‘ Irish rugby shows the path for Irish soccer to follow?’ by Sammy McNally

screen-shot-2016-11-21-at-14-48-15

Okay, so disappointingly, Ireland didn’t beat the All Blacks –  the world Champions – twice in a fortnight – but no one seriously believes we will have to wait  anything like 111 years again for another win.

Irish rugby stands as an outstanding  example, perhaps the best example, of all Ireland cooperation.  There are of course many other excellent examples, including  the GAA, the Orange Order and the main Churches and other sporting organisations – but rugby remains the best  example in terms of inclusivity and success.

By and large the Irish Rugby Football Union(IRFU) has diplomatically negotiated the complexities of managing a sporting country which contains 2 separate political  jurisdictions without stirring up political controversies and they have done that through prolonged periods of widespread politically inspired violence and widespread disturbances over symbols and identity.

Quite an achievement.

Arguably, the IRFU could improve the protocols on constitutional symbols further and although they have introduced a new constitutionally neutral anthem the Irish tricolour still flies and the Irish anthem is still played when the Irish President is present. Having gone most of the way on neutrality – why not finish the journey – and remove all symbols?

But notwithstanding that unfinished journey, rugby surely stands as an excellent template for other Northern and Southern sports organisations.  Ireland, have won 2 of the last three European 6 Nations Championships and the 4 Irish provinces are competing in the premier European competition – Wales, by contrast, have one region in the competition.  (Below province level Irish clubs play in the All Ireland club league). Three Irish provinces, Leinster, three times,  Munster (twice) and Ulster (once) have all won the European Cup since (1999).

As Irish rugby showed in the 2 games against the All Blacks they can compete against the best in the world and their successes at Provincial and National level surely offer a path which other Irish sports should consider following.

So why doesn’t Irish soccer look to emulate Irish rugby’s success?

Although, Dundalk supporters may understandably object,  given this season’s European progress and Linfield supporters are extremely proud of the club’s achievement  in getting to the quarter finals of the European Cup in 1996/7, the story of Irish club soccer has been abysmally poor and arguably embarrassing – and shows little signs of improvement.

Unlike in Rugby, where the majority of the best Irish players play in Ireland, the inclusion of Irish based footballers in either of Ireland’s teams is a cause for headlines in the Belfast Newsletter or the Irish Times.  Whereas Ulster’s Ravenhill and Munster’s Thomond Park  are regularly sold out, soccer club attendances North and South are very poor – whilst thousands of Irish fans travel to Britain every week to see ‘proper’ football because they can’t see it at home.

With both international Irish soccer  teams enjoying a measure of success in the European championships – and success is measured by both as simply getting there – the only trophy likely to be picked up, is one for the behaviour of their fans (as both sets of fans were awarded this year) rather than ever getting a sniff of the actual championship  trophy itself.

Of course, rugby supporters, by and large (with the notable exception perhaps of Limerick) , are drawn disproportionately from the Northern and Southern middle classes and therefore a much easier candidate for joint enterprise in terms of having a single team,  it’s success must nevertheless contrast so sharply with the performance of soccer to at least force the football authorities North and South to consider to emulate it?

Irish soccer authorities should surely look to drastically reduce the number of clubs (or introduce a new top tier) and develop an All Ireland league whilst simultaneously seeking   to join some form of European league (as happens in rugby’s Guinness Pro 12 league) with other countries who wish to promote their own league and keep their own players at home.

A single Irish team for the whole country, stripped of all constitutionally divisive symbols and playing internationals fairly shared between Belfast and Dublin would clearly enter international competitions with a greater chance of success and a single Irish club structure competing in a European competition would help bring to an end the divisive legacy of the disastrous decision of the football authorities in Dublin in the 1920s to break away and set up a separate organisation(the FAI)  to administer the sport.

Since the dawn of professionalism in rugby union(1995), Ireland has enjoyed unparalleled success at National and Provincial  level and although the journey for soccer may be more difficult and fraught surely those who love the sport must realise that sooner or later  the idea of  keeping the sport divided  between the 2 jurisdictions, on such a small island – must  be abandoned.

Soccer is just a sport after all and success, like in rugby, where there is one team for the country would reflect equally on both sides of the border without undermining either British or Irish identity.

So why not give it a go – after all – there really is not that much to lose?

71 Responses to ‘ Irish rugby shows the path for Irish soccer to follow?’ by Sammy McNally

  1. ANOTHER JUDE November 21, 2016 at 3:06 pm #

    George Best was in favour of an all Ireland team, but the good old boys at the IFA were dead set against it. Things would have been better had he had the likes of Giles and Brady alongside him at international level instead of the dross he had to put up with.

    • Willie D. November 21, 2016 at 4:03 pm #

      Not sure I would categorise players like Pat Jennings, Pat Rice, Sammy Nelson, Derek Dougan, Terry Neill, etc, as “dross.” But wasn’t the I.F.A., based in Belfast, the original governing body of an all-Ireland football team, before the F.A.I. decided to set up a rival body in Dublin (as the author states), so perhaps the blame for the fact that we have two governing bodies and teams on this island should be laid at their door. I don’t think there is any chance of an all-Ireland soccer team being established, unless political union is established, there are simply far too many men in blazers on both sides of the border with a vested interest in the status quo.

      • ANOTHER JUDE November 21, 2016 at 10:04 pm #

        Perhaps I was a little harsh there willie D, I should have said even better players than the ones not as good as the players you mentioned. Dougan organised an all Ireland team to play Brazil around about 1974 or so and Harry Cavan ensured he never turned out for the north again. I agree about the men in blazers. Too many would lose out.

