What Jim and Arlene said about the BBC

Jim Wells was unambiguous in his condemnation of the BBC during the recent election campaign, claiming it had bombarded Arlene  Foster with relentless criticism   over the weeks of  the campaign. He voiced his criticism on-air to William Crawley, I think it was. The presenter mildly pointed out that the BBC seeks balance and would not have skewed things against the DUP leader. Jim Wells later said he regretted his criticism – not that he hadn’t been trenchant enough, but that he should have been far more excoriating.  In the leaders’ debate, Arlene Foster as good as told Noel Thompson that the BBC had stuffed the studio audience with her critics, a charge dismissed by Thompson with good humour.

It makes you wonder why they call it the British Broadcasting Corporation, if Wells and Foster were right.

I know from experience of  making programmes in the BBC that what people sometimes see as lopsided or even biased choices by the Corporation  are often taken on totally other grounds – the length of the programme, the quality of the guests, the need for variety and contrast – lots of reasonable reasons.

That said, a friend has just pointed out to me that the BBC’s TalkBack  today devoted over an hour to the question of unionist unity.  Which is a reasonable choice of topic, you’d think. After all, unionists have just had a very poor election vis-a-vis republicans/nationalists. But, my friend noted, when the DUP won the election last May and gained ten more seats than Sinn Féin, the BBC didn’t devote an hour of  TalkBack to a discussion of the need for nationalist/republican unity. I can’t remember if my friend is right but I’d feel safe in having a small bet that he is.

I wouldn’t necessarily put that down to a bias towards unionism by the BBC. Obviously Jim Wells and Arlene Foster think it’s quite the other way. And before someone says it, the fact that the BBC comes in for criticism from both sides of the house does not mean they’re impartial, any more than a parent beating his/her son is OK if  if he/she also beats his/her daughter .

My experience is that the most effective kind of censorship in the BBC is self-censorship. It is  indeed the British Broadcasting Corporation and so it naturally presents events from a British establishment point of view. It would be rather odd if it didn’t.  That perspective, for better or worse, becomes internalised by those who work there.  I would guess that uppermost in most producers’ and presenters’ minds is not a bias one way or the other, but  a concern for a successful and well-built programme. That doesn’t mean those same programmes will be anything other than in keeping with the British Broadcasting Corporation’s code and values. Which is unfortunate for that part of the population which considers itself Irish rather than British.

A final thought: while I have my criticisms of the BBC, I’ve experience of television in Canada and the United States. Believe me, the BBC is to be cherished in contrast with the output across the Atlantic.

Here is a link to a report by Professor John Robertson, of University of the West of Scotland, about media coverage of the Scottish independence referendum. It’s worth taking the time to read.

https://thoughtcontrolscotland.files.wordpress.com/2015/08/propagandascotlandreferendum2014.pdf

And here is an hour-long video involving Prof Robertson again, on the same topic…

19 Responses to What Jim and Arlene said about the BBC

  1. billy March 7, 2017 at 2:30 pm #

    you wouldnt have had the election only for the bbc is another way to look at it.not that it changed anything.

  2. pjdorrian March 7, 2017 at 2:36 pm #

    I tuned in to TB at 12.20 and turned it off at 12.25. I dare say the other 55 mins was as dismal as the 5 I listened to. It did seem a surprise that they would devote a whole hour to this kind of sectarianism, yes sectarianism.
    I’m old enough to remember a unified unionist government, talk about a cold house for Fenians, it was a no house for Fenians .
    I imagine this new movement is a harking back to their ‘good’ old days. Fuck all open on Sunday, park swings padlocked, public park gates padlocked and everywhere undiluted discrimination again the Taigs. Let’s hope if another election is called in Three weeks we can get the non unionist vote out again.
    Btw, where are those names of people on the RHIs?

