Constitutional parties and mergers

Is Sinn Féin a nationalist party? It’s a republican party but it’s also a nationalist party, in that it aims for Irish reunification through peaceful means. The Belfast Telegraph appears  to think the Shinners are not constitutional nationalists: having considered that party’s surge in the election results, the Telegraph’s editorial two days ago added “Constitutional nationalism did well, and SDLP leader Colum Eastwood has built a solid base.” Judging from its columnists over the last ten years, the Telegraph is a slow learner. But if “constitutional” equates with “non-violent”, Sinn Féin have been a constitutional party for at least twenty years now – some would argue longer.

The matter which seems in recent days to have preoccupied the thinking of Arlene Foster, leader of the constitutional DUP,  is the notion of a single Unionist party. Failing that, Arlene suggests   a pact between Unionist parties so that Unionism wins seats against nationalism of all stripes.

Is that a realistic proposal? It’s a possible one, although the UUP still lives with the dream of reversing its long decline and smashing the DUP. Let’s pretend, however, that the DUP and the UUP merge or form pacts in every electoral area. What would be the result?

Well, you’d have a much stronger Unionist vote total. Unionists here would have displayed their maximum electoral strength. Adding together the number of seats gained by the DUP and UUP, you’d get 38. But adding together Sinn Féin and SDLP votes, you’d get 39.

There are other variables, of course, such as whether Jim Allister would vote with the Unionist bloc, which would make it 39 each. And of course the Alliance, the Greens, PbP and so on.

But to come back to the key question: if the DUP and the UUP were one or acted as one party, how would the SDLP react? Like the UUP, they’re jealous of their own identity and would fear being swamped by the Shinners. But if they didn’t respond with a water-tight electoral pact at least, to match that of unionism, the SDLP would be in danger of being seen as the prop of unionism here. Not a particularly glowing function for a constitutional nationalist party.

14 Responses to Constitutional parties and mergers

  1. cushy glen March 8, 2017 at 11:23 am #

    Strange phrase ‘constitutional nationalism’. Would love to know who thought that one up. Not anyone on this island I suspect.

    Whose constitution?

    What constitution makes protest & opposition to those in power illegal?

    Considering that the Irish state & it’s subsequent constitution arose out of a violent uprising we’re on tricky ground here.

    Even British barons rose up against their monarch to create Magna Carta & later a bunch of commoners beheaded a king to establish a ‘constitutional monarchy’.

    Let’s drop this ‘constitutional’ bullshit.

  2. joe bloggs March 8, 2017 at 11:35 am #

    Yes – people are forgetting about TUV and the Alliance in the “Unionist Minority” line. I am pretty sure Jim Allister is relatively sound on the constitution and you never tire of telling us that the Alliance are, in fact, a (u)nionist party. For the latter, the decisions of the house (if it gets back up and running) and how it votes, or indeed if it votes (the abstention hand can only be used sparingly without being seen as a cop out) will have a huge impact on its large (u)nionist voter base. While there is an opportunity for the Alliance to help pass legislation that is to the benefit of all people in NI (its MO) – if it votes with nationalism, or abstains and causes a potential stalemate, those middle class (u)nionists who are happy to vote for Naomi in the spirit of moving our society forward, may decide to switch from being “(u)nionists”, back to being full blooded (and warm blooded ?) Unionists.

    Naomi Long may not be so steady walking that tightrope.

    • Oz 2015 March 8, 2017 at 2:29 pm #

      Oh Dear,
      Now you are threatening the alliance party.
      Or at least trying to threaten them. Don’t do as we ask and we won’t vote for ya.

      I wondered how long it would take for unionists to start on the Bonar Law.
      With the “things mightier than a parliamentary majority” type of line.
      Turns out… Not very long at all.

      • joe bloggs March 8, 2017 at 4:07 pm #

        I think you are seeing “threats” when there aren’t any. An observation on how circumstances might affect another of the political parties (a bit like the author of the blog is doing in his post).

        I think your pavlovian response says more about your hatred of all things and people Unionist than anything else.

  3. pjdorrian March 8, 2017 at 11:43 am #

    On a related matter, have you noticed how Nolan in the last two days has been pursuing ,”Does any party have the right to determine another party’s leader.”?
    One would almost think he was asking for forgiveness from DUP for his chasing up RHI.
    Speaking of which about 3 weeks ago he made a big song and dance over his team getting the names of those on this benefit. Last week a judge said it was grand to publish the names. No mention from Nolan about the names this week. One would almost think BBC was protecting someone or some party.