  2. Twinbrook Lad November 21, 2016 at 3:32 pm #

    Is there a defense put forward by the IFA that they would lose their standing and position within the committee that sets the rules within FIFA for the global game? I understand they have a permanent position on said board. I think that’s a lame excuse however and used to hide behind what would be a marvellous gesture for both sides. My fear is that an ugly side of sectarianism might surface (Glasgow, anyone) but I for one would be all for it. Provided they are happy to come to The Brandywell!! No national Anthems? Yes please

    • Sammy McNally November 21, 2016 at 4:11 pm #

      Twinbrook Lad, I think the key thing would be the team equally reflecting both
      parts of the country without any symbols which would reference either. As you say “No national Anthems”.

      From a football point of view it would make sense for both teams and at club level but would have to be demonstrably fair in terms of implementation.

      In terms of the IFA losing their influence in FIFA – there is the constant fear for the IFA of being subsumed in a British team if FIFA decide to re-open that debate.

      • Twinbrook Lad November 21, 2016 at 4:33 pm #

        Thanks Sammy. Your first paragraph reflects the similar nature of your original blog to rugby in becoming a neutral environment so yes, I agree with that and rugby provides the model template that if the will were there could be emulated.
        Second paragraph, again I totally agree but I feel that over a number of years the Setanta Cup competition showed a level that both leagues were similar so I do not feel that there is a wide discrepancy between the leagues.
        Self interest has dogged the IFA which is why they never took part or encouraged their players to sign up for Team GB in the Olympics. A pity.

    • Sammy McNally November 21, 2016 at 4:53 pm #

      Twinbrook Lad, thanks for that in relation to club soccer – I was trying to say (perhaps unclearly ) that clubs are equally as bad on both sides of the border and after decades of getting nowhere a new approach is required..

  3. joe bloggs November 21, 2016 at 4:17 pm #

    How about a green shirt with a big celtic cross covered in Shamrocks….? Of course, the IFA already have that, and have been representing Irishmen from all communities on the football pitch since 1880. A great pity that the bigotry of others set up a rival organization.

    • Sammy McNally November 21, 2016 at 4:50 pm #

      joe bloggs,

      of course people can always find reason’sin history for particular actions – but it looks like a bad decision by Dublin to break away. And I agree the IFA have made many attempts to be inclusive but it is very difficult when running a Northern Ireland team to satisfy both ‘sides’ in the North.

      But whatever about the past – the way forward for club soccer and ‘national’ soccer surely should be to put aside considerations of identity and concentrate on having one good team.

      The Irish rugby team is made up of those who see themselves as British and Irish and reflects extremely well on both identities.

    • Sherdy November 21, 2016 at 5:24 pm #

      Joe, if the IFA have the British national anthem played at their matches, and if they have their annual British poppy day remembrance where Catholics/nationalists feel obliged to wear special pro-British garb, then they are not representing Irishmen of all communities!

    • Sherdy November 21, 2016 at 5:24 pm #

      Joe, if the IFA have the British national anthem played at their matches, and if they have their annual British poppy day remembrance where Catholics/nationalists feel obliged to wear special pro-British garb, then they are not representing Irishmen of all communities.

    • Ryan November 22, 2016 at 2:24 am #

      “A great pity that the bigotry of others set up a rival organization”

      Most would say it was the bigotry of others that drove them to set up another organisation….

  4. Jim Neeson November 21, 2016 at 4:46 pm #

    It should be noted(1) Best, Jennings,Rice and Dougan wre all for one Ireland team
    (2) Soccer is the only sport that has two teams.
    Perhaps MT or Billy could explain this phemonon!!!

    • MT November 21, 2016 at 10:36 pm #

      “It should be noted(1) Best, Jennings,Rice and Dougan wre all for one Ireland team
      (2) Soccer is the only sport that has two teams.
      Perhaps MT or Billy could explain this phemonon!!!”

      It’s not the only sport that doesn’t have an all-Ireland team, and it can be explained by the Southern clubs forming a breakaway association in 1921.

  5. Jim Neeson November 21, 2016 at 4:50 pm #

    Sorry for the spelling errors i.e were, phenomonon, Hope I have it right this time.
    It is just the illogic thinking of some fans that has confused me !!!

  6. Freddie Mallins November 21, 2016 at 6:16 pm #

    Sure in effect we already have an all Ireland team, with players from, Cork, Dublin, Antrim, Donegal, Derry, Waterford and Tipperary. Every corner of Ireland is represented. Maybe not ideal, but not bad.

  7. MT November 21, 2016 at 7:27 pm #

    I should have though cricket or hockey would be much better examples.of sports that have successfully kept together both parts of Ireland, respecting the symbols of both. Rugby as pointed out has a much more dubious history in that regard, relying on the unionist contingent keeping the head.down.

    Despite the achievement of beating the All.Blacks once in one hundred years, and in a friendly, ironically the success of the single Irish rugby team does not.compare favourably to the success of the separate football teams.

    Ireland and Italy are the only teams.of the ten countries that play rugby professionally never to have reached a World.Cup semi-final: quarter-finals being as far as they’ve ever gone.

    In contrast, both NI and ROI, in a sport played professionally at a high level by scores of countries, and thus in the face of much tougher competition, have both reached World Cup quarter-finals.

    • Sammy McNally November 21, 2016 at 7:42 pm #

      MT,

      You are being a tad ungenerous there – 5 European Cups and 3 championships in the last 10 years is pretty. Packed grounds and all the players staying at home – including 2 or 3 European Players of the year.

      In that period both Irish teams have been ranked in very lowly in the FIFA standings and have near empty club grounds and Northern Ireland losing players to the South and constantly having to defend its position on flags and emblems. I think the IFA have done a great job in an almost impossible position – with their best player McClean playing for the South and arguably the best Northern manager of all time managing the South.

      Why not have one team and ditch all the symbols and both identities benefit as in rugby.

      It is win -win rather than lose-lose or at least win-win more than currently.

      • MT November 21, 2016 at 8:05 pm #

        “You are being a tad ungenerous there – 5 European Cups and 3 championships in the last 10 years is pretty. Packed grounds and all the players staying at home – including 2 or 3 European Players of the year.”

