be nationalist.
What is needed is a political revolution in Ireland. We have been left with the remnants of the shackles of British rule throughout this island and are still finding our way and failing miserably. It is time Ireland was reformed to become a suitable nation for all of the Irish people.
Lets start with water charges. Both Fine Gael and Fianna Fail have proven beyond a doubt they are taking the people for fools. Are we going to roll over and let them away with this? The people have made it clear they do not want water charges.
Likewise, Stormont has proven it is no more than a farce, more and more people will reject it. Let it go.
Lets start there. We need a new social charter drawn up to reform the current constitution of Ireland which represents every Irish citizen on this island.
If unionism dies not want to participate, it doesn’t have to. Many EU immigrants may not wish to get involved, unionists can choose not to if they wish.
The new charter should reform utility charges, health and education.
The state should control all schools. The catholic church should be given the opportunity to hand them over or over time be phased out and explain to the people why they refused should they do so.
The core of the new charter should be for a pluralist, liberal and progressive style of government but totally separate from any religious interference.
Ireland will not function as a left wing state but has suffered from right wing governments. The Irish people put an importance on hoe ownership that is not felt in most countries of the world, most probably due to our past relationships with land ownership or lack of it through periods of British rule.
Communism and far left policies will simply not work.
We need to look at new solutions, Irish solutions fit for purpose for the Irish people.
A new social-conservatism that will more fairly bridge the best of both left and right wing policies and applied with the rights of the people enshrined into the constitution to prevent unfair taxes and policies from hurting the people. This should also over rule anything out of the EU should the try to impose water charges for example.
Government should be devolved throughout the island whether through the existing provincial of county boundaries or new ones drawn up.
Wile Dublin should remain the capital and financial centre, each devolved parliament should control its own tax rates, and council policies operating within agreed budgets.
We should scrap the Westminster style of parliament and create a new means of government where there is no pathetic back chat between opposition and government leaders in a room full of twits. I would scrap the senate and have every government consisting of two councils. One with the larges party or coalition of parties runs the country and a second council where the leading opposition party or coalition are given the opportunity to scrutinise every law passed so both councils must be satisfied for it to get through, say 75% support over both councils needed.
No opposition needed and no upper house of wasted money.
“The past is a big sticking plaster for Unionism and until we get some mechanism in place to adequately deal with it, the future is in jeopardy – every day we are hearing about inquests of past events that continue to haunt our society – fresh start, will there ever be a fresh start? Is a fresh start even possible in the North with all the past hurt and suffering on both sides? ”
Only if a fresh start is for all of the Irish people and we are not selfishly looking inwards towards individual parts of the island separately.
I care nothing about a fresh start if it is self contained within 6 counties and promoting the tolerance of bigotry and aimed at disparaging the Irish identity of which I am proud off.
“I thought it a positive move last week, Peter Weir, making a visit to an Irish language school, particularly after Gregory Campbell’s disrespect towards the language.”
It is, it is a pity the media did not promote it as much and lead by example in focusing more on positive gestures than negative.
“But then again, if all this “reaching out” is potentially having damning consequences on SF’s vote, why would Unionists reach out? To date, very little acts of reconciliation hasn’t really damaged the DUP vote!!!”
Why indeed. Sinn Fein have committed to this strategy, it is their mess to deal with.
I do not however believe they should turn away from this path, they have made their bed and are now on a one way street, but they no longer represent my views which are no longer represented by any party here.
What I am saying is we need a new all island political party based on the mechanisms outlined in the GFA and focussed on building a new charter for an independent Ireland. It should stand in elections on both sides not to participate in Stormont but to profile for the new charter and new state.
I would also like to see other republican parties standing in councils, and where there is a nationalist control, to fly the Irish flag and promote the Irish language regardless what unionism thinks about it. There is nothing in this state that represents my identity that isn’t flying off a lamppost. That is second rate Irish, how can anyone claim otherwise?
“Both men were killed on 24th May 1922, some 5 months AFTER the signing of the Anglo-Irish Treaty (December1921). I’ve also noticed a few newspapers stated they were murdered during the War of Independence – this is factually incorrect as a truce occurred on 11th July 1921.”
I copied and pasted, thanks for correcting but makes no difference to me. I supported the IRA throughout the recent conflict. They were never the terrorists here in my eyes. It was the British army, RUC and loyalists who terrorised me throughout my younger years.
If unionism doesn’t like that, they can go to hell.
Everyone knows Ireland has had a troubled past, the relationship between Britain and Ireland has never been better. Unionists are preventing this developing for selfish reasons. It is time they were put in their place.
“What if Unionists continue to fail to engage in reconciliation?”
Then to hell with reconciliation with unionism or at least the part that is intransigent.
Let us focus on reconciliation with those who do wish to reciprocate and refuse to work with those that don’t.