    • Michael March 8, 2017 at 3:54 pm #

      One party does not have the right to determine another party’s leader.
      However the party leader does not have to be appointed FM.
      SF and SDLP have said they will not go into government with Arlene nominated as first minister until after the RHI investigation. There’s nothing stopping the DUP from nominating someone else.

  4. meh March 8, 2017 at 11:58 am #

    as a firm believer of ” Satyagraha ” I wonder with all respect to MMG does the dimming of the shadow of the gunman in SF make the party more palatable to non-violent supporting Nationalists to vote for? Can that reason other than “crocodiles” partly account for the 3.9% increase in their vote? The Children of Holy Cross are now of an age to vote. They are also part of the age cohort coming along that out number the PUL community, it’s not the number of unionist parties that is their problem, it’s their ever diminishing number of voters, listening to talkback yesterday they still seem to be failing to grasp this fact & at basic maths, no wonder RHI..

  5. Perkin Warbeck March 8, 2017 at 12:20 pm #

    ON the VERGE of a MERGE ?

    Constitutional is, of course, long for con
    Which d’Stoops, oops, SDLP, lean upon
    Let blonde Michelle
    Ponder long ‘n well
    In the beauty salon this dangerous liaison.

  6. Patrick Fahy March 8, 2017 at 12:25 pm #

    Was interesting listening to Nolan being put on the back foot this morning. He asked Jim a caller from West Belfast if he was a member of Sinn Fein. Jim turned the question on him asking if he Nolan was a member of the DUP. Nolan was momentarily flummoxed and then hesitatingly said ‘ I don’t disclose which party……. Nolan had earlier been pressing Jim as to why Arlene should stand down when no Sinn Fein minister had ever done so in the past. Nolan of course knew the answer -,that no Sinn Fein minister had ever presided over a department where a scandalous waste of money had occurred as in Arlene’s case in the RHI debacle. Yet he persisted and persisted until it became boring.

    • billy March 8, 2017 at 12:48 pm #

      they have been drawing 17,million in wages a year for the last 10 years and achieved nothing.far more that has been spent so far on rhi so they are all guilty of waste.they should all step down.

  7. TheHist March 8, 2017 at 1:11 pm #

    Mr Wells, DUP MLA, just a few days back referred to Sinn Fein as “Militant Republicans” in response to the party asking Arleen Foster to step aside in the formation of a new Executive. He said ” “We can’t allow militant republicans to dictate who is our leader or the first minister. If you allow Sinn Fein to do that you are setting a very dangerous precedent for the future.”

  8. Ryan March 8, 2017 at 1:19 pm #

    Unionists may love the idea of Unionist Unity between the DUP/UUP at first (even though it wont make any difference at all in the current Assembly make up, it wont make a Unionist majority for example) but its a very difficult thing to create. There’s a reason why many different Unionist parties exist because many different Unionists exist. Some Unionists aren’t economic conservatives, some want to reach out to Republicans, some are deeply opposed to power sharing with Republicans, etc.

    Trying to unite all these differences would be extremely difficult. Those Unionists who champion Unionist Unity solely want it to happen on constitutional grounds but in reality it wouldn’t make much difference. The Assembly Elections, for example, used transferable votes, Unionists could already vote for every Unionist candidate standing and many did. So would 1 Unionist party have made a difference in last weeks election? I don’t think so because the reality is many Unionists voted the way they wanted and, in the likes of Lagan Valley, transferred and got Nationalists (SDLP) elected over another Unionist. That’s how they WANTED to vote. Some Unionist voters wont be dictated to by the DUP/UUP.

    The Newsletters Sam McBride said of Unionist Unity under 1 party: “It would look like Unionisms Last Stand”. Indeed it would. And not only that, it wouldn’t even change much except form new divisions within Unionism (watch people leave the DUP/UUP and form new parties, will TUV/UKIP join this new United Unionist party? etc) and scare off many SDLP/Alliance transfers that usually went to the UUP.

    Unionist Unity not as good as it sounds for Unionists.

  9. Kevin March 8, 2017 at 2:11 pm #

    Jude, you say that `Judging from its columnists over the last ten years, the Telegraph is a slow learner.’ Would it have been appropriate for you to acknowledge that you were among the Telegraph columnists who contributed to this slow learning process ?

  10. Dominic Hendron March 8, 2017 at 6:00 pm #

    I hear the rugby fraternity are up in arms,someone has stolen the wooden spoon. For what purpose is anyone’s guess.