        Not sure what provincial/club success has got to do with the international team?

        “In that period both Irish teams have been ranked in very lowly in the FIFA standings and have near empty club grounds and Northern Ireland losing players to the South and constantly having to defend its position on flags and emblems. I think the IFA have done a great job in an almost impossible position – with their best player McClean playing for the South and arguably the best Northern manager of all time managing the South.”

        Northern Ireland are doing very well without McClean or the other O’Neill.

        “Why not have one team and ditch all the symbols and both identities benefit as in rugby.”

        The obvious answer is because people don’t want one. Nearly 100 years of a NI team has forged its own tradition, heritage, mythology and identity.

        “It is win -win rather than lose-lose or at least win-win more than currently.”

        Not sure NI fans would view the loss of their team as win-win. If they did presumably they’d be lobbying for it.

        • Ryan November 22, 2016 at 2:17 am #

          “Northern Ireland are doing very well without McClean or the other O’Neill”

          Yes, 3 losses and 1 win at the Euros, a win against the weakest team in the entire tournament (Ukraine). NI could barely keep 30% possession against Germany at both the Euros and their WCQ match. On the other hand, ROI have beaten Germany and drawn against them at Home in Germany itself (Euro 16 Qualification).

          Is this as good as it gets for NI MT? Is this your version of “doing well”? reaching a major tournament once in 30 years?……BTW, McClean has scored 3 goals in 2 games for us, he hit the bar against Georgia too. Previous NI managers tried very hard to get him to switch to NI for a reason. Michael O’Neill is a decent manager but he doesn’t compare to Martin O’Neill, even he would admit that too. Indeed I think if the money is right Michael O’Neill will end up as Scotland Manager in the next year or two, especially if Scotland don’t improve and reach World Cup under Strachan.

          “The obvious answer is because people don’t want one. Nearly 100 years of a NI team has forged its own tradition, heritage, mythology and identity”

          Really? That’s just your opinion MT, that doesn’t mean its other peoples, you don’t speak for them. A survey showed 50% of Protestants would favour an All Ireland soccer team. So your assertion of “People don’t want one” is already proven wrong. I want an All Ireland soccer team and so do thousands of others. Sectarianism is not a tradition, its not heritage and its not an identity. Even Englishman Jack Charlton described Windsor Park’s atmosphere as “Toxic” when he went there as a manager. What do you mean by “mythology”? NI was never a soccer team of great legend, as I said it hasn’t reached a major tournament until Euro 2016. It was beaten 3-2 by Luxembourg, LUXEMBOURG, in 2013. Time to get real MT.

          “Not sure NI fans would view the loss of their team as win-win. If they did presumably they’d be lobbying for it”

          Its a national football team, NI fans aren’t the only ones who have a say. The NI football team is suppose to represent everyone here in the North, therefore everyone, not just NI fans, have a say.

  8. Sammy McNally November 21, 2016 at 8:13 pm #

    MT

    re. “Not sure what provincial/club success has got to do with the international team?”

    A good domestic league – perhaps to championship standard (currently League 1 or below) would allow many of the players to play in Ireland and a good club structure – based on an All Ireland league or ideally a Euro league (for tier 2 countries) would only be beneifical for the international team.

    • MT November 21, 2016 at 8:16 pm #

      “A good domestic league – perhaps to championship standard (currently League 1 or below) would allow many of the players to play in Ireland and a good club structure – based on an All Ireland league or ideally a Euro league (for tier 2 countries) would only be beneifical for the international team.”

      Wishful thinking. I’ll stop short of saying it’s a fantasy, but Ireland will never be able.to support a full-time professional league. The audience isn’t there for.it either in terms of paying spectators or television. Ironically there is more money coming into Irish football than ever via the Champions League and Europa League: money that would be halved at a stroke if there were a single league.

      • Sammy McNally November 21, 2016 at 8:25 pm #

        Thats a fair point about the money – i dont have the figures – I know Dundalk got a shedful of money this year.

        But a full time league if Ireland was linked to other countries who need to encourage a higher standard. There will be a big audience for good football and if ever there is a European Super League then Dublin in particular would be a contender.

        The money increases dramatically the further you go and iif Dundalk can almost qualify for the Group Stages then the chances of that happening regularly if they and other Irish teams competed in a proper (or better league) would increasde.

        It is a poor argument to keep playing in bad league simply because of short term advantage in money – all sports teams/leagues/organisations should seek to improve their standard and having 2 very poor leagues on 1 small island doesnt look like the way to go.

        • MT November 21, 2016 at 10:34 pm #

          “But a full time league if Ireland was linked to other countries who need to encourage a higher standard. There will be a big audience for good football and if ever there is a European Super League then Dublin in particular would be a contender.”

          If you’re suggesting a supranational league, then (a) it’s not going to happen, as it goes against the whole structure of football and (b) even if it did, it wouldn’t be dependent on an all-Ireland international team, nor make such a team necessary.

          • Ryan November 22, 2016 at 1:56 am #

            “If you’re suggesting a supranational league, then (a) it’s not going to happen, as it goes against the whole structure of football and (b) even if it did, it wouldn’t be dependent on an all-Ireland international team, nor make such a team necessary”

            MT has borrowed mystic Meg’s crystal ball again….

  9. Ryan November 22, 2016 at 1:46 am #

    According to a survey done last year around 50% of Protestants support an All Ireland soccer team. Of course its not simply up to Protestants whether there is an All Ireland team or not, Catholics in the North have just as much a say, especially given we’ll be the majority in just a few short years, if we aren’t already. Indeed all of Ireland, North and South, has a say.

    It is fair to claim that the vast majority of Catholics don’t support the NI football team but that doesn’t mean they don’t have a say on the national team that represents this jurisdiction. The NI team is suppose to represent everyone here, that’s the whole point of a national team but yet its failed utterly in getting the support of half the population and soon it will be supported only by a minority.

