‘The SDLP & GARC: A Political Marriage or Electoral Divorce?’ by Eugene Meenan

Anyone who followed with any attention the happenings surrounding the parading deal in Ardoyne not so long ago will recall one of the most obscure yet fascinating sights in North Belfast’s recent times – what appears to be a rather cosy relationship between the SDLP in the North of the city and leading members of the Greater Ardoyne Resident’s Collective.

It wasn’t of course that surprising, because a leading SDLP Councillor is the brother of the individual who made death threats against a  local journalist during the whole fiasco. But given the antics of Dee Fennell towards Fr. Donegan, and especially given the extra cosy relationship the SDLP has always courted with the Catholic Church, it was a bit of a ‘pig in a poke’. A political intrigue waiting to happen. We are living in strange times when the polite “bourgeois-wannabes” are teaming up with thugs who scream in the faces of respected local clerics.

It is of course part of a desperate bid to get votes/relevance and keep their only MLA for North Belfast in a job by sucking up to the anti-Shinner wet-the-beds of the flock. I went to university with some SDLP voters and stalwarts, and behind closed and candid doors they always seemed to consider the dissident lot a  lasting embarrassment to this part of the world. I remember one staunch SDLP-voter telling me he would happily have all of them interned without trial.

For all the attention GARC draw to the injustice suffered by dissident republican prisoners in Maghaberry, and there are things which need to be addressed there, they are more than prepared to get behind the rotten zealots who allowed for discriminatory legislation against the employment of republican ex-prisoners. They are more than willing to garner support for a political party which has actively tried to cut off funding and resources to groups and organisations which help all republicans in the community, regardless of their stance on the peace agreements. It’s a really rather stinking move to get into bed with the very same people who couldn’t care less about the physical, social and psychological well-being of republican voters.

You can tell a lot about someone, not just by what they stand for, but by who they stand with when the times get tough. The fact is, the eejits in GARC are signing themselves up to be used and abused by the very people who will cut them loose once they get past the post on polling day. They’re squandering their votes on candidates who look down their noses at them and who for the most part wouldn’t want to live in the working-class areas they ask to elect them.

I’ve been called lots of colourful things by GARC associates and it really just serves to highlight that they can’t have mature political discussion without resorting to abusive antics. At the same time I don’t doubt that there are some decent people in that organisation. And to them I would put a few simple questions. Who genuinely serves your interests? Whose lot and destiny is tied up with yours? Who lives and works in the same community as you? Who has children and grandchildren in the same schools as you? Who has family and friends requiring welfare protections like you? Who goes to the same doctors and hospitals as you? Who watches the same television programmes and vacations at the same holiday resorts as you? Who has the same income levels as you?

So, do you really think the shady Redmondites of the SDLP share the same social-class and electoral interests as you do? Honestly? We often talk of turkeys voting for an early Christmas but in this case it’s more like Rangers opting for another visit by the auditors.

18 Responses to ‘The SDLP & GARC: A Political Marriage or Electoral Divorce?’ by Eugene Meenan

  1. michael c January 12, 2017 at 4:24 pm #

    In my own area ,a dissident wannabe wrote a letter to the Irish News attacking SF.The thrust of the letter was SF’S electoral thrashing of another candidate who foolishly thought he could take on SF’s massive South Derry electoral machine.This letter attacked SF using all the usual disso cliches and was probably an embarrassment to the defeated “independent” candidate.However a few days later an SDLP candidate decided to congratulate the “letter writer” in person for “doing a good job”in doing down the shinners.Unfortunately so out of touch was the stoop in question( they have no roots in Republican communities at all) that he “congratulated” a man with no connection to the letter at all.The man had a similar name to the letter writer and was perplexed at the adulation poured upon him by the stoop!

  2. fiosrach January 12, 2017 at 4:40 pm #

    ……….. shady Redmondites ……… on a par with the ‘continuity RUC’. Worth every penny that we should be paying you,jude.

  3. Robin Percival (@RobinPercival2) January 12, 2017 at 5:14 pm #

    Strange blog, Jude. As someone who has some knowledge and for awhile involvement in the parading issue in Ardoyne, there is aboslutely no evidence of the SDLP and GARC working together. The SDLP reps, including Nichola Mallon to whom you make indirect reference were very clear that they endorsed CARA and not GARC.

    I agree the SDLP in the past have done some stupid things, not least their support of Jim Allister’s attack on ex prisoners. But if we are going to criticise them lets do so on the basis of the policies they endorse and the things they have done (or not done). But’s let cut out the innuendo and out-of-date- labels. Does any one really care about Redmond in this day and age? Lets have a proper political argument and not scurrilous tale bearing,

    • Jude Collins January 12, 2017 at 7:08 pm #

      ” to whom you make indirect reference” – not so, Robin. Eugene is the writer, not me.

      • Robin Percival (@RobinPercival2) January 13, 2017 at 9:32 am #

        Sorry, Jude. My mistake!

    • Argenta January 12, 2017 at 10:56 pm #

      Robin
      Can I congratulate you on your fair and balanced post ,something we don’t see a lot of in many of the responses on this blogspot.Perhaps someone can enlighten us on the background of the author of the main blog?Can it be assumed that he’s a Sinn Fein member with an axe to grind in North Belfast?

  4. MT January 12, 2017 at 5:55 pm #

    ” discriminatory legislation against the employment of republican ex-prisoners.”

    There is no such legislation.

    • Jude Collins January 12, 2017 at 7:10 pm #

      Maybe you should ask republican ex-prisoners, MT. I have an inkling they may beg to differ.