  3. paddykool March 7, 2017 at 3:41 pm #

    Unionism is in new territory for the first time so there is some novelty in that situation which the listening public might want unpicked and studied, which is a possible reason for giving it a little time on air. It’s a fact that nationalism and specifically republicanism have made a good enough argument to finally win enough voters to almost equal the unionists’ heft. They will eventually surpass even that I’d imagine . They started from an imposed position of weakness that had been mathematically worked out county by county to make sure that unionism would have its own precious little state.It was the ultimate hustle by the British government and it presented nationalists with a steep hill to climb over practically one hundred years .It has been a long climb and some of us have lived through most of the stages.Anyone in their sixties or seventies now would have seen the the state properly braced first in the 1960s.Even then it could seemingly do whatever it liked to do and it was at this point where it began to assault it s own citizens live on television.
    This latest little uproar for unionism was coming for a long time these past forty years and was unavoidable given the logistics .Now they talk of coalitions and the nostalgia of monolithic unionism of old, as though it was in their gift. Nationalism is simply a bigger beast now.It is the natural growth and the natural way of things that this might be so. the trend has been flagged -up but has been ignored by unionism who still maintain the mantra that there is no change. Well no matter what some will mutter , there have been great changes.
    How could Jim Allister(TUV) at one extreme end and someone like Steve Aiken (UUP) at the other end , agree on policy? Jim Allister doesn’t want to share power with republican candidates at all , which is frankly unavoidable, by all accounts and he hates the DUP for doing any such thing . Steve Aiken sounds like he would prefer a more genteel form of unionism , free of overt ,lurid ,fundamentalist protestantism.How could they join with the DUP ‘s narrow “vision” for a future here?
    In any case , voters would need to ask themselves in relation to Arlene Foster or any other future minister , just how open and accountable they might want them and their ministers to be .It seems to me that they want to give them(Arlene included) a free hand to do any damn thing they want to do. That’s not what I want from my ministers and MPs. i want them all to be accountable and without favour while balancing the books.
    The latest thing is to atttack the BBC as messanger of their ills..Can they really be serious? Arlene Foster deserved all of the scrutiny that she got from Nolan and others .Gerry Adams has been down that route too as far as scrutiny went , but he wasn’t running a department that was wasting millions of our money. It ‘s as old and as hoary as that …They want to shoot the messenger who brings the bad news.That’s all .I wonder just how long they will huff with the press.It strikes me they are going the Trump route and are busily painting black crows ,white to suit their own agenda.Project Fear indeed!.

  4. Perkin Warbeck March 7, 2017 at 7:54 pm #

    RTE in Donnybrook, Dublin Postal Division 4, Esteemed Blogmeister, seems to see itself as the Development Squad for the Gods in the Premier League of the BBC.

    From the likes of the Leprechaun-loathing Edward, oops, Eamonn Andrews to Sir Terry Woebegone it has always been the lambent ambition of their succubuses, oops, successors to follow in the walking- backwards footsteps of their beady Antecedes.

    Sadly, there has been something of a steep decline in the number of RTE superstars who make it to the Big Time accross the water. First we had the truly sorry spectacle of Gay Byrne westering home with his economies of scale between his ego.

    Next, after Ryanairing east every weekend, his wooden protege, Tubridy, has been finally grounded in the shallow spoonerisms of the League of Airland.

    AUNTIE’S NICELY-NICELY NIECE

    RTE treats the BBC with all due deference
    As befits a team of the Vauxhall Conference
    Gay’s protege Tubs
    No more in the subs
    From these losers to SF more intolerance.

  5. michael c March 7, 2017 at 9:18 pm #

    SF reps getting more “earthy” in their responses these days and what a welcome development it is.I like my public reps to sound like the rest of us and roared with laughter when Michele Gildernew responded “jaysus it’s brilliant” to a question about how she viewed the election results.(that interview was on SF twitter).Then today Conor Murphy retorted to Nolan this morning – “Maybe you’ll allow me to answer the bloody question”!.

    • paddykool March 8, 2017 at 8:31 am #

      That’s been noticed alright michael…Not to mention reference to nailing Brokenshire’s “waffle” yesterday…maybe we’ll get some straight talking in the future and hopefully Sinn Fein will remember just why they have been elected.