    Would an All Ireland soccer team help heal divisions here? Help give us a better chance at gaining success at soccer? I think it definitely would.

    If there was an All Ireland soccer team, that means all our talent, all our resources, all our coaching expertise, etc would be going into one team, instead of two. At the minute we’re dividing our resources, which is only damaging both teams, especially the NI soccer team. The NI soccer team, with due respect, is not only heavily dependent on Championship players but also League 1 players too. How can they possibly compete with the World’s finest players? To put it into context, one of Germany’s or Spain’s star players would be worth more in value than the entire NI soccer team, a lot more. I’m including NI’s reserves in that too, btw. You could maybe throw in Windsor Park as well.

    If we had an All Ireland team we would more likely qualify for major tournaments regularly. This means more money for the Irish football squad because every team that qualifies for a major tournament gets money from UEFA/FIFA and this money is usually re-directed into buying better facilities, better stadiums, better coaches, etc and hence a better soccer team. Both the ROI and NI teams got 10 million euros each for just getting to Euro 2016 (as did all teams that got there) and for every match won/drawn the teams got extra cash, £500,000 for a draw I believe. For example the winning team of World Cup 2018 will receive nearly £50 million prize money. Portugal received £25 million for winning Euro 16.

    The reality is money matters when it comes to sport, of course it does. But both Irish teams squander it by having two different teams and set ups. That money could be directed into training the next generation of Roy Keanes, George Bests, Robbie Keanes, etc. If we do have one Irish soccer team then success at tournaments/games will be much more likely than it is at present. The Irish Rugby Squad proves this will be the case when we work together. Ireland was 2nd in the World Rugby Rankings during the World Cup. Not bad for a nation of Gaelic footballers and soccer supporters…..indeed, if soccer was followed in Ireland just as passionately as New Zealanders follow Rugby then I think Ireland would’ve won the World Cup a long time ago.

    PS: Even Enda Kenny thinks having one Irish soccer team is a good idea, he suggested a yearly charity match between an All Ireland team and England. He might be on to something…..

    • MT November 22, 2016 at 7:19 am #

      “Of course its not simply up to Protestants whether there is an All Ireland team or not, Catholics in the North have just as much a say, especially given we’ll be the majority in just a few short years, if we aren’t already. Indeed all of Ireland, North and South, has a say.”

      It’s not up to ‘Protestants’ or “Catholics’, but the members of the IFA and FAI, who would have to dissolve themselves, and to FIFA, who would have to change their constitution..

      “Would an All Ireland soccer team help heal divisions here? Help give us a better chance at gaining success at soccer? I think it definitely would.”

      “Would an All British Isles soccer team help heal divisions here? Help give us a better chance at gaining success at soccer? I think it definitely would.”

      “If there was an All Ireland soccer team, that means all our talent, all our resources, all our coaching expertise, etc would be going into one team, instead of two. At the minute we’re dividing our resources, which is only damaging both teams, especially the NI soccer team. The NI soccer team, with due respect, is not only heavily dependent on Championship players but also League 1 players too. How can they possibly compete with the World’s finest players? To put it into context, one of Germany’s or Spain’s star players would be worth more in value than the entire NI soccer team, a lot more. I’m including NI’s reserves in that too, btw. You could maybe throw in Windsor Park as well.”

      “If there was an All Ireland soccer team, that means all our talent, all our resources, all our coaching expertise, etc would be going into one team, instead of two. At the minute we’re dividing our resources, which is only damaging both teams, especially the NI soccer team. The NI soccer team, with due respect, is not only heavily dependent on Championship players but also League 1 players too. How can they possibly compete with the World’s finest players? To put it into context, one of Germany’s or Spain’s star players would be worth more in value than the entire NI soccer team, a lot more. I’m including NI’s reserves in that too, btw. You could maybe throw in Windsor Park as well.”

      If we had an All British Isles team we would not only more likely qualify for major tournaments regularly, but reach semi-finals and finals . This means more money for the British Isles football squad because every team that qualifies for a major tournament gets money from UEFA/FIFA and this money is usually re-directed into buying better facilities, better stadiums, better coaches, etc and hence a better soccer team. The England, Sscotland, ROI and NI teams got 10 million euros each for just getting to Euro 2016 (as did all teams that got there) and for every match won/drawn the teams got extra cash, £500,000 for a draw I believe. For example the winning team of World Cup 2018 will receive nearly £50 million prize money. Portugal received £25 million for winning Euro 16.

      “The reality is money matters when it comes to sport, of course it does. But both Irish teams squander it by having two different teams and set ups. That money could be directed into training the next generation of Roy Keanes, George Bests, Robbie Keanes, etc. If we do have one Irish soccer team then success at tournaments/games will be much more likely than it is at present. The Irish Rugby Squad proves this will be the case when we work together. Ireland was 2nd in the World Rugby Rankings during the World Cup. Not bad for a nation of Gaelic footballers and soccer supporters…..indeed, if soccer was followed in Ireland just as passionately as New Zealanders follow Rugby then I think Ireland would’ve won the World Cup a long time ago.”

      The reality is money matters when it comes to sport, of course it does. But five British Isles teams squander it by having five different teams and set ups. That money could be directed into training the next generation of Gareth Bales, Wayne Rooneys, Kenny Dalglishes , Roy Keanes, George Bests, Robbie Keanes, etc. If we do have one British Isles soccer team then success at tournaments/games will be much more likely than it is at present. The British and Irish Lions Rugby Squad proves this will be the case when we work together. The Lions are a match for any international rugby team. Not bad for nations of soccer supporters, rugby league and Gaelic players…..indeed, if soccer was followed in the British Isles just as passionately as New Zealanders follow Rugby then I think an all British Isles team would’ve won the World Cup a long time ago.