Call the DUP to task on a number of issues including the Irish language, mutual respect and if they fail to live up to their responsibilities to the nationalist community, bring the fucking shithouse down for good.
The nationalist people will at least respect them for doing so.
If Sinn Fein were in government with Fine Gael and they treated them like chumps, would they allow the coalition to continue?
It isn’t bloody rocket science.
You do realise that the two men in question were murdered returning home after a planned raid on the middle glens area by unionists was called of but were unfortunate to run into an ambush set up by B Specials
jessica
I broadly agree that Unionists need to be more constructive in their dealings with nationalists.
But the use of the veto by petition of concern in the 2015-2016 session was only slightly weighted to unionism and the report by the BBC IN 2013 said there had been a total of 63 POCs up to that date with 37 being tabled by unionists,26 by nationalists.
This is far from the one sided obstructionism you describe.
“I broadly agree that Unionists need to be more constructive in their dealings with nationalists.”
I’m afraid the opportunity may have gone and passed for many including myself.
They can do whatever the hell they like for all I care, along with any other bigoted group throughout the planet.
They are no different, no better and no more relevant to me than any fascist group in any other nation.
And I was not complaining about the use of the veto, that is what it is for, It could used a million times justifiably.
The abuse is when you use it for sectarian reasons such as promoting the Irish identity in Ireland believe it or not.
You couldn’t make this stuff up. British partition of Ireland has left us with a hell of a mess, we may have an end of conflict, but this is still a shithole of a place thanks to the presence of unionism.
“This is far from the one sided obstructionism you describe.”
I doubt nationalists have been in a position to abuse the veto in such a sectarian nature but it is time we did.
Fight fire with fire is sometimes the only choice we are given.
Ah now, jessica, they don’t get it all their own way. Didn’t Tesco in Cookstown (An Corr Críochach) take the camping chairs with the offensive logos on them OFF the shelves.
Well written Jessica,
it would be interesting to hear Jude´s opinion on Jessica´s analysis. Sinn Fein seem to be losing support because of their passive reaction to Unionist dogmatic bluster. I can´t pretend to know why this is the case. Is there some long term strategy in their tactics? It would be nice to know what Nationalists think about this? Like every movement that has its occasional low points, Nationalist Ireland needs a little encouragement at the moment.
“it would be interesting to hear Jude´s opinion on Jessica´s analysis. Sinn Fein seem to be losing support because of their passive reaction to Unionist dogmatic bluster. I can´t pretend to know why this is the case. Is there some long term strategy in their tactics? It would be nice to know what Nationalists think about this? Like every movement that has its occasional low points, Nationalist Ireland needs a little encouragement at the moment.”
Sinn Feins tactics were right, they failed because the south did not support them, instead party politics took over and Irelands selfish nature did the rest, not least the southern media.
Ireland has always stood by and let other parts of the country fall, ignoring the problem until it lands on our doorstep. Seems we haven’t changed much.
The nationalist vote has gone down because most nationalists don’t see anything worth voting for, not because of support for UK rule.
DUP intransigence plays a part, but the biggest factor is people have given up on Irish unity.
Nearly everyone I ask says who is interested, meaning the south have no interest.
We are on our own and Sinn Fein are simply mimicking the people on the grounds feelings that we have no choice but to soak it up.
Until there is another strong voice prepared to speak for all of the Irish people on this island, things will remain as they are.
Sinn Fein are committed to the current strategy of reconciliation and that is all they can do now.
It is time Gerry Adams stood down and Dublin took the lead of the party to restore some hope there is still some interest in Irish unity from the south
I am a long time supporter of Gerry Adams who is one of my hero’s, but I am also a pragmatist.
https://eurofree3.wordpress.com/2016/05/19/checkmate-stormont-style/
Well explained Jessica,
One little reminder though Jessica, I don´t think working class folk in the South have thrown in the towel when it comes to supporting our fellow countrymen in the North of Ireland. Unfortunately, you are correct in your analysis of the comfortable classes in the South. Can we change that? It is very difficult when our establishment and media are controlled by get along Cassidy´s. I dare say a few of these upstanding gentlemen would love us all to be back in UK, licking their feudal masters behinds at every opportunity. A cold day in hell comes to mind when I think of that ridiculous scenario.
Bullykiller,
“One little reminder though Jessica, I don´t think working class folk in the South have thrown in the towel when it comes to supporting our fellow countrymen in the North of Ireland. ”
It is very reassuring to hear that BK.
You can be sure it will be up to the working classes to fight for every change needed and I mean throughout the island including those in working class loyalist areas of the north.
Those opposed to change towards a new Ireland you can be sure are doing ok financially with things the way they are and would prefer not to take the risk of pursuing changes that would benefit the greater number of people. It will be up to the rest of us to change things for them anyway.
The whole country will need to come together to achieve it though.
Perhaps water charges will provide the catalyst to wake enough people up.