  6. slanlot March 7, 2017 at 10:58 pm #

    Sinn Fein’s testicles are under going a rapid growth phase .

    • giordanobruno March 7, 2017 at 11:50 pm #

      slanlot
      There does appear to be a different tone to statements from SF now.
      Not aggressive exactly but more confident maybe.
      That is to be expected and maybe it will bring positive results but they should be careful not to overplay their hand I think
      If they come across as saying ‘now its our turn to be bastards’ that will only alienate those they still need to persuade.
      Nothing has been won yet.

      • Jude Collins March 8, 2017 at 10:58 am #

        “Nothing has been won yet.” – Discuss.

        • gendjinn March 8, 2017 at 4:04 pm #

          Unionism has lost. Nationalism will win soon enough. Within five years.

          • giordanobruno March 8, 2017 at 11:31 pm #

            So you agree then.

  7. Brian March 7, 2017 at 11:01 pm #

    I’m working in London this week and listened on iplayer radio to talkback show. I’ve no doubt there was no similar show last year about nationalist unity but the fact that unionism is now a minority for the first time in the history of the state leads me to believe I’d be surprised if they didn’t discuss it. This is a real news story that I want to hear unionist reaction to. The Nolan show earlier in the morning was again disgraceful, tabloid radio.

  8. Am Ghobsmacht March 8, 2017 at 1:49 am #

    Tv in north America (and Australia and NZ) is borderline unwatchable.

    My granny used to think it was run by communists. I’d happily listen to Soviet propaganda for an hour a day if it means I can keep the beeb.

    As for the DUP, who’s left to blame? Themselves? Sorry, i lost the run of myself fir a minute, obviously it was the lundies…

    • paddykool March 8, 2017 at 8:42 am #

      It is a curiousity Am Ghob that the DUP have single-handedly done more to de-stabilise Norneverland than any other party in the historical record.The fact that they do not even realise how they achieved the feat is almost a bonus really.Their multi-thousand pound advertising punt for Brexit in the UK , just to prove how Little Englander they enjoy being perceived ,will eventually do them no favours when they go looking for some money to rreplace the 75% lost from the EU fund for their farming community in Fermanagh and find the till closed tight .Then the cry from Buckinghamshire and Essex will be ,”Who are these beggars?”

      • Am Ghobsmacht March 8, 2017 at 11:25 pm #

        Harry its like watching a man who doesn’t realise that he’s on fire trying to fill up his car in a petrol station.

        • paddykool March 9, 2017 at 7:26 pm #

          Now there’s an image alright!

    • Am Ghobsmacht March 8, 2017 at 11:26 pm #

      Sorry, when i say ‘it’ I mean the BBC. Or communist BBC as granny used to call it…

  9. gendjinn March 8, 2017 at 4:01 pm #

    “Believe me, the BBC is to be cherished in contrast with the output across the Atlantic.”

    Breaking Bad. Mr Robot. Game of Thrones. Penny Dreadful. Legion. The Expanse. The Americans. Better Call Saul. The Shield. The Magicians. 12 Monkeys. American Crime. Band of Brothers.

    What original dramatic programming has the BBC produced in the last 5 years that even begins to compare to that list? Shameless?

    The BBC is an overpriced, overpaid imperial propaganda outlet and part time paedophile ring. But sure if we utter anything but praise for the BBC they’ll never invite us back on again, will they?

    • Am Ghobsmacht March 8, 2017 at 11:20 pm #

      I don’t think he means the cream, rather the median and the presentation e.g. adverts every 10mins, adverts rotating in the foreground while you’re watching a program and when one program ends another one starts immediately only to go into break three minutes later. I managed to watch the movie Oblivion and it took nearly 3
      hours, its a 2hr movie…

      Plus the BBC is the foundation of British comedy. I’ve listened to north American comedy channels; aside from Chappelle’ hicks, Wright, Leary and a few others they are pale compared to the British and Irish stand up comedians (most of whom depend on the BBC for their living).