  10. Sammy McNally November 22, 2016 at 9:40 am #

    MT,

    National football teams by and large represent individual states and in the British Isles thee are 2 states. At some point, much feared by NI and Scotland and Wales that may be the way of things.

    Currently the South gets a fair smattering of Norther players and that shows no signs of abating and if Northern Ireland were to be integrated into either of these states in football terms then all but the most die hard Unionists would probably throw their lot in with the South.

    Although a British Isles team would undoubtedly do very well – that is not something that FIFA would allow and is not something there is any support for.

    The point about an All Ireland team is that bigger would probably mean better and unlike your (tongue in cheek) suggestion is largely practical and has potentially a large amount of support.

    • MT November 22, 2016 at 1:12 pm #

      “National football teams by and large represent individual states”

      Indeed. And there is no individual all-Ireland state.

      “Although a British Isles team would undoubtedly do very well – that is not something that FIFA would allow and is not something there is any support for.”

      By the same reasoning they wouldn’t allow an all-Ireland team either.

      “The point about an All Ireland team is that bigger would probably mean better and unlike your (tongue in cheek) suggestion is largely practical and has potentially a large amount of support.”

      It’s not practical, given it’s against FIFA rules.

      • Sammy McNally November 22, 2016 at 1:21 pm #

        MT,

        Thats a faIr point about FIFA not allowing it – but I’m not sure that would be the case. It would probably suit them to have one less association – and provided there was support from both sides – unlike with your British Isles suggestion – then given that Norther Ireland doesnt fit the State to Country ‘rule’ anyway – it might well be acceptable.

        Wondering if there is a precedent or near-precedent or if any statements have been issued by FIFA on the subject?

        • MT November 22, 2016 at 1:24 pm #

          No precedent or near precedent. Plenty of precedents for existing members to be divided up, though.

  11. Sammy McNally November 22, 2016 at 9:43 am #

    Ryan,

    wondering what your view is on the dropping of constitutional symbols if there was an All Ireland team and whether you think there would be opposition to no such symbols from southern fans?

    I suspect there would be quite a bit?

  12. Ruaidri Ua Conchobair November 22, 2016 at 11:47 am #

    Sammy,
    What are the rules of this sports reconciliation process – why not write to the main Unionist political parties the majority of Unionists elect to speak for them to ascertain their position on this issue?

    It seems to me – given what occurs in relation to the IRELAND/Irish nation’s Rugby team, todate the British Unionist perspective is: a) change what’s Irish in Ireland but b) respect what’s British in Ireland?

    British Unionists constitute approximately 12% of the island of Ireland population yet they seek the representative influence of 50% – surely you must realise this is unreasonable and unacceptable?

    Until new reconciliation rules are clear and agreed, I say that when the British Unionist minority volunteer to join any all-Ireland Irish nation team (Rugby, Soccer or otherwise) they should do what’s expected of we of the Irish nation who opt to join a team within the N Ireland statelet region i.e respect what’s Irish in Ireland or go join a British team in Britain and learn how unwelcome they are over there…

    To reiterate, if change is to occur we must first agree the rules. Then, we must consistently and fairly apply them. I’m willing to consider accommodation not facilitate ongoing British supremacism and anti-Irish bigotry. Alas, todate I detect only a Unionist willingness to maintain their Colonialist supremacist mindset and hatred of all things Irish in Ireland…

  13. Sammy McNally November 22, 2016 at 1:10 pm #

    Ruaidri,

    With appropriate respect to yourself, who has held the highest office in the land, albeit some time back, and at a time when the country was not divided on sporting or other issues – I think that a position of equality and generosity should be adopted which affords equal respect to both jurisdictions – for 2 main reason.

    Firstly, that it would offer an excellent example to others of how to conduct such matters (and not just in sport)- not in terms of numbers or percentages but rather illustrating that those who are in a position of strength should respect those who are in a minority and a minority with very strong and legitimate views (irrespective of the presence of bigots within their ranks).

    Secondly, we don’t have a great record on either side of the border – admittedly in different ways and to varying degrees – of being generous and in my opinion when opportunities present themselves to change that we should eagerly grab them.

    • Ruaidri Ua Conchobair November 22, 2016 at 2:28 pm #

      Sammy,
      I repeat, what are the rules proposed by the British Unionist community. Are they; a) respect each others identity b) remove from all public/shared events all political and/or cultural symbols the ‘other side’ don’t like?

      Maybe, you’re advocating a c) give parity to every minority group who reach a 10-12% ratio of the state’s.nation’s population – if this is what you mean then pray tell me that you are aware that within a decade the Polish ethnicity will be 10% of the population within the NI colony statelet territory?

      Also, when you contend ‘equality’ and ‘generosity’ be applied across both ‘jurisdictions’ are you seriously suggesting such be applied across the whole of the UK and the whole of the RoI or just be confined to within the contested NI colony statelet territory?

      Let’s agree the rules of the game, before we start trying to play the game…

      • MT November 22, 2016 at 6:02 pm #

        ” if this is what you mean then pray tell me that you are aware that within a decade the Polish ethnicity will be 10% of the population within the NI colony statelet territory?”

        What is the evidence for this far-fetched claim?

      • MT November 22, 2016 at 6:03 pm #

        “Also, when you contend ‘equality’ and ‘generosity’ be applied across both ‘jurisdictions’ are you seriously suggesting such be applied across the whole of the UK and the whole of the RoI or just be confined to within the contested NI colony statelet territory?”

        Didn’t you read the blog? He’s talking about an all-Ireland football team.

  14. Sammy McNally November 22, 2016 at 3:35 pm #

    Ruaidri,

    I dont think we need to consider “what are the rules proposed by the British Unionist community”

    This is an opportunity to lead by example and to do so from a position of strength for the South. You ask a simple question – what is the fairest way to represent both identities if there was a single football team? The answer is no political constitutional symbols (which rugby has largely achieved) and shared fixtures in both jurisdictions.