      • MT January 12, 2017 at 7:15 pm #

        “Maybe you should ask republican ex-prisoners, MT. I have an inkling they may beg to differ.”

        If they did, they’d be wrong.

        • Gearóid January 12, 2017 at 7:40 pm #

          Mind made up there MT. I’m sure it’s galling to be on the losing side, you have my deepest simpathy and understanding, we nationalists know only too well the feeling. Tiocfaidh ar lá

          • MT January 12, 2017 at 7:50 pm #

            “Mind made up there MT. I’m sure it’s galling to be on the losing side, you have my deepest simpathy and understanding, we nationalists know only too well the feeling. Tiocfaidh ar lá”

            Sorry but I’ve no idea what you’re talking about.

  5. Gearóid January 12, 2017 at 8:14 pm #

    As I’ve suspected for along time now MT, you are totally deluded.

    • MT January 12, 2017 at 8:42 pm #

      “As I’ve suspected for along time now MT, you are totally deluded.”

      I’m not totally deluded. In fact, I’m not deluded at all.

      If you lack the ability to engage in mature discussion, I suggest that you stick to reading the comments only.

      • Wolfe tone January 13, 2017 at 11:23 am #

        “I’m not totally deluded. In fact, I’m not deluded at all.”

        Have you any evidence of this?

        • Pointis January 13, 2017 at 8:37 pm #

          Lol Wolfe Tone, best reposte of the year so far!

  6. Gearóid January 12, 2017 at 9:19 pm #

    MT, you’re some boy to be talking about mature discussion. Really?
    You are the archetypical copy and paster. You give one word answers to genuine answers and you have that arrogance that seems to be a disease of fundamental unionism.

    I don’t deny it MT, I am genuinely entertained by your simple interactions, please don’t stop.

    Time and again you have been asked by Jessica and others to give an in depth comment on YOUR feelings and YOUR take on the whole subject of the partition of this part of Ireland, unionism, misrule, criminality, equality, fairness, the OO, to name but a few. Time and again you revert to a lazy copy and paste interaction with a one or two word contribution from your own thoughts.

    I clearly do not lack the ability to engage in mature discussion, however I do like reading the comments and will continue to do so, whether or not it pleases you.

  7. Gearóid January 12, 2017 at 10:41 pm #

    No reply MT? Thought not!

  8. Michael Coogan January 13, 2017 at 8:32 pm #

    Eugene can you explain the timing of this article. I am a former Sinn Fein Councillor and resigned in 2012 due to continued sabotage of local Sinn Fein initiatives. Ref- Down Recorder Nov 2012. I don’t wet the bed, speak for GARC and certainly not the sdlp. I would take issue with some of your comments though because I believe they are about securing votes for Sinn Fein for the worst of reasons.
    If Sinn Fein can’t get votes on their policies and actions they don’t deserve them. To have a succession of side kicks attack the competition rather than print it on their own web sites is both typical and cowardly. Stand on merit or don’t stand at all.
    As for GARC cosying up with the sdlp, I suspect both know exactly what they’re doing, but let’s take them at face value and imagine they are representing the views of a significant number of people in Ardoyne. Face value because that’s what your asking them to do with Sinn Fein, they have a job to do and I would imagine it is slightly more palatable to cosy up to the sdlp than the orange order, PSNI and the DUP.
    Bringing the relationship between the sdlp and the Catholic Church in to it is relevant in the past tense only, because Sinn Fein have now assumed the position. Blessed are the peace makers and that great bastion of support for Republicans of any ilk over the course of history. Dee Fennell had a go at the priest, So What. Many a Sinn Fein Councillor, member has done exactly the same and worse over the years and rightly so.
    I don’t think anyone from GARC is suddenly going to start voting for the sdlp because they stood near each other at a protest. The sdlp have opposed Republicans for years, I’ll grant you that but the real tragedy now is that Sinn Fein are doing exactly the same. You went to school with some sdlp stalwarts who said they’d happily see republicans interned. I sat on a Council and worked in Stormont with Sinn Fein elected reps and members who said exactly the same thing.
    I questioned the use of the word criminal to describe Republicans. I questioned the use of the word traitors to describe republicans and I asked how I was supposed to criticise local republicans as either criminals or traitors when I and the community they lived in knew they weren’t.
    It is a really rather stinking move to get in to bed with the very same people who couldn’t care less about the physical, social and psychological wellbeing of republican voters. Seriously Eugene, seriously. Sinn Fein have been doing that for years now and they acknowledged their own failed strategy last week. The voters know it too and they’re sick to death of it, actually ashamed of it. Ashamed that the people they put their trust in continually bent over to the DUP.
    I’m not suggesting the sdlp are any better, in fact I can still just about manage to say they’re worse because they did for 30 odd years what Sinn Fein have been doing for the past ten years at least.
    The sdlp do look down their nose at GARC and really anyone who isn’t one of their own, but I’ve news for you, so do Sinn Fein. They dismiss any criticism as dissident, they refuse to engage constructively in what was once their home ground and just because they’ve copped on to that this week it doesn’t mean they will be instantly forgiven.
    They needed to win the middle class in order to take the big votes, we all know it’s the middle class who vote. The working class you think Sinn Fein still come from gave up voting when they’re own people let them down. What Sinn Fein forgot when they sold their souls to win the middle class vote, was that vote is high maintenance and their support is conditional. The republicans left behind were the core vote, not any more or people like you wouldn’t be writing these articles trying to win them back. They’ve forgotten where they came from.