    Whether some Unionists want to fly the Union flag 365 days a year on every civic building in the North or not is irrelevant – as is whether the % of Poles in the country (unless they start demanding a homeland).

    The rules are that a unilateral stand is taken to be inclusive and non controversial on this issue and stick to that irrespective of any carryon by themmuns.

  15. Ruaidri Ua Conchobair November 22, 2016 at 5:48 pm #

    Sammy,

    The symbols of the Irish nation are things to be cherished, not despised… enough is enough!!!

    I don’t believe the average decent Protestant in the North are unsettled by Irish symbols as is sometimes suggested by the loudest voices of the DUP and UUP et al.

    The vast majority of our 32 county Irish nation will rightly not tolerate the pointless erosion of our nation’s cherished symbols to suit a cohort of hate-fuelled and intransigent British Colonialist supremacist bigots. If truth be told, the majority of the Irish in Ireland and the majority of British nation in Britain wouldn’t miss this NI colony Unionist cabal if tomorrow they disappeared off the face of the earth… let them stew in their self-destructive hate.

    When the impending demographic shift occurs, the British Colonialist supremacist element will get neither greater nor lesser citizenship rights and entitlements as our other ethnic communities. Stop pointlessly trying to appease them, just wait!!! Tick, tock!!!

    Stockholm syndrome is a terrible affliction some Irish people need to relieve themselves of, and instead take pride in and cherish what’s Irish in Ireland.

    P.s. Do read: The Unionist community values & identity dilemma – rational analysis terrifies them http://belfast-child.blogspot.co.uk/2016/09/NI-Unionists-Values-Identity-Dilemma.html

    • MT November 22, 2016 at 6:06 pm #

      “The vast majority of our 32 county Irish nation will rightly not tolerate the pointless erosion of our nation’s cherished symbols to suit a cohort of hate-fuelled and intransigent British Colonialist supremacist bigots.”

      ‘Nations’ don’t have counties.

  16. Sammy McNally November 22, 2016 at 6:03 pm #

    Ruaidri,

    I totally disagree – there are 2 legitimate traditions on this island – we have an international treaty in the shape of the GFA that gives the assent of the people of Ireland.

    I’m not sure where you get the ‘despise symbols from? Symbols are just what they say on the tin – and should be used when appropriate.

    It is nothing more than good political manners to respect those who hold a different perspective whether they are or are not sitting on a demographically slim majority (in the North).

    Anyone Unionist or Nationalist could share in the Irish victory over the All Blacks without needing to reference political identity and the same could perhaps happen in football – if both ‘sides’ gave up on the unimportant stuff (ie political symbols) and concentrated on the important stuff i.e. and Irish team (North and South) playing well.

    As for Stockholm syndrome, I’m not sure if that is aimed at me but for the purposes of this debate I see no merit in discussing political ideology when the topic is practical cooperation without it.

  17. Sammy McNally November 22, 2016 at 6:23 pm #

    Ruaidri,

    “cohort of hate-fuelled and intransigent British Colonialist supremacist bigots.””

    I presume you are not suggesting that the preference by Unionists not to see a tricolour is any different from our (ie Nats) desire not to see a Union flag when we are supporting out team?

  18. Am Ghobsmacht November 22, 2016 at 7:18 pm #

    Let’s loosen the masks shall we;

    “A single Irish team for the whole country, stripped of all constitutionally divisive symbols and playing internationals fairly shared between Belfast and Dublin ”

    Do nationalists on here accept that this means either NO tricolour as the sole flag or a tricolour AND a northern flag to represent BOTH Irelands (ditto the Soldier’s Song)?

    Come on, lets have ya…

  19. Ruaidri Ua Conchobair November 22, 2016 at 7:38 pm #

    Sammy,
    01: Do you accept, the entity known as Northern Ireland is what’s in contention?

    02: Do you accept, the jurisdictions known as the Republic of Ireland and Great Britain are not in contention?

    03: Do you accept, what constitutes the ‘British nation’ is not in contention?

    04: Do you accept, what constitutes the ‘Irish nation’ is not in contention?

    05: Do you accept, the GFA protects both British and Irish identity and doesn’t make any reference to the relatively new British colonial ‘Northern Irish’ hybrid identity?

    If British Unionists/Colonialists wish to partake in the IRISH nation’s native cultural activities (Gaelic games etc) and/or our other social pastimes (Chinese Soccer and American Hockey etc), they’re most welcome. However, they are not entitled to demand we hide the symbols of our nationhood.

    The IRISH NATION is just that; it’s Irish!!!

    The IRISH nation is not some colonial hybrid British-Irish ethnicity, and British Unionists must learn to respect this fact over and above their personal feelings of identity. The IRISH nation is a unique nation in its own right and – like all other nations, we Irish have an ancient and varied line of ancestry. As the Unionist Commenter Alex Kane suggested, Unionists seem to be suffering from a multiple personality disorder that they need to resolve within themselves.

  20. Sammy McNally November 22, 2016 at 9:22 pm #

    Ruaidri,

    My political views which are probably very similar to yours are irrelevant – there are 2 states on this island both are legitimate and there are two teams and I think we only need 1 team to cover both. We cant have symbols that satisfy everyone so we have none or newly agreed ones.

    Rugby makes a fairly goods stab (not good enough) in my opinion at being neutral and that is a good template. Bigotry either Nationalist or Unionist should be ignored and try and get a consensus on improving football free of any symbols – not because symbols are not important( I personally love the Irish flag) – but because they are inappropriate in this context of 2 jurisdictions and identities.

    It is a bit ludicrous to suggest that because a flag (tricolour)which was designed to bring people together cant be flown – that people (North and South) then should not come together. Thats the symbolic tail wagging the sporting dog.

    • MT November 22, 2016 at 9:27 pm #

      “there are 2 states on this island both are legitimate and there are two teams and I think we only need 1 team to cover both.”

      And why do you think that? It wouldn’t be because you are a nationalist?

    • Ruaidri Ua Conchobair November 22, 2016 at 9:51 pm #

      Sammy,
      I believe, there are more reasonable and moderate a-political Protestants than is often suggested by the DUP and UUP et al I’m willing to listen to them. That said, the loud-mouthed intransigent supremacist bigot cohort only start shouting about this topic when mention is made of making changes at the contested Aviva stadium which is supposed to represent all who inhabit the NI colony statelet.

      The majority in the South will understandably contend, let the anti-Irish British supremacist cohort fester in their soul-destroying hatred and bigotry… the END!!!

  21. Sammy McNally November 22, 2016 at 9:30 pm #

    MT, as per the main post – it works for rugby.

  22. MT November 22, 2016 at 9:32 pm #

    “MT, as per the main post – it works for rugby.”

    Two teams work for football.

  23. Sammy McNally November 22, 2016 at 9:35 pm #

    MT,

    Leaving aside the national teams – do you not think a slimmer better All Ireland club league would be worth exploring?

    • MT November 22, 2016 at 9:40 pm #

      “Leaving aside the national teams – do you not think a slimmer better All Ireland club league would be worth exploring?”

      It has been explored recently and did not proceed on economic grounds. Even if clubs had felt it would work economically there would yet have been further legal and jurisdictional obstacles and the issue of European places to surmount.

      I was opposed as the effect on those clubs excluded would be damaging.

  24. Sammy McNally November 22, 2016 at 9:46 pm #

    MT, fair enough. Have you any links to that?

  25. Nuacht November 23, 2016 at 12:40 am #

    And another interesting link

    http://www.the42.ie/will-we-ever-see-all-ireland-soccer-team-cormac-moore-2333851-Sep2015/

  26. Sammy McNally November 23, 2016 at 9:42 am #

    Thanks Nuacht

  27. Nuacht November 23, 2016 at 1:59 pm #

    I thought that the Setanta Cup was a great idea, and it did seem that it was popular with most teams and fans. The southern media also seemed to be enthusiastic about the competition. However, it does require commitment from both leagues and the participating teams. If one of the leagues or any of the assigned clubs are not willing to participate then its not going to work.

    It was a bit disappointing to see that certain northern clubs lost interest and didn’t want to continue after the 2014 competition. Linfield apparently cited scheduling difficulties. Its therefore surprising that Linfield are able to find the time to take part in the Scottish Challenge Cup.

    http://www.goal.com/en-ie/news/3942/ireland/2016/09/07/27277122/linfield-crusaders-compete-in-scottish-challenge-cup

    • MT November 23, 2016 at 6:56 pm #

      “It was a bit disappointing to see that certain northern clubs lost interest and didn’t want to continue after the 2014 competition. Linfield apparently cited scheduling difficulties. Its therefore surprising that Linfield are able to find the time to take part in the Scottish Challenge Cup.”

      Not surprising at all given the Scottish season coincides with the NI season. The scheduling problems with the Setanta Cup were causes by the different seasons played by the two leagues. The last aborted competition waa proposes for May and June, which is the break period for Irish League clubs between the end of the season and the start of pre-season training.

      The other factor worth mentioning is prize money. The level of enthusiasm is directly proportionate to the amount of prize money and TV money. As this declined sharply in latter seasons so toon did the priority given to it by NI clubs, who chose instead to prioritise domestic League and Cup matches.

      The Scottish Challenge Cup offers decent prize money and TV money.

      • Sammy McNally November 23, 2016 at 8:04 pm #

        MT,

        Cross border club competitions has got to be the way to go – whether it is Ireland to Britain or Ireland North to Ireland Ireland South in order to drag up the level of the leagues.

        Two proper Irish teams to play the 4 top Scottish teams and perhaps 6 teams from Scandinavia would be the basis for a reasonable competition.

      • Nuacht November 23, 2016 at 8:21 pm #

        I’m sure that a revised schedule to suit both leagues could have been arrived at, if there was a desire to find that accommodation. Shifting it back a month or two would fit in with preparation for the preliminary Europa and Champions League games.

        The level of prize money (whatever it was) didn’t deter the LOI teams from participating. Are you saying that Irish leagues clubs have heavier financial requirements that LOI clubs ?

        • MT November 23, 2016 at 8:58 pm #

          “I’m sure that a revised schedule to suit both leagues could have been arrived at, if there was a desire to find that accommodation. Shifting it back a month or two would fit in with preparation for the preliminary Europa and Champions League games.”

          It would then clash with European fixtures.

          “The level of prize money (whatever it was) didn’t deter the LOI teams from participating. Are you saying that Irish leagues clubs have heavier financial requirements that LOI clubs ?”

          Because it didn’t clash with the ‘business end’ of the LOI season. The timing coincided with pre- and early season for LOI but the end of the IL season.

          • Nuacht November 23, 2016 at 9:59 pm #

            It wouldn’t have to clash with actual European fixtures if it occurred before those games commenced, i.e. during preparation time. Anyway, its just another excuse found to opt out…

            didn’t clash with business end of the season…. more feeble excuses. Where else would you hear such nonsense

          • MT November 23, 2016 at 11:30 pm #

            “It wouldn’t have to clash with actual European fixtures if it occurred before those games commenced, i.e. during preparation time. Anyway, its just another excuse found to opt out…”

            But that is the only break in the year for IL.clubs. I already explained that.

            “didn’t clash with business end of the season…. more feeble excuses. Where else would you hear such nonsense”

            February-April is the business end of the IL season. Not sure how you can deny that.

            You seem to be suggesting some kind of conspiracy. If you don’t believe the reasons given for IL.clubs losing interest, what reason to you give?

          • Nuacht November 24, 2016 at 12:33 am #

            No need to get off on conspiracy theories. Losing interest covers it all

          • MT November 24, 2016 at 12:39 am #

            “No need to get off on conspiracy theories. Losing interest covers it all”

            It doesn’t, given that we were discussing why they lost interest.

  28. Sammy McNally November 23, 2016 at 2:12 pm #

    Nuacht,

    I think any Irish team North or South who had a chance of joining the Scottish or English league in any capacity would go for it.

    Scotland and Ireland and perhaps some Scandinavian countries would be candidates for some type of multi country league or cup.

    The Scottish league is in danger of getting to the same standard as the Irish league the way they are heading.

    • Nuacht November 23, 2016 at 8:27 pm #

      Sammy,
      Yes I agree that any opportunity to participate in external competitions should be taken. That’s why I think that it was a shame that the northern clubs lost interest in the Setanta Cup. There was a financial incentive with Setanta and it was competitive, although it seemed that the southern clubs were more successful than the northern clubs (only two northern clubs won the competition between 2005-2014). I can’t imagine that the poor record had a negative impact on the northern clubs attitude/confidence because the Scottish Challenge Cup would probably be a bigger challenge for them.

      I believe that an all-Ireland league would raise the standard to at least the level of the Scottish Premiership. Teams like the current Dundalk side would have no fear of going to Parkhead or Ibrox. They have scored in all their away Europa games this season and were very unlucky to be beaten by former UEFA Cup winners Zenit St Petersburg. The Zenit manager said that Dundalk were the best opposition they had met.

      The rest of the LOI teams will have to raise their game if they want to overtake Dundalk and Cork City. In an all-Ireland league with professional teams there would be more cash available, which would attract imports from England, Scotland and beyond, and inevitably raise the standard.

      The Limerick FC chairman had a very novel idea a couple of years ago. He wanted to attract good players from Greece by offering them a better way of life than what they have been enduring since the economic crisis. Unfortunately, Limerick were relegated and circumstances changed. Would those Greek players not be a good addition to any team competing in an all-Ireland league ?

      Johnny Giles left his job as manager of West Brom in 1977 to become manager of Shamrock Rovers. His intention was to bring them to a level where they could compete better in Europe, and at the same time offer good local talent the opportunity to play at a good level without having to leave Ireland. He didn’t succeed, mainly because he couldn’t get the other clubs to embrace his ideas. Times and attitudes have changed since then but Rovers came close to that standard for a very short time in 2011 when they qualified for the Europa group stage. That was during Michael O’Neill’s reign as manager (and Jim Magilton as assistant manager). Those two guys had no problem managing Rovers and there are plenty of players coming in both directions so I can’t see why playing regularly against the top teams from anywhere in Ireland should be an insurmountable problem.

      Dundalk has taken the Rovers achievement further with their Europa performances so now the bar is set higher. What was particularly pleasing to see was that there were lots of supporters from other LOI clubs cheering on Dundalk in their home games. That’s how it should be, forget the local rivalries and support your league for international games, regardless of which Irish team is involved. Another surprising thing was the level of interest in the Dundalk games. I went to Tallaght Stadium (without advance purchase of ticket) to watch the game against Maccabi Tel-Aviv and I couldn’t get in. It was a sell out !

      With an all-Ireland league it could become a routine expectation for our teams to be in the Europa or Champions League group stage. A lot of people were negative about Johnny Giles vision at the time but we now know that it is possible to raise the standards.

      Talking and moaning about poor standards and low attendances will not help to improve football in Ireland. Rugby and GAA people didn’t do that. Instead, they took hold of it and made it successful by reaching out and including all of Ireland. Obviously there are negative people in both codes but thankfully they haven’t been allowed to spoil it for the rest of us. So if you want to be negative about uniting the two soccer leagues then go ahead and moan away to yourself about all the reasons why things can’t or won’t happen. Most of us will be hoping, and I expect, that reconciliation and meaningful cooperation will prevail. The moaners will eventually be left behind with their NEVER, NEVER, NEVER mentality.

      Getting back to Rugby, we all know that current arrangements are not perfect and that there will always be some people who feel aggrieved, left out or just like to have something to complain about regarding bias against their local players, teams or venues. The IRFU clearly want to spread the game around the country but when it comes to international games then playing those big games in the stadium with the largest capacity is the obvious thing to do, i.e. Lansdowne Rd/Aviva Stadium. Despite that being so obvious I have heard it said on this site that the IRFU were bias against Ulster by not playing internationals in Belfast. Perhaps some rugby mad people from Cork and Galway might have similar views but I have never heard that mentioned, unsurprisingly.

      Limerick has a good stadium in Thomond Park but it’s not big enough to host the big international games. As far as I know, most recent international games played in Thomond were against Canada, Italy and Romania.

      Also, I don’t think that the Irish rugby captain would agree with the supposed negative bias against Ulster players.

      The 2023 World Cup bid is a great opportunity to help allay some of those prejudices. Having two grounds available in Ulster is a very positive move, thanks in part to the GAA. Apart from Croke Park the GAA have also made grounds available in Cork, Galway and Kerry. That’s what we call cooperation !!! Imagine if the GAA had decided to take a negative attitude to the World Cup bid ??? We might even be having anti GAA commentary on this site.

  29. Sammy McNally November 24, 2016 at 2:16 pm #

    Nuacht,

    lot of interesting points there.

    Dundalks performance has been very surprising. Unfortunately they have contractual problems with their ground and ground improvement is therefore stalled.

    Historically as you outline there have been blips of success and Dundalk may yet prove to be one of them but currently you might expect them to survive in the scottish premier league.

    But the structures just dont suggest that any success is sustainable and as you say for whatever the reason its a shame that the Setanta didnt work.

    In relation to rugby there was perhaps a justifiable issue for Unionists that the anthems protocol was not observed when a match was played in Belfast.